Remix.run Logo
▲ jvanderbot 5 hours ago

I got coffee with a nice person from HN today. They were wearing a hat with the word "Luddite" on it. I knew what it meant but asked anyway - yes it's not anti-tech, it's anti automation and loss of craft.

The thing about luddites is that yes they wanted to preserve human craftsmanship, and as you say it didn't work. John Henry died. Luddites worked in factories and declined into poverty. Hopeless. Doomed.

But, I am cranking down my personal backlog with AI tools, using them at work, and loving the usefulness of them. It doesn't feel like I'm a master weaver who has their work automated, it feels like I'm reaping productivity gains.

Was there ever a moment in the Luddite movement when some of them leaned in and had fun? Did some of John Henry's colleagues just really enjoy the new steam drivers?

It doesn't _feel_ like I'm being forced out of my trade. I sincerely doubt the Luddites had a moment where they happily shelled out the 1820 equivalent of $20/m to get access to a weaving machine. I'm not saying "this time is different", but I am saying everyone tells me to not use AI, and to be afraid, and I'm de-skilling or whatever, etc. How do we all _know_ what is right?

A loom does not bring agency. It takes it. But I feel like having a computer, access to LLM, increases my agency just a bit. It allows me to do more, not just do what I need to _faster_. It's not _just_ automation.

▲achierius 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

What fundamental difference are you pointing at between looms and computers here? Both let you do craft faster.

Note that it took some time before workers' wages actually collapsed.

▲CamperBob2 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think the Luddites' beef was more about losing options, as they watched their sense of agency in their lives and careers slip away. They couldn't rent their own automated looms for the equivalent of $20/month. Those things were expensive, exotic machines usable only in industrial settings, more like NVL72 racks than RTX 5090s. But with AI, we are as you suggest gaining options, so any comparison with Luddism fails from the get-go.

Obviously the correct way to view the arrival of AI is as an empowering tool for the ultimate benefit of us all, but just as obviously there are a lot of people who simply don't seem capable of understanding that. Obviously the correct way to react to the arrival of AI is to severely regulate the monopolists and oligarchs rather than the technology itself, but... see above.

Unfortunately there is no obvious way to deal with people who think the Luddites were somehow morally superior, or who otherwise want to rehabilitate or emulate them. It's like flashing back to late 2019, watching news reports come in about some sort of weird, unusually-severe flu that seemed to be spreading. Nobody knew for sure what to do then, and I don't think anyone does now. But we are going to have to do something to keep those people from dragging us backward with the self-centered psychological pandemic they are trying to spread.

▲ifwinterco an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

People (even software engineers, seemingly) seem to conflate writing code, which is a skill that LLMs do sort of replace, with software engineering.

In my opinion LLMs can write code but they don't replace human skill and judgement in software engineering.

They can help you make decisions but ultimately humans still have to be responsible.

When your payments gateway goes down the week before Christmas you can't just say "well Claude did that, I have no idea how it works or why it can't handle the traffic".

The LLM bros want to claim that role will be handled by... who? The CEO is going to start prompting Claude at 3am making random changes in production to fix the payments gateway? The product manager? The cleaner?

Or you have some agent loop constantly making random changes in production to crucial core parts of your codebase with no human supervision?

I just can't see how actual software engineers who understand how the system works aren't still needed