Remix.run Logo
▲ smallmancontrov 18 hours ago

The Broken Window "Fallacy" assumes that distributional problems don't exist, lol.

I know why rich people who own many shares of aggregate economic capacity want me to believe that it is the only important thing and that sacrificing aggregate capacity to fix distributional problems is never worthwhile. But I don't believe it. The industrial revolution was gnarly with unnecessary distribution problems that ensured crippling poverty for the masses amid extraordinary leaps in aggregate capacity. This time around I don't want a century of Cyberpunk Oliver Twist before the peons are allowed a dignified life.

Adjacent, improved argument: taxes are a better fix for distributional problems than throwing stones at windows. I agree, and I will add that broken windows are a better fix for distributional problems than guillotines. I really really hope that we can convince capital to pay taxes because that's the only future where things don't go to monumental shit before getting better.

▲randomNumber7 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> The industrial revolution was gnarly with unnecessary distribution problems that ensured crippling poverty for the masses

Which basically only changed when people fought for their rights

> I really really hope that we can convince capital to pay taxes

I sadly can't see that happening without ww3

▲roncesvalles 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Exactly. Let's say there was one guy in the world who owned 99% of all the wealth. Is it really a bad idea to break his window so that he may disburse some money on getting it fixed?

Now, let's say the handyman whom the rich guy paid to fix the broken window uses that money to start a company that successfully competes with this 99% person?

If you generalize this, the conclusion is that broken window fallacy assumes that the pie needs to grow in a monotonically increasing fashion, when in reality sometimes the pie needs to shrink a little in order to grow a lot, if that shrinkage results in redistribution of wealth.

▲cowlevel 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The better idea in that case would be to create a new currency, distribute it equally to everyone, declare the old one worthless and thereby reset the market.

▲mitthrowaway2 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

But the government could just print the money and hand it out as a UBI, without anyone having to waste time fixing a broken window.

▲roncesvalles 16 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, inflating away the rich guy's wealth and distributing it to other people would be the "correct" way, but perhaps one that isn't available in a libertarian-leaning society.

Whether fixing the window is "wasted" time and resources depends on supply-side slack. If there's a warehouse with millions of windows, or the handyman is underemployed and has nothing better to do, then that's not necessarily a linear waste.

▲mitthrowaway2 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I think it's more compatible with libertarianism than breaking the rich guy's windows. It also doesn't even have to inflate his wealth away, if the amount of new money printed merely cancels the deflation caused by mass unemployment.

▲smallmancontrov 14 hours ago | parent [-]

The money printer taxes a very specific slice of assets -- cash, bonds, negotiated salaries, accounts receivable. It does not tax stocks, commodities, and real estate, and in fact inflates their value due to the cantillon effect. If the problem is that stocks have sucked the oxygen out of the room, the money printer is a bad way to get the oxygen back. A better designed tax would target where the money went, not avoid that location or exacerbate the problem.

▲mitthrowaway2 14 hours ago | parent [-]

That's true, a capital gains tax is probably necessary.

▲pamcake 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Sir... This is a ycombinator's...