Remix.run Logo
▲ giantrobot 16 hours ago

> Railroads disrupting a horse and wagon certainly would impact the salaries of wagon drivers.

Railroads didn't do that. Horses and wagons remained in wide use after the advent of railroads as a last-mile mode of transport.

Before railroads moving masses of goods and people typically required navigable waterways. Either natural ones or canals. Railroads augmented waterways and allowed that mass transport to expand far from those waterways. The underlying steam engine also helped with expansion as a factory or processing plant could be built near a resource, be powered by a steam engine(s), and ship finished/processed goods via those railroads to some market.

Railroads (and steam engines) expanded the economy far more than the supplanted any particular part. When they did supplant something the economic expansion largely provided new work for whoever's job was obviated.

Knowledge work replacement by AI doesn't necessarily offer the same economic expansion. If it replaces one type of knowledge work there's little stopping it from replacing another type. OpenAI and Anthropic are only viable if they capture significant portions of the US GDP. Anything less and they can't even pay their debt obligations let alone actually make money.

There's no real indication all those replaced workers could find any other jobs, certainly not ones that make as much money. And UBI will never happen, the billionaire class will never pay the taxes that would be required to support it. So that leaves lots of people left with no way to support themselves.

▲MiroslavPokorny 4 hours ago | parent [-]

> Railroads didn't do that. Horses and wagons remained in wide use after the advent of railroads as a last-mile mode of transport.

Many horses and wagons lost business due to trains, just because some remained doesnt change the fact the others lost their place in the system.

Proper comparisons are about numbers not nothing changed because of one cherry picked item.

> Knowledge work replacement by AI doesn't necessarily offer the same economic expansion.

Most people using AI are not knowledgeable. A lot of AI seems to be dumb animations or flyers or silly graphics or emails nobody reads, or more powerpoints. Thats not knowledge those lines of work, are a tax on everyone else.

Nobody needs advertising, or pointless sociual media type communications.

▲thisismyanon2 3 hours ago | parent [-]

By and large trains didn't displace horses, trucks did. Trains provided long haul service while horses provided last mile service without a lot of overlap. You can see this today in countries where horses are still fairly popular like Cuba and Romania. You'll see an occasional horse on the autopista but it's not until you get into cities that horses are common enough to become problematic (and you'll see signs forbidding them as a result).

  Nobody needs advertising, or pointless sociual media type communications.

Ah, you don't remember the AI company plastering San Francisco with adverts imploring people to stop hiring humans? That was not an issue with trains.