Remix.run Logo
▲ seiferteric 20 hours ago

I am trying to understand something about the economy and AI. If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way (initially anyway)? What I mean is, if you had an industry that was worth say $1 billion, but now that same industry could be automated and done cheaply then it is no longe worth $1 billion? In some ways this is beneficial to the economy in that has reduced the cost of this industry and so customers see a benefit of cheaper products, but how would it benefit say AI companies since they are not capturing a $1 billion industry, but instead sort of destroying a $1 billion industry? I am mainly looking at this from the perspective of the value of an AI company.. If they just keep commoditizing industries and there is ample competition between AI companies, then how is the AI company capturing value such that they would be worth as much money as people are saying they are worth (trillions of dollars)? I know that there is more to this, like freeing up this money and labor could lead to new industries etc., but how much of this will actually go to AI companies?

▲LarsDu88 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Over the long term the economy will grow. That I am 100% confident of. When you take previously scarce resources and commoditize them, the knock on effects tend to spread widely. Intelligence and automation used to be enormously expensive, and now they are becoming cheaper by the day. Right now, frontier LLMs, which I consider wildly inefficient can give you mostly functional blueprints and diagrams for working products, like basic electronics on top of the image generation and code generation that is increasingly being commoditized.

The goods and services built atop "tech" should start to become cheaper as well. For knowledge workers this is terrible, but for consumers, this is great. I think folks worrying about an economic collapse are only looking at this from the perspective of knowledge workers and not from the much larger population of consumers.

The effect on the AI companies with pure competition is to make them basically worthless unless they find ways of stifling competition. For example by banning open weight AI in the name of safety, forming a global monopoly, buying up all the RAM capacity in the world, etc. All of this stuff is going on right now.

The value is there. The true question is whether the wealth will be concentrated and captured or released and distributed. I'm in the camp the likely outcome is actually the former. A huge amount of the wealth of AI has not really been unlocked yet... consumer robotics, disease cures, universal constructor type machines. Furthermore, once we reach superintelligence, eventually someone will inevitably fuck up by letting the dam break by ablitering a model in the wrong way. This will give governments and companies rationale to lock up the best AI to develop frontier level IP.

▲dmz73 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Everyone here is focused on software development/IT which is not surprising. But "AI" is not displacing only IT, it is displacing all service jobs. Only jobs that currently cannot be replaces are manual labor and some trades...and you only need relatively few plumbers, electricians and hairdressers, specially when most people do not have an income. So most of the current workforce will have little to no income and therefore no money for most of those new products, even if they are now abundant and cheap.

▲consp 43 minutes ago | parent [-]

Considering no llm assisted chatbot has ever helped me and problems were easily solved after getting in touch with a human, we have a very long way to go. Those things are not worth the money and customers hate them.

▲tosapple 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm trying to follow your logic fairly and completely, but I'm not sure it's a good idea to have such a sterile view of 'consumer'.

To be a consumer, and participate in a market, one needs liquidity.

If consumers have nothing to offer that is fresh to the market, their resources will drain.

Labor and Knowledge Services, are 'fresh' to the market at the point of sale.

If you take that away you have nothing, what do you propose the human do?

It's the same architecture as buying from communist China.

It will likely codify the assetted class, imo.

▲chii 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> If consumers have nothing to offer

they will always have something to offer (it doesn't need to be "fresh"), just usable. Their labour or body, for example. And it's not like AI can automate every possible job - jobs like toilet cleaning, and a lot of service/hospitality work is hard/impossible to automate (at least in the medium term - may be long term we will all be served by androids).

The influx of labour from the (now redundant) high skilled professions means you now can have cheaper labour for all these services.

> codify the asset class

this has and always will be the case in a capitalist market. Unless you propose revolution (of the communist kind).

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲joedwin 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲FunkyMushroom 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The related economic concept here is the Broken Window Fallacy. Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy, because there's an opportunity cost doing to anything. And replacing the need to "fix broken windows" or do now-AI-automated work would free up that opportunity cost. Which is how it's worked for nearly all automation. (Though Computers are subject to long running debate about this. See the Solow Productivity Paradox)

The gigawatt-sized asterisk on all of this is that AI companies have to capture that $1 billion. Anthropic has to ten-fold increase it's revenues or it goes bankrupt under it's current commitments. It has to increase it's revenues another 10 times to reach the $10,000,000,000,000/yr revenue required to support it's current valuation.

Anthropic put their Total Addressable Market at 35% of Global GDP (~$40 trillion/yr). They're planning to capture all of the money.

The second gigawatt-sized asterisk is that because of the fine handiwork of Mr. Huang, China has made very competitive AI models available for free, so the actual ability for AI companies to capture the value of the labour they displace ends up being quite limited. Thus a problem in the predictions: Something as to break, but it is as of yet unclear what that will be. Maybe Chinese AI will be banned, maybe Anthropic & OpenAI go bankrupt.

▲cogman10 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The big issue with all this is that people whose jobs are destroyed by automation very rarely end up seeing improvements to their standard of living. And with the modern system, people are pretty boned if they chose the wrong career.

The luddite movement is informative here. When manufactures found ways to mass produce goods eliminating jobs left and right, the people in the skilled trades whose jobs were eliminated did not benefit in the slightest from the economic progress.

We now live in an era of diminishing jobs which provide livable wages. It's why so many economies have moved to require everyone to participate in the labor market just to achieve the basics.

Put more simply, broken windows harm society as a whole, but they do make glazers and the people who support the glazers happy. Now that we live in an era where a significant portion of the population is glazers so-to-speak and ai threatens to eliminate those jobs, it looks like the only path forward for those glazers is low wage jobs.

▲YZF 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

In the .com boom many people with degrees from other disciplines retrained for tech jobs. So the people who are (in theory) getting displaced here, like software engineers or mathematicians are also some of the most capable of filling other roles. So that's one thing. This is different from the industrial revolution where the people who got displaced were those doing the cheapest labour.

An economy is a complex system with feedback loops and equilibrium. Companies need consumers to make money. AI companies make money by selling AI to companies that make money by selling things to people or other companies. There is no economy in which nobody has a job and nobody buys anything and big tech makes money. So that is obviously not an equilibrium point. How exactly we get to an equilibrium and what that looks like is hard to predict and also depends on policy. Governments can employ more people. They can provide various incentives. And countries as a whole are somewhat self sustaining economies (some more and some less).

So... The world is not going to end (at least not from jobs going away). How even jobs and wealth are distributed depends to a large degree on policy but it has to be stable in many ways. Look at Russia? What sort of economy have they got compared to most western countries? A pretty sucky one. But people still largely have jobs and the country continues to function +/-.

▲marcus_holmes 15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I watched Thatcher destroy the UK mining industry. Whole communities wrecked, nothing to do there, no hope. I'm sure the US rust belt had the same experience under Reagan.

This happens routinely. It's just the first time that educated white-collar workers like us have had to experience it.

▲jvanderbot 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I got coffee with a nice person from HN today. They were wearing a hat with the word "Luddite" on it. I knew what it meant but asked anyway - yes it's not anti-tech, it's anti automation and loss of craft.

The thing about luddites is that yes they wanted to preserve human craftsmanship, and as you say it didn't work. John Henry died. Luddites worked in factories and declined into poverty. Hopeless. Doomed.

But, I am cranking down my personal backlog with AI tools, using them at work, and loving the usefulness of them. It doesn't feel like I'm a master weaver who has their work automated, it feels like I'm reaping productivity gains.

Was there ever a moment in the Luddite movement when some of them leaned in and had fun? Did some of John Henry's colleagues just really enjoy the new steam drivers?

It doesn't _feel_ like I'm being forced out of my trade. I sincerely doubt the Luddites had a moment where they happily shelled out the 1820 equivalent of $20/m to get access to a weaving machine. I'm not saying "this time is different", but I am saying everyone tells me to not use AI, and to be afraid, and I'm de-skilling or whatever, etc. How do we all _know_ what is right?

A loom does not bring agency. It takes it. But I feel like having a computer, access to LLM, increases my agency just a bit. It allows me to do more, not just do what I need to _faster_. It's not _just_ automation.

▲smallmancontrov 14 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

We could use a New Deal.

▲benrutter an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy, because there's an opportunity cost doing to anything

I know this is only a small bit of your overall point, but I don't think this is an accepted fact of economics.

The "opportunity" cost is true is you're comparing redundant work to productive work, but OP was comparing to unemployment, which is a different case. A bit of a simplification, but less employment leads to less spending which leads to less money to companies etc.

Here's a nice quote from Keynes about redundant work:

> If the Treasury were to fill old bottles with bank-notes, bury them at suitable depths in disused coal-mines which are then filled up to the surface with town rubbish, and leave it to private enterprise on well-tried principles of laissez-faire to dig the notes up again (the right to do so being obtained, of course, by tendering for leases of the note-bearing territory), there need be no more unemployment and, with the help of repercussions, the real income of the community, and its capital wealth, would probably become a good deal greater than it actually is.

▲lelanthran 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Maybe Chinese AI will be banned, maybe Anthropic & OpenAI go bankrupt.

Unless the entire world bans it, how would that help?

▲horsawlarway 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It wouldn't, it would just mire the US in an unproductive and isolationist quagmire - reducing our global competitiveness because every US company would be paying an "anthropic tax" for a service that competing countries access for much lower costs.

▲FunkyMushroom 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The absurdity is the point; The clear-cut ways to resolve the tension of "AI giants need pricing power but don't have it" are absurd (admittedly, the former much more so than the latter)

It's hard to predict an outcome "somewhere in between of two absurdities"

▲bryanlarsen 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If the US actually wanted a world-wide ban, it would probably happen.

Obviously we can't effectively ban already released models, but a ban on models with >10T parameters for instance, is quite feasible. It takes a ton of power to train and operate those, and infrared satellites can spot that.

I'm confident China would be very happy to sign on to a world wide ban.

1. AI is one of the only high tech areas where America is ahead of China. If AI is knee-capped, China would indisputably become the world leader in industrial tech and high tech.

2. China is releasing models as open-weight to commoditize the complements. A ban on 10T models would let them specialize and utilize the lower parameter models to extend their lead in areas like robotics.

And once the US & China signed on I'm sure Europe and the middle powers would quickly agree.

▲MSFT_Edging 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

This is such an interesting part of the whole AI equation.

The main benefit of the closed models is the regulatory control to say, insert guard rails against hacking things. That's also the main drawback as you now have handed control over this technology to a handful of companies, who will reap all the rewards of this captured sector.

It would be like the google/apple duopoly on steroids. Everyone forced to buy in to one of two ecosystems, with limited to no ability to undermine the duopoly via control of the device hardware. One can't make a real competitor because it requires access guarded by existing relationships and money. For the AI houses, it means you need approval from these groups to create in a competitive manner. That, IMO is too much power for an unelected organization to carry.

AI will likely only provide real benefits to humanity if it's open. But if it's open, it will also enable extreme harm in the form of cyber attacks, scams, and destruction of IP.

By keeping AI closed, it will bring a new form of imperialism. Instead of the core maintaining IP and the periphery suffering the secondary effects of industry, the core will maintain the capability and the periphery will be locked out of competition due to silly nation-state rivalries. This won't benefit humanity, it will lock us into the same cycle of misery for marginal gains measured in stock values.

So there's two ways AI can reasonably go: Cyber punk corporate overlords or cyber anarchy due to the inability to put a cork on the genie's bottle.

Both seem terrible to me. What good is space travel without freedom? What good is automation if there are incentives to maintain profit over stability? What good is the technology if any usage of it exposes you to fraud, violence, and blackmail at any moment?

Big fans of LLMs never ask "to what end?", they repeat shallow near term "wows" without considering the second and third order effects. "wow think about how good LLMs can spot cancer in scans!", great! but who will afford the scan without work? Will the overlords commit to luxury gay space communism? Or will they simply say "tough luck" and let that cancer fester?

Real AGI is incompatible with our current power structures, yet those current power structures desire the AGI. This cannot end well. Stagnation and stability would be preferable to the level of misery that would follow.

▲blobbers 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Sorry can you clarify the 10T revenue part? Apple makes about 0.5T revenue and has 5X the valuation. Pricing on revenue multiple you’d say anthropic needs 100B in revenue, which at 16B last quarter isn’t too far fetched.

▲bryanlarsen 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Apple's P/S above 10 is incredibly high. It reflects high margins, monopoly power, network effects and users with high switching costs. So it's probably not unjustified for Apple.

Anthropic has high margins and is working on the others but hasn't achieved them yet. It's margins are threatened as it and competitors are lowering prices regularly. P/S for commodity producers is well under 1. But lets assume tokens don't completely commoditize so a P/S of 1 is justified.

That's $1T. But Anthropic doesn't have $1T in revenue yet, and it's risky due to spending commitments. So you have to discount for both time and risk. That's where the other order of magnitude comes from.

▲FunkyMushroom 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm very loosely using a 10x multiplier. So a 1 trillion valuation -> 10 trillion revenue.

The standard P/S ratios apply to established companies, but Anthropic is not that. The current valuation is not based on the material state of the company, but on future projections.

It's not just enough to have enough revenue to "justify $1T value", there needs to be massive growth in it to justify the risks.

▲MiroslavPokorny 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

How many billions did Anthropic lose ?

▲cowlevel 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What if the opportunity cost is zero because all useful work is being done?

▲raducu 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Broken Window Fallacy. Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy.

The problem with AI is that work on an unprecedented scale will be made redundant and economic power will be concentrated into the hands of very few and there will be no way out in perpetuity.

▲hobo123 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Being able to buy massive intelligence for cheap (or running open weights on your own HW) doesn't give you economic power? Only if you don't use that power to provide something useful to others.

▲LogicFailsMe 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That seems to be what US leaders want, but the other 96% of the world thinks differently.

▲andsoitis 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You don’t know that.

▲nullsanity 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

How? A full server of GH200s is half a mil. That runs GLM5.3 Prime and Delegate Flash models.

Half a million, in 2026, is a lot for me and you, but pennies for even a modest sized business. And this is before prices go down.

Ive been using 9b models on my 4090 for coding and command tasks for over a year now. It's great! You obviously can't be like "Use huge framework and context, and just make me an app" but you can be like "Employee said vpn is running slow. Follow the process documented here: X to diagnose and propose a fix" where X is docs written by a Chinese model for 10 cents.

▲SoftTalker 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> China has made very competitive AI models available for free,

Is this a "commoditize your competitors" strategy when your motive isn't profit but disruption?

▲HWR_14 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Did you mean "commoditize your compliments"? The textbook example would be NVDIA giving away free AI models.

What you are probably referencing is "dumping". That's when you sell undercost to disrupt your competitors.

That may be why. Certainly the motivation of the CCP is supporting it isn't short term financial gain. But it's probably more about maintaining independence from a dependence on US AI long term than dominating the AI industry.

But I think it was originally just a side project to keep quants interested.

▲retwakm4 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I am a big believer in the solow paradox and I don't think AI changes anything about it. Just more money down the tubes.

Go read the papers on it if you want to hear some of the immensely plausible theories as to why micros and the internet and all sorts of what we think is technological innovation doesn't show up in economic productivity data.

▲mkarliner 8 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Maybe banned in the US. Which would put the US at a competitive disadvantage to say, Europe.

Of course, we have total faith and trust in the US and it's companies, so would never think of buying tech from elsewhere.

Clever strategy, please work on it right now.

▲smallmancontrov 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The Broken Window "Fallacy" assumes that distributional problems don't exist, lol.

I know why rich people who own many shares of aggregate economic capacity want me to believe that it is the only important thing and that sacrificing aggregate capacity to fix distributional problems is never worthwhile. But I don't believe it. The industrial revolution was gnarly with unnecessary distribution problems that ensured crippling poverty for the masses amid extraordinary leaps in aggregate capacity. This time around I don't want a century of Cyberpunk Oliver Twist before the peons are allowed a dignified life.

Adjacent, improved argument: taxes are a better fix for distributional problems than throwing stones at windows. I agree, and I will add that broken windows are a better fix for distributional problems than guillotines. I really really hope that we can convince capital to pay taxes because that's the only future where things don't go to monumental shit before getting better.

▲randomNumber7 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> The industrial revolution was gnarly with unnecessary distribution problems that ensured crippling poverty for the masses

Which basically only changed when people fought for their rights

> I really really hope that we can convince capital to pay taxes

I sadly can't see that happening without ww3

▲roncesvalles 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Exactly. Let's say there was one guy in the world who owned 99% of all the wealth. Is it really a bad idea to break his window so that he may disburse some money on getting it fixed?

Now, let's say the handyman whom the rich guy paid to fix the broken window uses that money to start a company that successfully competes with this 99% person?

If you generalize this, the conclusion is that broken window fallacy assumes that the pie needs to grow in a monotonically increasing fashion, when in reality sometimes the pie needs to shrink a little in order to grow a lot, if that shrinkage results in redistribution of wealth.

▲Haven880 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Anthropic assume Deepseek, Kimi, Qwen, Tencent don't exist and OpenAI is shrinking. Reminds me of Elon laughing at BYD decade ago. What will happen, USA get boxed in while surrounding countries trade with China. You can just look at 2 items USA was champion off for nearly 100 years: cars production and energy production. China is like the replicators in Stargate, they just peoduce more and more...and cheaper too. Heck even data centers, China now completed way more than what US able to this year. And they now start building EUV machine after their manhattan-like project euv prototype succeeded a couple months back. In 2029 they will have a woman on moon. Meanwhile I am still waiting Elon (not NASA) to do it.

▲Morromist 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The US keeps thinking its businesses own the world - and being very lazy about expanding and competing anywhere that isn't the US and europe. Anthropic's investors fell into this trap too. At least Nvidia seems to take China seriously, but can't really do much there legally because of us laws.

In reality China is taking market share all over like crazy with cheap, good products and services.

Someday I think we'll wake up and realize how much wealth we threw away from sheer lazyness and failing to do something about our bloated monopolies that have little reason to compete or innovate or expand - and being a big stupid bully that pissed off everyone else - but by that time we'll have lost most of the world's business to china, cars, software, ai, aerospace, online shopping, etc. All gone.

▲233mhz 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy

Are we talking about the real economy or the stock market casino? I have a feeling one doesn't care about facts and logic

▲0c3ca83 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Anthropic put their Total Addressable Market at 35% of Global GDP (~$40 trillion/yr). They're planning to capture all of the money

Oh, goody. They left room for their friends, Google and OpenAI.

▲giva 18 hours ago | parent [-]

SpaceX already claimed another 25% in its IPO, so they are left with only 40%.

▲joedwin 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[flagged]

▲noncoml 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]

▲stymaar 26 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> would it not actually lower GDP in some way (initially anyway)? What I mean is, if you had an industry that was worth say $1 billion, but now that same industry could be automated and done cheaply then it is no longe worth $1 billion?

GDP growth is usually measured in “volume”, which means that the demand for a good or service doubles while the price is divided by ten, the GDP share for this good or service doubles even if the amount of money is 5 times less.

The reverse is also true though, which means if something becomes twice as expensive (say oil) and people starts buying less of it, it's share of GDP will diminish. Because of that, the GDP deflator is underestimating inflation, and overestimating actual growth in times of high inflation.

▲somenameforme 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think the simple answer is that it won't. Look to other tech revolutions for precedent. The biggest winners of the Industrial Revolution were not mechanical device peddlers, or even the 'super farms' that utilized those devices in an obvious way to increase efficiency/scale/etc. The biggest winners were instead the people who achieved previously unimaginable things on top of all of this.

And I think this (in our revolution) will also generalize to 'cognitive work' companies as a whole. This is why I think LLMs are going to radically (and positively) reshape the world, but in a way that relatively few seem to be predicting for now.

▲littlexsparkee 18 hours ago | parent [-]

If labor income is decimated, there's a shrinking demand base for entrepreneurs using this technology to augment themselves. Maybe a select few make good money before the bottom falls out or get support from the remaining consumers of the physical economy (healthcare, etc).

▲somenameforme 5 hours ago | parent [-]

All labor is, is providing things that others value. When what's valued in a market shifts significantly, so does the equilibrium of the economy. The value of cognitive 'output' approaching $0 will ultimately just open a large vacuum for other things to become more valued, or to build things on top of this that previously would have been unimaginable.

▲lanthissa 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

“Productivity isn't everything, but, in the long run, it is almost everything."

is one of the better quotes for grounding yourself when people start talking about economic problems to big to know exactly.

to your question.

If an industry is 'worth' 1 billion, meaning it generates 1b in revenue lets say at 800m of investment.

and that drops to 80m of investment and 100m of revenue due to productivity improvements then competition, the economy is now free to invest that extra 820m in the next best productive use for that capital, while still getting exactly the same services.

If the companies investing in ai can manage 80m of investment and 300m in revenue as the end state. They're richer, the consumers getting the same service cheaper, and society is richer due to the extra 700m being used to produce other goods and services. Thats the dream.

▲paulryanrogers 5 hours ago | parent [-]

How can consumers consume if they cannot even afford food, much less shelter and healthcare?

▲armcat 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is a further cascading effect. Say that a specific $100b vertical is gone or severely reduced. In the worst case all the people working in that vertical are now unemployed. These same people now have no money or very little money to purchase or invest in other industries/verticals. Which means that there is a downturn in those verticals, leading to cost cuts and employee reductions. And those people now have less money to spend on other industries/verticals. And so on it goes.

▲SirMaster 18 hours ago | parent [-]

But if the AI makes it cheaper to develop and produce the products, they can lower the cost, so those with less money can still afford them. I don't know if anyone knows how that plays out in the long run. Surely it must reach some sort of equilibrium.

▲fakedang 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Except the products are barely priced on how much it costs but rather who can pay. Lmk when 365 Office or Salesforce reduce their prices to match developing economy prices after their generous use of AI.

▲timacles 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Don’t forget that all the people that had the big salaries in this industry no longer have those salaries. That is money that they cannot spend that is removed from the economy.

Which is why other economic disruptors like rail roads eventually lead to economic expansions, and were net positive

It doesn’t not look like that is the case with AI. It’s going to cannibalize the economy and not bring the expansion of previous developments. Which is a sad state for humanity

▲alex43578 19 hours ago | parent [-]

Railroads disrupting a horse and wagon certainly would impact the salaries of wagon drivers.

AI isn’t a magical force that takes your job and prevents you from ever working elsewhere: it’s a technology that will increase productivity and impact jobs via creative destruction.

▲raducu 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> AI isn’t a magical force.

It is the final piece in the re-feudalization/fascization(does this world even exist?).

We're back to feudal times where birth given rights to land, energy, resources, AI is all that matters, no more upper mobility.

▲xienze 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> AI isn’t a magical force that takes your job and prevents you from ever working elsewhere

Yeah I'd say if you were being paid six figures to do some office work thing (including software development) and now only 10% as many people are needed to get the same work done, it is very much going to take your high-paying job and make it considerably more difficult to find another one that pays the same. At a minimum, there's going to be a whole lot more candidates to compete with as you attempt to work "elsewhere."

Unless it's a _very_ slow transition to whatever the "next thing" that "can only be done by humans" pops up, this "creative destruction" is going to be devastating.

▲analognoise 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Creative destruction assumes there’s a new job to find. That’s not necessarily the case and hasn’t been for decades. Like the security guard who works 80 hours a week and their rent is 55% of their pay being told “just move to management”.

Or like elevator operators, who used to make good money. There used to be 120,000 of them in New York - now there’s about 90 thousand elevator technicians, in the whole USA.

There’s not always a replacement job. Or there is, sweeping the floor.

▲giantrobot 16 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Railroads disrupting a horse and wagon certainly would impact the salaries of wagon drivers.

Railroads didn't do that. Horses and wagons remained in wide use after the advent of railroads as a last-mile mode of transport.

Before railroads moving masses of goods and people typically required navigable waterways. Either natural ones or canals. Railroads augmented waterways and allowed that mass transport to expand far from those waterways. The underlying steam engine also helped with expansion as a factory or processing plant could be built near a resource, be powered by a steam engine(s), and ship finished/processed goods via those railroads to some market.

Railroads (and steam engines) expanded the economy far more than the supplanted any particular part. When they did supplant something the economic expansion largely provided new work for whoever's job was obviated.

Knowledge work replacement by AI doesn't necessarily offer the same economic expansion. If it replaces one type of knowledge work there's little stopping it from replacing another type. OpenAI and Anthropic are only viable if they capture significant portions of the US GDP. Anything less and they can't even pay their debt obligations let alone actually make money.

There's no real indication all those replaced workers could find any other jobs, certainly not ones that make as much money. And UBI will never happen, the billionaire class will never pay the taxes that would be required to support it. So that leaves lots of people left with no way to support themselves.

▲wing-_-nuts 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Yes, all those unemployed software developers who used to make multi-six figure incomes are now 'free' to compete in what will certainly be a ruthlessly competitive job market with all the other white collar professionals who were automated away. Likely into much lower paying service jobs, as those will be one of the few areas of the economy where the 'human touch' is still valued.

This reads like the line 'The rich man and the homeless are free to beg for change'

▲AndrewDucker 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If they turn a non-AI $1Billion industry in to an AI $50million industry then they have destroyed that industry, made $50 million themselves, and the people who were previously spending $1Billion between them are collectively $950million better off, which they will then get to spend elsewhere.

▲seiferteric 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Ya but they won't necessarily capture the $50 million themselves since there are already several companies that have comparable models that could all likely perform the same tasks, so at best they would get a fraction of the $50m? And if anyone can run an open model on their GPU then the barrier to entry to compete in this industry would be so low as to be worth almost nothing? Seems like a race to the bottom, like ultra efficient competition where the margins would be very low...

▲AndrewDucker 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Oh yes, I don't expect Anthropic (for instance) to ever be able to make back the money they've spent.

▲ 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲wing-_-nuts 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>the people who were previously spending $1Billion between them are collectively $950million better off, which they will then get to spend elsewhere.

It's generally worse for one man to have a billion dollars than for a 10,000 to have 100k. Those 10,000 people will spend that money where as the billionaire will almost certainly won't. An economy can only take so much 'investment'. Our economy depends on consumer spending.

If the top .01% get fabulously wealthy automating the bottom 90% out of good jobs, we will all be worse off for it.

▲WillAdams 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A good previous example of this was the computerization of publishing --- the investment costs were balanced by letting employees go (though the compositors' union bargained for sinecures) and it took at least a decade for an increase in GDP to be seen as the folks were retrained in new work, and the publishers adapted to the lower costs by increasing the breadth of book titles which were greenlit and published.

Note that this was further complicated by a change in the tax law which made the backlist a liability rather than an asset.

▲cowlevel 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Initially the product would sell for the same price as before, but it would be mostly profits instead of mostly wages. GDP would be the same.

▲mywittyname 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Historically, driving down the price of a product/service drove up consumption of the product/service. So markets will tend to grow to meet demand up to a saturation point.

In some markets, AI driving down costs will drive up consumption. So people won't necessarily lose their high paying jobs, they'll just do more work. Or, at least, corporations will capture the same revenue.

However, what's really untested is what the commoditization of knowledge is going to do to society. Having an agent at your fingertips with essentially a masters degree in every subject on earth, and the ability to apply that knowledge effectively is a pandora's box.

The closest analog is what industrialization did to craftsmen. How are people going to be qualified for jobs when AI can do a better job than anyone? But I suppose that's a political issue more so than a technical/economic one.

▲Espressosaurus 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Anthropic (and OpenAI's) value prop is to replace the labor for a cost. Their endgame is diverting the employee wages to them. And eventually the underlying business perhaps.

▲bcrosby95 44 minutes ago | parent [-]

I kinda think any product that doesn't have a physical aspect is going to go extinct. Why pay a business for something when I can just self serve myself?