Remix.run Logo
▲ xienze 19 hours ago

> AI isn’t a magical force that takes your job and prevents you from ever working elsewhere

Yeah I'd say if you were being paid six figures to do some office work thing (including software development) and now only 10% as many people are needed to get the same work done, it is very much going to take your high-paying job and make it considerably more difficult to find another one that pays the same. At a minimum, there's going to be a whole lot more candidates to compete with as you attempt to work "elsewhere."

Unless it's a _very_ slow transition to whatever the "next thing" that "can only be done by humans" pops up, this "creative destruction" is going to be devastating.

▲jimnotgym 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Interestingly...I have a team of people who deal with processing a document that is shared between companies. Purchase Invoices. They have had automation for years. It is offshored to make it cheaper again. But they are still there...at most companies.

I think the reason is that we can automate what is correct, the invoice matches the PO, the goods are receipted etc.

But most of their time is now spent on exceptions. The company didn't charge what the po said, there is no po, the supplier is not set up, the payment got returned from the bank, some goods are missing.

Now they can't fix any of those things themselves by design, because of segregation of duty controls, and specific humans holding Delegation of Authority for changes. You see if you can order things and pay for them yourself (with the companies money), fraud is inevitable. Giving this to an LLM makes fraud inevitable.

Then we say lawyers and auditors... the personal liability for signing key documents in those industries lies with licensed people. An LLM could prepare files, but that licensed person still has to review them, and employ other reviewers to ensure that the file is correct.

▲pmg101 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I remember when I was a young man, meeting a socialist who seemed very incensed about the coal miners.

I just couldn't understand it. If society no longer needed coal mining, was he seriously proposing they should all keep their jobs anyway? I couldn't take in this way of seeing the world.

So I'm pretty sanguine about the same thing happening to my own career, if it does. In the end, you can only expect to get paid for providing a service society needs. I can't think of any other remotely sensible way of running things, myself.

▲equalsione 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You described an economy, not a society. Economies exist to support society, not the other way around. No, it can’t all be sunshine and lollipops for everyone - things shift and what was once a solid career disappears. This happens all the time. But a society (or maybe a functioning society) doesn’t throw people away if they aren’t bringing in a paycheque every month. Which was at least part of what the miners strike was about. And every other iteration of the same thing back to the Luddites

▲alex43578 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Most people would agree that a healthy, working-age individual should either support themselves, work, or be in education intended to build economically valuable skills. If they aren't working, why should we be taking from those who are to support them? Society can only support so much dead weight before it breaks down.

▲smallmancontrov 13 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Mismanaging an inelastic excess of labor into soggy demand in order to dumpster wages is not the way to treat labor if you actually cared for labor, so I can only conclude that you do not care for labor and dumpstering wages is your entire goal.

▲equalsione 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

“Soylent Green is people“

▲randomNumber7 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The thing I live in feels more like a FFA server than a society.

▲triceratops 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> In the end, you can only expect to get paid for providing a service society needs

It was a fair expectation when nearly everyone had a service to provide. But why now? No one asked to be born.

▲jimnotgym 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

And it was never true. There are people alive today who get paid because their ancestors were friends with William the Conqueror after 1066. They were granted monopoly powers over things people needed, not wanted, nearly 1000 years ago.

Being in a competitive market is for us to bear but not them

▲thewebguyd 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

And importantly, we've grown so huge (population wise) that not everyone needs to provide a service in the first place, even if you can.

We need to move beyond the "everyone must contribute something" mindset, and instead place value on simply life itself instead of what that living being provides or does not provide because there simply isn't room for everyone to provide some service to society, everything is covered. The things that are not covered are generally high skill and high education (expensive) positions that not everyone has the ability to fulfill anyway.

Basically, and before we have mass unemployment and homelessness from AI, we need some sort of universal basic living floor as a safety net. Make sure no person is able to go without housing, food, utilities, education and healthcare.

▲don_esteban an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The thing is that there is still so much that needs to be done (starting with proper care for sick/elderly/kids, but also environmental cleanup and maintenance). The problem is that there is no money to pay for all of that. Not because there is no money (after all, at the basic level, money is just an abstract construct to motivate people), but because the people who do have money do not care for those things.

I.e., this is the problem of how the economy is organized, not of not having enough people to do all those things that need to be done. But we are too deep into 'capitalism (greed) is the best' ideology to clearly see that and do something about it. The way the things are going, either pitchforks or terminators are going to come out. The AI industry is betting on terminators.

▲pmg101 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

To be clear I'd frikkin love free money so I can chill and do whatever I want. But I don't think I have any moral right to it.

▲mitthrowaway2 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Conversely, I believe that the moral right to posess a larger share of wealth than other members of society is justified by the incentive that it creates for people to work, invent, take risks, and contribute to that collective wealth. This has been the engine of plenty for a long time. But if we are coming to the end of an era in which there is any useful work that humans can contribute, as automation begins to take our place, then there is equally no longer a need for an incentive to reward that work, and so the moral justification for wealth inequality vanishes along with it.

▲pmg101 13 hours ago | parent [-]

I think that's right. So if we end up in a feudal like system with all wealth concentrated in the hands of a tiny elite and no means to access it for anyone else, then not only is there likely to be armed insurrection/revolution, it is morally justified.

▲triceratops 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Either there's a moral right to earn money through whatever skills one can offer, no matter how productive. Or there's a moral right to free money.

Anything else, in the long term, amounts to murder through abandonment. It's no different than leaving a wounded person in a forest while the group marches ahead, even though the group has plenty of food and a stretcher and a car, and fit, healthy people to lift the stretcher into the car.

▲pmg101 14 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't agree with your dichotomy.

I think you have a moral right to offer to provide goods or services for people. They aren't obliged to want them though. I think it's on each person to find out how they can provide something people want.

Just because I enjoy coding or am good at coding, if nobody wants to pay coders then it's on me to find out what I can provide that they do want.

▲triceratops 10 hours ago | parent [-]

> it's on me to find out what I can provide that they do want

Sure. But what if that is "nothing"? Or something that pays so little you literally can't afford the necessities of life? Or it's only work you find objectionable (e.g. crime or prostitution)?

For all of human history, given enough time, money, and work, anyone could retrain into something that paid them enough money. "Try harder bro" used to be trite but true. In a true AGI/ASI world it may be an impossible demand. Is it still fair?

▲pmg101 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Right but either that person provides for themself, or other people who also did not ask for them to be born have to provide for them.

Personally, the second option seems even less fair than the first one.

▲bcrosby95 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I dunno, people love to talk about fairness on one end, but don't seem to care about it when you compare being born into poverty vs being born into a trust fund. All of a sudden life isn't fair.

Some people own land simply by virtue of being a distant relative of the first group of people who successfully defended (or took) it from other people with violence. Some people don't own land because their distant ancestors failed to.

It's just all so weird, when so much wealth is tied up in an asset that no human had any hand in creating.

▲mitthrowaway2 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The latter option implies that there is productive work that humans can do to contribute to the economy, otherwise the second group necessarily does not have any members.

▲triceratops 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Right but either that person provides for themself

How though? Just saying "do it yourself" doesn't make it so.

> or other people who also did not ask for them to be born have to provide for them

They have to personally provide for them? That's not quite it is it? Society as a whole is more productive. Automation provides for them.

> Personally, the second option seems even less fair than the first one.

Why? Consider the alternative.

▲timacles 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

please explain what service managers and executives provide to society

No one is saying bring back coal mines or CRUD software jobs. What people are saying is that the working class is being ELIMINATED from the economy. If you are in the working class your options are: service/construction work. Be an electrician, or a waiter, or lawn care professional. And they make jack shit for money. While the managers of AI make millions, so the economy shifts to them, away from people who do labor. But dont forget they all still have to pay taxes which fund all of the massive debt for AI and wars and all other BS.

You cant think of a remotely sensible way of running things because you dont understand what is happening. Society is COLLAPSING. The managerial class is systematically eliminating the working class. So enjoy your pretentious outdated theories about capitalists and socialists. While the world around you decays for the next 5 decades. I assume you're a bit older because (im in my 40s) thats the only people I see with this delusional view of society, they simply dont give a shit about the future.

▲QDwQ1 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

so are you rich? or are you just planning to be homeless once your entire career field is wiped out?

▲alex43578 15 hours ago | parent [-]

Or option 3, go do something else for work. Wild, I know. Life isn't YA fiction where a magical sorting hat gives you a singular job for your whole life.

▲AlexandrB 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

This is what happened to manufacturing and the advice offered to those folks at the time was: "learn to code". The modern equivalent would be "learn to take care of old people", because that market is going to be booming for the next decade or more.

▲xienze 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> because that market is going to be booming for the next decade or more

Well guess what, unless you're willing to be paid less than Haitian immigrants to do that work, it ain't gonna be booming for _you_. Ditto for construction, landscaping, et al. You know, those jobs Americans "won't do."

▲happymellon 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Except they blew all their money on cruises and AI generated images.

▲Applejinx 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

…because 'old people' clearly all have generational wealth on the order of your typical AI tech billionaire and can hire servants and caretakers at white-collar salaries.

That market is absolutely not going to be booming. It's a societal problem that large numbers of old people are exploited, broke, and brainwashed by generations of social media. That's not a booming market, that's a captive army of peons valuable only as long as human votes matter. They could as easily be disposed of, and so could you.

▲xienze 18 hours ago | parent [-]

> …because 'old people' clearly all have generational wealth on the order of your typical AI tech billionaire and can hire servants and caretakers at white-collar salaries.

But they can vote for taxpayers to support it.