Remix.run Logo
▲ elgertam a day ago

I came close to thinking that way a couple years ago, but I've become more optimistic. There is no shortage of problems that can be solved (in fact, wants are infinite), and LLMs may actually enable our profession to reliably deliver them better than 50% completion.

I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong, even with strong and capable models.

For a certain type of engineer who enjoys really arcane technical problems, yeah, the gravy train may be over, or at least will involve a lot more machines than it used to, as Alan Turing predicted about "mechanical work" becoming a "drudge."[0]

And I think Big Tech is for the foreseeable future a sink for capital in the form of specialized hardware rather than human capital.

[0]https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alan_Turing#Quotes

▲marsten a day ago | parent | next [-]

The arcane technical problems aspect of the job has always been changing; LLMs are just a continuation of the trend.

I'm old enough to remember when compiled languages like C were bemoaned by people because their skill at crafting assembly by hand was suddenly less important. Or similarly with people who were brilliant with arithmetic, or symbolic manipulation, or manual drafting/lettering. These skills were all paramount at one time, and it's natural that the people who excelled at them will feel a sense of loss.

The real goal, however, will always be to solve real-world problems. Engineering consists of whatever gets you there most effectively.

▲SomaticPirate a day ago | parent | next [-]

Bullish on AI in the long to medium term but that doesn’t change the fact that it’s displacing junior level jobs now.

Several students I have been trying to help enter the field are facing greater barriers than I have ever seen. Not just leetcode but dozens of interviewing rounds. The problems that they are asked also feel increasingly hard and it seems like interviewers are using AI during the interview while forbidding the interviewee from leveraging any external aids.

We are really burning the next class of developers with the current interview process

▲timr 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> Not just leetcode but dozens of interviewing rounds.

I cannot believe that companies are still using leetcode. That's just complete idiocy. The game is all about reading and understanding code now. Anyone who is still conducting timed code trivia examinations has completely lost the plot.

Stop cargo-culting your interview process, and use your brains!

▲tgma 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This is a classic fallacy: that interview should look the same as the job. There is no reason[1] your evaluation pipeline has to necessarily resemble the task you are hiring for. You could test people on random cognitive tasks and predict their job performance.

[1]: Purely technical. There may be social reasons or legal consequences like "disparate impact" theories coming at you.

▲mlyle 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Sure, random cognitive tasks are correlates of technical job performance.

But there's plenty of people with high intelligence and problem solving that aren't good programmers, so we probably want to try to hone in on that a little bit instead of picking something with positive correlation.

There are also tall people who are not great basketball players, and vice versa. If you can't do anything but measure height, maybe you should pick for your team that way... but if you aren't so restricted there's surely better ways to go.

▲tkamat29 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Why would you want to hone in on finding "good programmers" though? Programming is not the end-all be-all skill of being a good software engineer, this was true even before AI but is even more true now.

Leetcode is popular because:

1. It gauges problem solving ability and pattern recognition, which are essential to any job, and particularly useful for software engineers.

2. It is language agnostic - most jobs would rather have a strong engineer that doesn't know their particular language/tech stack than a weak engineer that is familiar with the stack.

3. It has objective evaluation criteria (correctness + time/space complexity).

It's certainly not perfect, but I have yet to see an alternative that accomplishes all of the above. The one thing I can see potentially complementing it is the new style of AI-assisted assessment where you are dropped into an unknown codebase, and asked to make fixes/features that are assisted by an AI agent. This solves the language-agnostic issue with pre-AI versions of these interviews, where you had to have memorized specific tech stack features or language syntax in order to accomplish the task. Now AI can take care of that stuff, and the interviewee can focus on the problem solving aspect.

▲timr 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> It gauges problem solving ability and pattern recognition, which are essential to any job, and particularly useful for software engineers.

Proof of claim required. Leetcode primarily measure's someone's ability to memorize leetcode problems, and secondarily measures their ability to vomit this knowledge up in a stressful situation.

There's an entire test-prep industry surrounding this interview method. Any undergrad will tell you that the way you pass leetcode interviews is to "grind". You'd have to be oblivious to not realize that the system has been gamed to hell and back.

Since you are just asserting things, I will assert a simpler explanation: the primary reason Leetcode is popular is because it is cheap. If you have the problem that you have too many applicants and don't want to spend money interviewing them all, you have to come up with an efficient filter that doesn't violate hiring laws. You don't particularly care if the false negative rate is high, so a test of superficially relevant trivia is what you do. Even better if the trivia can be validated by computer!

Setting aside the fact that almost no companies actually had this problem outside of FAANG, thanks to AI, the approach has gone from "somewhat relevant" to "completely irrelevant" within a couple of years. It's time to take it out back and shoot it.

▲01CPMD3174 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Leetcode is popular because it gives hiring teams an objective 1)getting people to self select out of the process and 2)shortlisting the people who do opt-in.

I’m sure the companies know that Leetcode is not a great indicator for likelihood to succeed in the role. If they had a perfect information about people, then would stop interviewing at all and just take the best people who applied.

They don’t have perfect information. The information is highly asymmetric. The companies are just trying to not be efficient and not get burned.

It sucks for candidates. But it makes sense for companies when they thousands of applicants they know effectively nothing about.

▲filipdobro 16 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Leetcode interviewing is popular because it barely requires any effort by the interviewer. It is a small, localized knowledge check of your DSA skills. No other profession requires you to invest this much time into the interviewing process. How about we look at past achievements, contributions and certifications, like in any other field?

▲TeMPOraL 14 hours ago | parent [-]

> How about we look at past achievements, contributions and certifications, like in any other field?

In other fields, those things aren't nearly as meaningless and easy to game as they are in ours.

▲filipdobro 10 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't agree with that. No mechanic shop will test if you actually know how to change the brakes of a car. They have to gauge it from the interview process without doing the actual work.

▲mlyle 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The mechanic shop will figure out you don't know what you're doing really, really quickly though. Whereas when we hire someone it's often much longer before we get quality feedback.

▲jjav 14 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Leetcode is popular because:

Well, no. It rewards ability (and free time) to repeatedly work through problems and memorize the solutions. And it rewards acting skills so you can perform like you're discovering solutions on the fly, that you've actually memorized.

That's all it does.

▲tgma 14 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Weeding out smart non-programmers is quite easy. Obvious by their resume and their non-coding interviews. I bet in an unlikely scenario that you fail to detect that, you probably have a pretty good hire who'll learn in a heartbeat.

What you really want to weed out, at least at top-tier companies who can afford to be more selective, is people who have a resume, but are not that great at fundamentals. Most loud complaints seem to be of this nature: guy had N years of experience at previous company/is author of popular software, but couldn't get through basic linked list/recursion/BFS--as if this is not an acceptable bare minimum expectation of a professional in the field.

Often people are too polite to say it out loud, but realistically, that is exactly when it is working as intended.

▲miroljub 13 hours ago | parent [-]

It's not. In 99,99% of programming jobs you will never have to implement a linked list. And yet, interviewers pretend it's important to be able to write it on the blackboard.

▲tgma 13 hours ago | parent [-]

Not the point. If you have way more applicants than roles and you are paying well, given the choice between a programmer who cannot implement a linked list [really?] and one who can, you would hire the one who has that ability, even if all they do all day is to stare at Claude Code.

▲montag 15 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Leetcode is and has always been a conveniently disguised IQ test.

▲tptacek 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

People love saying this, but it doesn't make any sense. There are software firms that, within the past 15 years, broadly screened all candidates with actual IQ tests. There's no reason to disguise them at all. The reason nobody in the industry does this is that we all know what a debacle it would be to screen primarily on IQ tests rather than "can people do the job effectively".

▲menaerus 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It takes some IQ to solve leetcode problems but better performance of human A in comparison to human B does not say anything about their absolute IQ capabilities. It's a conveniently disguised test for attracting highly motivated individuals with average or more than average IQ and nothing else.

▲JustFinishedBSG 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's an absolutely terrible intelligence test.

It's basically just a grinded leetcode test.

▲oreally 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]

▲oreally 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Wrong.

Literal psychologists have done the research on this: A good, predictive interview is a small representative test of what people do in the normal job. Only us techbros seem arrogant enough to want to be the exception to decades of research.

▲timr 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> This is a classic fallacy: that interview should look the same as the job. There is no reason[1] your evaluation pipeline has to necessarily resemble the task you are hiring for.

Well then. If the "classic fallacy" is that job interviews should reflect the actual job, then what does it really matter what we do? Let's just have a big pub quiz. That measures "intelligence", too.

> You could test people on random cognitive tasks and predict their job performance.

Show me a single piece of evidence that memorizing code golf answers from a book is a valid proxy for intelligence, and we'll talk.

(Hint: You'll have better luck convincing me that it's a stealth way of discriminating against older, more experienced applicants who are further from undergrad and less willing to re-memorize Cracking the Coding Interview for the 150th time. Because it actually is.)

In any case, I do not understand this...Stockholm syndrome...that some programmers seem to have for the idiotic interview system.

▲boorang 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> (Hint: You'll have better luck convincing me that it's a stealth way of discriminating against older, more experienced applicants who are further from undergrad and less willing to re-memorize Cracking the Coding Interview for the 150th time. Because it actually is.)

I hadn't actually thought about it this way, but it makes sense. I'm in my early 50s and hella experienced and talented (if i do say so myself), but I refuse to do any interviews that require me to do any more preparation than researching the company I'm applying to.

▲timr 17 hours ago | parent [-]

I think it's a common story for anyone who has been around a while: you have a career (possibly even working for big, famous names) develop a long resume of accomplishments, and some dinky startup with a staff of teenagers rejects you via email because you didn't solve a leetcode hard problem while singing and dancing on zoom.

It's obviously absurd, and while I almost understand it for a company that doesn't know you, you'll get hit with this stuff when you've been referred internally, by people you worked with in the past.

▲tgma 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Obvious strawman: is "coin flipping tournament" a "random cognitive task?"

There is a century of data and studies that suggest cognitive ability is positively correlated across tasks. Conducting IQ tests for hiring is practically illegal in the US. Leetcode is the closest you get to an IQ test without tripping some laws.

▲timr 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, I changed it to a better metaphor before you wrote your comment. I had originally written "pub quiz", then changed it to "coin flipping contest" to emphasize the stupidity of the task, then changed it back, anticipating the criticism. The argument does not change -- the claim that testing coding trivia is a test of intelligence is a bald assertion.

Please use your intelligence to see the argument I am making, instead of nitpicking the example.

> Conducting IQ tests for hiring is practically illegal in the US. Leetcode is the closest you get to an IQ test without tripping some laws.

No, it isn't. Disparate impact is. Any test that has a disparate impact on a protected class is de facto illegal, but there's case law surrounding IQ tests.

By the way...ironically enough, Griggs v. Duke Power established that any intelligence test must have relevance to the job responsibilities, which sort of blows a hole in your entire theory of the case that this is a "classic fallacy".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co.

▲kelipso 17 hours ago | parent [-]

> the claim that testing coding trivia is a test of intelligence is a bald assertion

I think you have to let this one go. SAT, LSAT, GRE, ASVAB all correlate well with IQ scores. Leetcode should too, after the interviewee does a few weeks of practice (just like all those other tests).

▲timr 17 hours ago | parent [-]

> Leetcode should too, after the interviewee does a few weeks of practice (just like all those other tests).

I mean, you're just making stuff up, but ok.

▲tptacek 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Not only is it not practically illegal, as the sibling commenter notes, but several household-name corporations openly IQ test candidates. General cognitive testing is presumptively lawful in white collar employment.

▲tgma 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Your pivot from "IQ test" in your first sentence to "general cognitive testing" in second is the whole point.

Leetcode is just one step away from that (and much more litigation-proof).

▲tptacek 17 hours ago | parent [-]

IQ tests are general cognitive tests. If your entire argument is that IQ tests are fine so long as you call them something else, you're not really saying anything.

Leetcode is not a general cognitive test, obviously.

▲tgma 17 hours ago | parent [-]

IQ tests are general cognitive tests. The opposite is not necessarily true.

The whole point of the multibillion dollar test industry is to fudge a "noisy" IQ[ish] test and make it look like it won't have disparate impact (validation "studied") and buy you some ass-covering ability.

> Leetcode...

"one step away"

▲tptacek 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Leetcode is a domain-specific test. It is the opposite thing to a general cognitive test. The entire point of IQ is the positive manifold: the notion that general cognitive tests are all monitoring the same latent variable.

If you're saying, like, the Wonderlic test is fine but IQ testing isn't, all you're saying is that the "IQ brand" is problematic. That's wrong, but also it's not saying anything interesting. Call it whatever you want, it's the same business premise.

If you're saying that Leetcode is, like the Wonderlic, a direct proxy for IQ, that's just clearly false.

▲tgma 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

[flagged]

▲ 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲Mawr 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> This is a classic fallacy: that interview should look the same as the job.

I think I'm gonna get a stroke reading this. The classic fallacy is the nonsense you're spouting — that there's anything besides the job itself that is relevant to it. You're hiring people for x, so the only thing you care about is their ability to do x. This is obvious.

The perfect test is just hiring someone on the spot and seeing how they perform. We don't do this because it's expensive but obviously it would be the perfect test, measuring exactly what you're hiring for, by definition.

So then any test that goes further and further away from that ideal becomes worse and worse at predicting job performance. The trick is figuring out a good enough test that's still reasonably quick and cheap to do.

Deliberately going out of your way to test your canditates for something unrelated to the job is insanely stupid.

It's essentially just arrogance. Arrogantly asserting that you know for sure your particular "generic" test actually selects for ~all traits you want while also rejecting ~all traits you don't. I assure you, the chances of you having a good enough model of reality to do this are laughable. Pure arrogance.

Again, easiest to see by thinking of the opposite example to before — the worst test possible would of course be something completely unrelated, so idk, having a chef play ping-pong. I'm sure you could convincingly argue it tests something, but why in the world would you not just have him make a dish, since you know, that's what you're hiring him to do? (it's not actually by the way, now that's a classic fallacy — that the job is the mechanical subset of it and not the job as a whole. Soft skills, anyone? sigh).

I've seen someone suggesting that since a lot of programmers like playing Factorio, why not interview people by having them play Factorio? Ah, because then you're selecting for Factorio players. Do you have a good model of what makes a good Factorio player? Hell, do you have a good model of what makes a good performer at your job? You absolutely do not. Why select for Factorio players when you can select for your-job players?

Another common example of this utter arrogance is thinking that a candidate's performance during a highly stressful, unnatural, and artificial classic interview grilling environment is indicative of their perfomance in the every day feeling-secure-in-their-job state of mind. Oh, look, this fool I'm basically abusing from my position of power is stammering and squirming, must mean he's a good-for-nothing loser! Hah, another fraud found!

So sure, keep putting people in as much stress as possible and asking them how many golf balls fit in an airplane. BTW, I walk out of such interviews immediately. Have fun with your new Leetcode grinder performative actor hires though — you get what you test for.

▲tgma 14 hours ago | parent [-]

> ...you get what you test for.

Multiple trillion dollar companies has not been that bad.

▲JackMorgan 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As someone who's spent too much time grinding leetcode: leetcode is very effective in filtering for people who are willing to put in 50-100 hours prepping a cognitive skill only used in interviews. People who have the time to spare to do the prep and are willing to do a bullshit task for the chance to work at the company. People who are desperate for the pay or prestige, and will likely not rock the boat too hard because they worked hard for the job.

Leetcode could be replaced by learning a made up language, memorizing a huge list of numbers, or reciting an epic poem.

The Leetcode game is mostly memorizing pre-existing solutions and then practicing applying them to lots of variations of the same problem.

The real filter is psychological: will you jump through hoops even when they don't make sense?

▲dingdongditchme 16 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I used something akin to leetcode in my days as a hiring manager and would not give up on it as a tool. It's not the final rank, but it filters before the interview. If the code is perfect there is not much to talk about other than probing whether you wrote it yourself, but since perfect code doesn't exist it gives us a good basis on discussion during the interview of things that do matter on the job. If the code is poor or nonexistent then I can dismiss (maybe sometimes wrongly) the candidate and focus on more promising ones. Of course it is not great for candidates having to do a whole lot and becomes more meaningless when the answer can be vibe-coded but it does still help imho.

▲blurjp 8 hours ago | parent | next [-]

[flagged]

▲timr 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't dispute that it's an effective filter. That is pretty much the only thing it is good at: winnowing a population of applicants down when you don't care about the false-negative rate.

The argument that you can use the the artifact of the coding challenge as a starting point for further discussion is perhaps true, but it's like saying that you can use an applicant's resume as a starting point for discussion, once you've filtered out everyone who failed a keyword search.

▲dingdongditchme 14 hours ago | parent [-]

Isn't that the whole point of the process reduce the candidate pool to 1? Both cv and coding challenge open up quite different discussion. I am not only interested in the applicants past but also in the way he approaches problems (even if they are somewhat trite and not representative). More important to me is a third aspect for which we never really had a good test and that is "enthusiasm" for the job.

▲threatofrain 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Reading and understanding code? Or architecture? Reading code seems to be a very local concern, something that could be swapped out at will, sometimes with a whole new language and ecosystem.

▲timr 18 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't know, but if you don't write the code anymore, and you don't understand the code anymore -- at least to the extent of being able to quickly read and fix it -- then you certainly are not necessary.

So maybe we should try testing for that skill. This is not a hard thing to do, and there are many, many functional responsibilities and traits that a professional developer requires, which go beyond this.

Here are but a few, off the top of my head: spoken communication, written communication, time management, organization, focus, creativity, system design (aka architecture, as you suggest), planning.

It's always been painfully idiotic that we've used code golf for interviews, but the rapid advance of code robots has thrown it into sharp relief.

▲cortesoft 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It was always stupid to do leetcode interviews

▲jjav 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The game is all about reading and understanding code now.

I wish you were correct. The trend is that nobody reads code anymore, AI writes it and people rubberstamp it with barely a glance (if even that, some companies might have AI rubberstamp it and off it goes into production).

▲Betelbuddy 13 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>> The game is all about reading and understanding code now

My colleagues use the LLM to do that...

▲ 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲Sateeshm 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Reading and understanding code is not it either.

▲boorang 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I have 20+ years of experience, and even I can't psychologically handle the current interview process. I think people underestimate how much of the interview process is basically a form of "high stress memory testing".

▲zdc1 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've heard an idea that hiring for juniors is more like hiring for quants now: you care less about coding skill and more about general aptitude / intelligence.

Unfortunately that means we may see more of these brain teaser / gauntlet style interviews.

▲tesnorindian 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Even passionate devs are getting affected. Earlier in India, Engineering colleges used to push students towards IT from other streams pointing out that IT jobs are lucrative. But today people are warned about joining IT jobs expecting it to be a scam.

▲corrinavirus123 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As a mid level dev who knows I can competently do the job I’m having the same problem :(

Interviews are so hard

▲8note a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

expectations for juniors will change over time, ands university curricula for software engineering degrees with it

▲0c3ca83 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

This is just because companies realized that the kids are both unnecessary and desperate. As AI gets better, the effects will move up the stack.

Though, there's a competing effect: as AI gets better, the amount of skill drops. Maybe the demand for seniors will turn into demand for juniors as AI improves at architecture, and the work shifts towards manual testing.

▲atherton94027 a day ago | parent | next [-]

Or more likely, the demand for seniors increases as managers realizes they cut off the supply of junior engineers

▲bonoboTP 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

A junior is unlikely to become a senior in your company so that argument doesn't bite. We are not 30-40 years ago when people stayed at one place for a decade or even their whole careers.

▲komali2 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> when people stayed at one place for a decade or even their whole careers.

It sounds like you, like me and probably a lot of us here, are in startup world, but even here I would say the average career is something like four or five years. Most of my peers outside of startup world have worked at the same company the last decade.

I think we're probably the exception still.

▲tezzer 20 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm going on 11 years at a robotics entity (minus a 2 year flyer at a FAANG for better lunches and stock) because I really love the work. I interview elsewhere a couple times a year to practice talking about myself and see if the grass is really greener, but if you like what you do and you're good at it, stopping the churn is pretty refreshing.

▲bonoboTP 18 hours ago | parent [-]

I hope you never complain about fake job postings with no real intention to hire, given that you do fake applications with no real intention to get hired.

▲com 17 hours ago | parent [-]

It is up to the interviews and interviewers to convince good candidates to join. Especially those who are in work and satisfied with their current position.

Nothing fake about these applicants, they’re just hard to convince.

▲0c3ca83 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That sounds like some good copium.

I'm already remotely prompting Claude through the "senior engineers" where I work. I'm not saying anything, but the company would probably be better off without them. The level of disconnect with the code has effectively turned them into dead weight. They'd be better off replacing them with manual testers.

The reality is that staying in a job and shipping what the managers ask for takes less skill.

The question is how long it will take management to notice and decide to do the next round of layoffs.

▲akbarian 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Good, then we need less managers as they become dead weight. And what do we need you for?An agent can do your job soon aswell.

▲0c3ca83 13 hours ago | parent [-]

If AI works out as the AI companies predict, human thought is dead weight.

This is not a good thing.

▲tgma 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I think a lot of what's attributed to AI re juniors (and everything else) is really the confounding effect of ZIRP ending. BigTech headcount growth stalled before LLM. A key point is that a "junior" engineer was really an apprentice. The decade before that, the big employers basically understood that they have to hire from universities and train employees themselves to get to their hiring targets. No one expected the out-of-college junior eng to be net productive in the first year or two. The problem is if you don't need to grow the headcount beyond what the market can already supply you in mid-senior engineers, why do you need to pay for their training?

▲ultrarunner a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Going from asm to C is a different mode of thinking, but a cerebral challenge nonetheless. The transition we're in includes a substantial disengagement of thought. For those of us who like thinking, this is something to mourn.

▲bonoboTP 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If you're ambitious enough, there is still plenty to think about. Design, tradeoffs, what to measure, how to express your goals, what you value and want to spend more time going deep on, what counts as good enough, etc. A lot of decisions but they are of the sort where you also need to be given enough agency and decision by your company. The type of job where you're given a spec and you just code it up is indeed going away.

Maybe at some point AI will do this better too, and at some point they will just mind read you as to what you're trying to build so you don't even have to be able to verbalize it any more, but we are far from thatm

▲lantry 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

AI makes it possible to disengage from thinking, much more than past technologies did. You can prompt it with "yes, keep going" and just accept whatever it spits out. However, you'll still get better results if you are also thinking, and challenging it when it makes bad assumptions.

If you like thinking, you can keep thinking. AI can't stop you from doing that unless you let it.

▲NegativeLatency 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I feel that some, I’ve also been able to take on just a huge scope of work and deliver satisfactory results, which is interesting in its own way.

Been able to finally remove a really painful and bad ORM from a legacy codebase.

▲derangedHorse 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The transition we're in includes a substantial disengagement of thought

Not really, the problem is just changing. Just like C allowed developers to leverage a standard library and a checked type system to create software, AI is allowing developers to leverage english and verifiable specifications to create software. We're all still developing software per a set of requirements at the end of the day.

The varied implementations will always exist and the job is both picking the right requirements to work on, and delivering in a way consistent with its goals.

▲StilesCrisis a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Really? I find the thinking is very different but I'm still keeping very busy. It's like never-ending PR review cycles.

▲hirvi74 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Do you mind helping me understand a couple of things about your perspective?

> The transition we're in includes a substantial disengagement of thought.

While I think you are more correct than not, a cheeky part of me cannot help but think that humanity might be better served if some thoughts were never engaged with in the first place.

1.) I apologize if this is a rather blunt question, but how much of your identity is based on your own perceived (and perhaps exemplified/actualized) intelligence?

   I have had a fortunate enough life to have befriended many people who I consider to be far more intelligent than myself. Of these many individuals that I remain in contact with, I have noticed the ones that are the most adamantly opposed to the LLM frenzy, the "death of thought", etc. are the ones that have the strongest attachment/most pride in their own intelligence. I suppose it is a rational reaction, but I think LLMs are hurting a lot of people's egos. 
> For those of us who like thinking, this is something to mourn.

2.) That statement is what I am most curious about. Do you mind elaborating on what thought there is to mourn? What exactly is being taken away from you? I hope I am not about to come off as condescending, but what is actually preventing you from engaging in deep thought? One is not compelled to use AI outside of their own volition. Even in instances of employer mandates, one is not forced to use AI outside of their occupation.

▲byronturncoat 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm not the person you're responding to, but I think that you're searching for a correlation that does not exist. There is a universe of nuance in why someone might believe that LLMs cause the death of thought that has nothing to do with their ego. Perhaps they've seen it directly affect engineers on their teams. Perhaps they have themselves experienced the phenomenon. Perhaps they've read the numerous studies that have been published on the subject.

Just because someone doesn't believe the same as you, it doesn't mean that they've got a fragile or damaged ego. I, personally, think that people who don't see the death of thought are delusional, and it's got nothing to do with ego.

When someone spends 40 hours per week doing a thing, having the ability, motivation, and pleasure in solving problems they enjoy can and is being taken away. Yes, one can engage in "deep thought" in personal time, if you've got time for that with children, responsibilities, and other leisure activities. Not everyone has time to engage in deep thought enough in free time to compensate for the loss in the workplace.

▲hirvi74 7 minutes ago | parent [-]

> I think that you're searching for a correlation that does not exist.

I cannot provide evidence in favor or against my conjecture, so you very well may be correct.

> Perhaps they've read the numerous studies that have been published on the subject.

I feel it is necessary to push back on this point a bit. I will read any research you are willing to share, but from the studies I have happened to read, the "death of thought" would be a hyperbolic mischaracterization of observations. Most studies I can remember reading tend to measure performance on small, narrow sets of tasks. For clarification, what do you believe "death of thought" means? If you mean an atrophy in a particular skill being linked to outsourcing the skill to LLMs, then I am more inclined to agree with you. In other words, I do not disagree that using LLMs for any and all programming is linked to the atrophy of one's ability to program, but I would be more suspicious of claims that suggest that such usage of LLMs is linked to one's ability to think critically in many or most domains.

> Just because someone doesn't believe the same as you, it doesn't mean that they've got a fragile or damaged ego.

I am well aware. However, I never shared my opinions on whether I believe thought is dying or not, so I am not sure what disagreement you believe the OP and I have. I was merely sharing an observation that I have noticed amongst people I consider to be highly intelligent within my social circles. In hindsight, I can understand how the wording of some of my questions my be interpreted as subtly sharing a stance. Some people have a way with words, while others like me often struggle. My apologies.

> When someone spends 40 hours per week doing a thing, having the ability, motivation, and pleasure in solving problems they enjoy can and is being taken away. Yes, one can engage in "deep thought" in personal time, if you've got time for that with children, responsibilities, and other leisure activities. Not everyone has time to engage in deep thought enough in free time to compensate for the loss in the workplace.

Of course. That is true of any limited resource be it time, money, health, or what have you. Those that find themselves in such a situation have both my sympathy and empathy.

▲MiiMe19 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

disclaimer: Not the OP.

1. I feel like I have a decent amount of my identity tied up in being "smart". I have always enjoyed learning, have been good at solving problems, and have been able to get out of some pretty difficult circumstances that were definitely slanted against me in terms of being able to find a stable and high paying job through a combination of luck, being born decently smart, and hard work.

2. For my entire life I have been able to work towards or have a job where my purpose is to solve interesting problems and get paid well for it. I have been lucky enough to be in a position where I could paid to sit down and build solutions, understanding every intricate detail of what I made. And now, it seems like the entire industry is just throwing this away. Why engage with deep thought when everyone around is thoroughly convinced that the act of thinking is "last gen" or "going out of style"? If everyone else is wrong, that doesn't change the pressure to just stop thinking and ship 50 commits a day of unread slop. If everyone else is right, why bother thinking? I am just going to lose my job and be stuck doing menial labor until the AGI builds robots that can do my job. Either way I am unhappy. And sure, I do not need to use AI outside of work, but that does not change the existential dread of having the next 30-40 years of my career turned into something that I absolutely hate.

Overall, we have effectively built a machine or a widespread perception of a machine that rewards not thinking and not taking responsibility. Why bother trying to accomplish anything if a machine can do it better than you. I value solving problems, I value understanding, and I value working hard, and at least for me I feel that I may have to start mourning the fact that you used to be able to get paid to do all three. On the bright side, if anyone my age is poised to, by the stupid credentialism of our society, stay in the job market after this, it is me. So either I make a decent amount of money and escape the permanent underclass or all of society is cooked, in which case at least I won't be judged.

▲alexose a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I spent years of my early career being the guy who could make websites look bubbly with custom border graphics stuffed into <table> layouts.

border-radius could have knocked me out of the game, but I decided to keep going. And I'm glad I did.

▲murukesh_s a day ago | parent | next [-]

OMG wonder how many of us remember/experienced those times.. still remember using Java applets to do some interactive stuff and replaced that with Ajax when it was a thing! You are a hero web dev if you write 100 lines of Javascript.

▲riddlemethat a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I remember how frustrating it felt that website standards no longer mandated tables for layouts and we had to learn div layers. Not to mention the semantic web or the switch of dynamic content away from flash…

I’m excited about what this next progression entails. I’m building complex software in months in a home lab that would have required millions in investment just five years ago. In five years I don’t think any of us can say for certain what the industry will look like.

▲alxmdev a day ago | parent | next [-]

The switch from table-based layouts to divs & CSS happened over 20 years ago, and I still don't really get the value of it. Tables gave an intuitive control over page layout that worked in every browser and maintained structure even without styling. Divs required obtuse CSS float and clear rules and useless nested elements to achieve the same designs, and it didn't even work everywhere consistently. At the time it seemed like change for the sake of change, and 20 years later that space is still a mess.

▲proxyscore 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Mobile layout came along

▲mitxela 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The point is "semantics" which actually means "the word table is only allowed to be used around numeric data, and you can't ever say italic or bold, you have to say emphasis or strong emphasis, but they're allowed as long as they're wrapped in a style attribute for some reason"

4/5

▲jimbokun a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> I’m building complex software in months in a home lab that would have required millions in investment just five years ago.

Have you been able to translate that into a steady income?

▲sylos 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It never does. And the software wila probably rot on the vine

▲blackqueeriroh 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

In what world does this need to be the point?

▲jimbokun 4 hours ago | parent [-]

In a world where people need to pay rent or their mortgage.

▲fomoz a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I love this comment.

SWEs who oppose AI seem to forget that they are paid to solve problems, not write code.

▲truncate a day ago | parent | next [-]

Most SWE who "oppose AI" in my experience, don't oppose AI but oppose its how its being adapted or used. All gas no brakes. You can't really say "lets think about it a bit" without becoming AI denier/opposer or whatever.

We make aggressive decisions, based on overly optimistic bet on "AI will fix it" mindset. I think it should be more towards, given what we have now and may put in little bit of optimism around AI how can go forward without completely dismissing decades of engineering principles we developed. If AI really goes 10x better than what it is now, then we can just build stuff much faster then anyway, but it didn't we made something reliable today as well something we can keep building on 5/10 years from now.

▲stinkbeetle a day ago | parent [-]

> You can't really say "lets think about it a bit" without becoming AI denier/opposer or whatever.

What does "lets think about it a bit" even mean though? You want other people to stop using productive tools? Or you want to be able to opt out of using productive tools without an employer worrying about it? There always seems to be either a shifting of burden to others, or a denial that AI tools increase productivity.

People can think about AI and use AI with all gas and no brakes. Or you can opt out of using AI for as long as you like to think about things.

▲truncate 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

>> You want other people to stop using productive tools?

This is the EXACTLY the kind of BS you get. No, not asking you to stop using those tools. Its not 0 or 1 thing. Its not a choice between "all gas no brake" and "I wont use AI". But maybe, just maybe, think a little about what you are producing, instead of just being a ENTER PRESSING entity. The amount of spaghetti that is being generated is not just an issue from the perspective "oh the code looks horrible to read", but also fundamentally how we build complicated systems, and it becomes bandages over bandages that just sucks and potentially fragile.

The alternative is don't go all gas, work strategically thinking a bit longer term like we always had in past, and maybe you loose little velocity in short term, but you are likely better off in long term.

AI is always ready to implement something, or generate code, and make decisions, and it will do whatever you ask it to do. However, to make right decisions you need to understand the problem/context etc etc. And that was always significant portion of work, and you can be little faster with that with AI, but I think that part is still kind of slow but we as industry are in denial about that, and just not doing that part that well anymore.

▲stinkbeetle 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> This is the EXACTLY the kind of BS you get. No, not asking you to stop using those tools. Its not 0 or 1 thing. Its not a choice between "all gas no brake" and "I wont use AI".

No, THIS is exactly the kind of BS you get. All that and you didn't answer the question at all. What exactly do you want?

> But maybe, just maybe, think a little about what you are producing, instead of just being a ENTER PRESSING entity. The amount of spaghetti that is being generated is not just an issue from the perspective "oh the code looks horrible to read", but also fundamentally how we build complicated systems, and it becomes bandages over bandages that just sucks and potentially fragile.

Yep, people do think about it. Don't you? Do you not like how others think about it, or do you not like the conclusions they reach? Would you rather they do something differently? Without the BS, let's hear it. What do you want?

▲lanstin a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You can go out and take a walk around the block/quad/building still. And come back knowing the exact prompt to use to find the true explanation for some puzzling data anomaly/code behavior/failure mode.

▲jimbokun a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> What does "lets think about it a bit" even mean though?

Don't push code no human has read into production.

▲stinkbeetle 21 hours ago | parent [-]

Well I asked the OP, but appreciate your opinion and contribution too.

> Don't push code no human has read into production.

So you don't want to do that in your production environments? Or do you want others to not do that in their production environments?

▲jimbokun 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Both.

▲wholinator2 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Surely those aren't the only two options though? What if "let's think about it a bit" is about your coworkers going head first into a design that you know will fail, and then maybe let's think about how we can do a better design before we lock in a shit one. The AI does build _exactly_ what you ask, whether it's a smart choice or not. Surely you can just automate that choice to the AI as well, why not? "Think about all the ways to design this and pick the best". But possibly we are being led blind into a tar pit. So maybe, just maybe, we can spend a seconds of our lives to try to involve our human domain knowledge and hard won expertise at this job and its systems to guide the AI in a more productive route. Or is this scenario really just about slowing down everyone around you because you're secretely an indignant, neolithic, asshole.

▲stinkbeetle 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> Surely those aren't the only two options though?

(EDIT) I didn't mean to imply those as only two options, just points of a spectrum.

> What if "let's think about it a bit" is about your coworkers going head first into a design that you know will fail, and then maybe let's think about how we can do a better design before we lock in a shit one. The AI does build _exactly_ what you ask, whether it's a smart choice or not. Surely you can just automate that choice to the AI as well, why not? "Think about all the ways to design this and pick the best". But possibly we are being led blind into a tar pit. So maybe, just maybe, we can spend a seconds of our lives to try to involve our human domain knowledge and hard won expertise at this job and its systems to guide the AI in a more productive route. Or is this scenario really just about slowing down everyone around you because you're secretely an indignant, neolithic, asshole.

Having different perspectives and advocating for what you think works best, how to use tools, how to approach problems, has always been a thing and always will be. People where I work have a lot of different ways of using AI and share ideas and techniques, for example. Telling someone to not do what they have found to work with things like "let's think about it a bit" doesn't work though, that's not collaborative, you don't just tell others to stop and think, you have to actually do some thinking yourself and come up with constructive ideas. Doomsaying or vaguely handwaving at how bad things might be doesn't work either. It's like telling farmers they shouldn't sow their crops because you're concerned the gods might be angry and smite the village so they should stop and think about it a bit.

The reality is that AI is a very productive tool and it is never going to be stopped now. Bad things could come of using AI, bad things could come of not using AI, a bad thing could happen when you walk down the street tomorrow. A lot of people are scared by it, but really just saying things like "let's think about it a bit" betrays the lack of thought that has gone in to understanding why other people use it and how people react to that kind of thing in general. Not really surprising OP has seen a bit of apathy or hostility to their message.

▲Tanjreeve 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I think ops point is the tools are irrelevant. What comes out is the only thing that matters. Making grandiose assumptions about the arc of history is the job of pundits and linkedin influencers.

▲dfdydx a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Everyone is paid to solve problems. If the things that make you stand out at solving problems compared to the average worker is writing code, this no longer being a moat is probably not good for your bargaining power.

▲stavros a day ago | parent [-]

The things that make me stand out at solving problems is that I can effectively convince machines to solve problems at massive scales.

▲rayiner a day ago | parent | next [-]

Okay, but what about all the guys whose marketable skill was just being able to connect database A to data sink B? Maybe these folks are underrepresented on HN. But there’s a lot of people who work on this sort of software.

▲Tanjreeve 16 hours ago | parent | next [-]

To me this makes AI sound more and more like the cloud. There was a lot of generic busywork before clouds got big too. But ETL at the level "lift and shift data" has been a solved problem for a decade or so now. But picking up commodity work has always been low effort high risk in career terms.

▲stavros a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah, there are tons of those people, and I'm afraid they're going to go the way of the weavers after the loom was invented. I don't think there's a way to put that genie back in the bottle, sadly...

▲sylos 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Everyone is now a member of the weaving business. AI exists to solve wages.

▲larodi a day ago | parent | prev [-]

in this regard we've been all wearing AI-generated textile for 200+ years now. come to think about it, humanity somehow survived, and it was so profitable a business for millennia, that people fought wars over its detail...

▲thmoonbus a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Do you know how many people “that sort of software” displaced just a few decades ago? Probably a lot…

▲dfdydx 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I’d wager a lot of people not from software engineering will be just as good or better than software engineers for that, if only because most problems in business are business problems: Joe from accounting with a solid understanding of accounting and passable prompting might be better at solving accounting problems with AI than John the dev with limited accounting understanding but great effectiveness at pointing the AI towards wrong problems.

▲weatherlite 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah A.I is pretty good at that

▲jimbokun a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Now everyone can.

▲cluckindan a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I know the incantations to summon the daemon and bend it to my will.

▲dfdydx 14 hours ago | parent [-]

There are a lot more people able to do that than there were able to code.

▲bootwoot a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I actually think a wide majority of SWEs, pre-AI, were in fact primarily paid to write code.

Most people don't do this for the love of the game.

Large corporations needed java code as a means to an end and an army of workers needed a paycheck. That dynamic is coming to an end.

▲marcus_holmes a day ago | parent [-]

This. The JIRA mills where folks log in, say "no blockers" in a half-hour standup, fix an endless stream of tickets, then log off and go do what they actually want to do. That's over, thankfully.

▲debugnik a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Many SWEs will not be paid to solve problems anymore due to AI. The ones that remain might be better equipped for the task, although I don't expect interests to align on doing a better job instead of a cheaper one.

▲kelnos a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's room for nuance there. I am well aware that the goal is to solve problems, but I actively enjoy the process of designing a program and writing the code.

Sure, maybe I can more effectively and efficiently solve problems by driving an LLM instead, but that's not a job I enjoy, or even care to do professionally.

▲gojiberries a day ago | parent | next [-]

System design has always been the most important and interesting part of software development. Now you can do that at a scale never seen before, it’s awesome.

That being said, software (written by hand) has replaced many craftsmen. It’s a bit hypocritical to bemoan AI taking away our need to write code line by line. It’s what we’ve been doing to others since the first computer started computing.

▲detourdog 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The question is how much software needs to be that scaleable? Besides graphics presentation most human problems wouldn’t scale past an 8 bit computer.

▲bluecheese452 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

No it hasn’t.

▲marcus_holmes a day ago | parent | next [-]

There used to be whole rooms of clerks doing double-entry book-keeping at every bank branch.

There used to be "typing pools", whole floors of mostly women who typed handwritten and dictated notes up into actual documents that could be filed and distributed.

I heard this week that there used to be seven draughtsmen per architect, and now there's one draughtsperson per seven architects.

So, yes, software has completely replaced entire careers. We can't really grumble when it's our turn.

▲somenameforme a day ago | parent | next [-]

Computers [1] themselves are perhaps the best example. Digital computers were so completely effective at obsoleting human computers that I think most don't even realize this used to be a profession, though it's quite obvious if you think about it. When even just relatively basic calculations would have taken so much time, nobody would have ever been able to get anything done if they were having to constantly do all the 'computing' themselves.

I suspect programming will be similarly forgotten in the future when any program can be concocted trivially and efficiently by description alone.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_(occupation)

▲marcus_holmes 20 hours ago | parent [-]

Well, we'll still have folks hobby-coding, because some of us enjoy doing that.

Much like potters used to be a profession that was needed in every community, and now they're "ceramic artists"

▲bluecheese452 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Was replying to the first part.

▲wholinator2 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

It's amazing how people tend to view their personal experience as the norm. Even down to interests.

▲tempest_ a day ago | parent | prev [-]

That can be interesting but LLMs can do system design fine. Sure it can make crap but it doesn't take 10 years of experience to learn the 50 or some prompt variations to get it to sort things out. As time goes on those will be baked into the harness.

People on hacker news like to think they are Picasso but the reality is 50% as good in 5% of the time has always been better from the business perspective.

▲threetonesun a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

SWEs also often forget that most of the software they create was designed to take jobs away from other people in other departments.

▲cheesewhistle a day ago | parent | next [-]

The frame often is positioned to include yourself and your own interests at the center of it.

▲pydry a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

When a pawn on a chessboard takes a piece is do you blame the pawn or the chess player?

Software devs were guilty of wanting one of the few middle class jobs left. Nobody enters the profession cackling evilly about how many jobs they will take.

▲gojiberries a day ago | parent | next [-]

> Nobody enters the profession cackling evilly about how many jobs they will take.

Capital has historically and enthusiastically done exactly that.

▲MatekCopatek a day ago | parent [-]

The parent comment isnt trying t9 deny that, they're just saying the employer should be held accountable more than the worker.

▲somenameforme a day ago | parent [-]

You think the employer just signed up to the evil club before starting his business? People start businesses because they have a neat idea or because they hope to make a better life for themselves. No different than a worker except in the path taken.

The reality is humanity itself pushes forward in a way that often steamrolls those who don't keep up. Nobody's driving the steamroller intentionally, yet it invariably inches forward nonetheless.

▲Timwi 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> You think the employer just signed up to the evil club before starting his business?

Yes, and you've even explained why:

> People start businesses [...] because they hope to make a better life for themselves.

Not for anyone else — for themselves. They do this by exploiting others.

▲somenameforme 21 hours ago | parent [-]

This doesn't even make any coherent sense. I have a bunch of apple trees in my back yard. I hire a a few guys to go harvest them and then sell them to a bakery which eventually turns them into apple pies, who in the world is getting exploited?

People can be exploitative, but there's nothing inherent about it any position or another. Taking money for labor you intentionally half ass is no less exploitative than e.g. some employer trying to undercut somebody's pay or whatever.

▲arximboldi 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

can the people that harvest the apple trees afford a house with a backyard large enough for a bunch of apple trees? perhaps exploitation has too overreaching connotations, but there is an inherent imbalance of power in the relationship that leads to systemic inequalities.

▲tarsierscripter 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Without ownership of property you just have a commons, where everyone picks all the apples off the trees, and then someone comes along with an axe and cuts the trees down for firewood, and then there's no more apples or apple pie for anyone.

▲somenameforme 16 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You're making a lot of assumptions about the owner that often don't really pan out. For example I have less than zero love for the Waltons but Walmart is just such a great example. Their gross profit margin is about 24%. That's how much they profit on each item sold. But then after you factor in their operating costs, labor in particular, it's down to 3%.

So the Walton's money printing button comes from taking 3 pennies from each dollar, but at a very high volume. If Walmart wanted to e.g. significantly raise the wages they pay, they'd have to substantially increase the prices on everything sold. The balance of higher wages for some but higher costs for all would almost certainly be a significant net-loss for the lower half of society.

And this issue is even more pervasive at smaller shops. Making ends meet is even harder for small business owners. The idea that somebody's just printing money because they own a business is unrealistic. Well it's kind of true for tech businesses, but I suspect we're going to see that change in the future - though that's another topic altogether.

▲Timon3 10 hours ago | parent [-]

I think it's telling that you're pointing at Walmart's margin without pointing out 1) what percentage of the operating costs are down to labor, and 2) how much wages could be raised using those 3%.

Like, just because the Walmart owners own a company in a low-margin high-volume sector, they're suddenly entitled to the 3% profit, while the employees often need government assistance to keep themselves afloat...?

▲somenameforme 9 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm not saying their percent of labor costs because it's not public information. It's buried in operating expenses, but it's going to be the majority of their costs, by a wide margin. Fortunately your other question is much easier to answer. WalMart's 3% profit margin is about $21 billion. Coincidentally they also have 2.1 million employees. So the math works out perfectly - a one-time raise of about $10k per year per employee, at which point the business would be unprofitable and no longer sustainable.

The margins in non-tech businesses are not at all like most people think. They're slim with massive sounding outcomes (like $21 billion a year in profit) coming exclusively from scale. Redistribute that back to the employees to the point of self destruction and it's certainly a substantial amount, but far below the level many seem to think.

The irony is that it's the companies that people think are 'generous' that are hoarding massive amounts of $$$. Apple makes something close to a million dollars in profit per employee, so they could afford to literally buy every single one of their employees a new Ferrari, every single year, and still be rolling in profit. But these sort of insane tech margins are not normal. More controversially, I think they're also not sustainable in the longrun - and the longrun just got a whole lot closer with LLMs.

▲Timon3 9 hours ago | parent [-]

> I'm not saying their percent of labor costs because it's not public information. It's buried in operating expenses, but it's going to be the majority of their costs, by a wide margin.

So that would be what, 60-70%? IMO that's wildly unrealistic, I'd need to see actual evidence to believe they are so far off the norm.

> WalMart's 3% profit margin is about $21 billion. Coincidentally they also have 2.1 million employees. So the math works out perfectly - a one-time raise of about $10k per year per employee, at which point the business would be unprofitable and no longer sustainable.

How is a company that's breaking even no longer sustainable?

▲somenameforme 7 hours ago | parent [-]

60% of your operating expenses being labor is pretty typical for a labor heavy industry, and WalMart's kind of the epitome of labor heavy with some 2.1 million workers. Their most recent reported operating expense was $148billion. If we assume 50% of that's labor that'd imply an average labor cost per employee of 148,000 * 0.5 / 2.1 = $35k. That's likely a significant lowball figure so the typical 60%+ is a reasonable ballpark.

The reason that breakeven companies aren't sustainable is because there's variance in most things, certainly including sales. WalMart's net profit margin varies from around 1% to 3%, so they're currently at a 'high'. Cut that down by 3% and you literally don't have enough money to pay your employees next year when you swing low. Let alone little niceties like performance incentives, raises, etc.

I think people just don't intuit how huge the world is and so how bizarre things get at scale. If you could earn just $1 from every person on Earth you'd be a multi billionaire. Even if you just limit yourself to Europe and the US, you'd be a billionaire. This sounds absurd, but it's true. It's because our intuition is just worthless for sufficiently big numbers.

▲pydry 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>have a bunch of apple trees in my back yard. I hire a a few guys to go harvest them and then sell them to a bakery which eventually turns them into apple pies, who in the world is getting exploited?

No matter how cute you try to make it sound, when one person owns the land and the other person works it in exchange for pay it's the person working it who is exploited.

Some people like to hand wave the question of who owns land and why they own it away but control of that wealth is always rooted in historic violence.

▲somenameforme 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You've yet to explain how or why anybody is being exploited, and instead are just engaging in circular logic-> 'employment is exploitation' -> 'how is this employment exploiting anybody?' -> 'because employment is exploitation.'

You can take away any and all land. Imagine somebody thinks a public park is in nasty shape, so they hire a few guys to go help them clean it up. Is that still exploiting people? This all just makes no coherent sense whatsoever.

▲pydry 6 hours ago | parent [-]

unequal land ownership is what made employment exploitative in that example.

capitalism is founded on the divide between those who work for a living and those who own for a living.

governments pay people to clean parks. it's not something a private citizen would typically ever do.

▲badpun 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Take two people. One saved for 30 years and bought a small piece of land. The other one partied for 30 years, and always spent his entire surplus and ends up with no capital. It's true that now the saver can "exploit" whoever rents from him, but at the cost of previously exploiting himself during the previous 30 years to build capital.

▲danhodgins 8 hours ago | parent [-]

Third guy had a silver spoon, didn't have to work to build capital, and spent the next 30 years partying with the other guy.

▲badpun 8 hours ago | parent [-]

That's an issue with inheritance, not capitalism.

▲threetonesun a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Some did. Many pled willful ignorance because computers were fun to tinker with. Given some of the terms outlined in this IPO I feel like anyone who made a lot of money today did so cackling.

▲dzonga 10 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

in my 30ish years of existence I haven't seen software take away people's jobs. transform yeah but take way jobs ?

unless when combined with robots.

▲andersonpico a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've always said that software developers are the perfect middle class for capital: they never fight for their own interests and find it fun to put down their peers as a pastime. Even then, capital came gunning for them and then what did they do? Beg "HARDER, I'M NOT LIKE THE OTHER WORKERS". It's incredible really.

▲georgemcbay a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> SWEs also often forget that most of the software they create was designed to take jobs away from other people in other departments.

Often maybe, but not always.

Avoiding displacing human labor that doesn't want to be displaced is always something I've thought about before any job I've taken.

No putting clankers before humans, no grifts, scams, pushing ads, gambling or incentivizing other forms of addictive behavior.

Fairly simple rules to live by, though it does mean there are entire major companies (and entire market categories of companies) I could never work for in good conscience.

I do find the fact that AI is disrupting us software developers first and foremost seems karmically fitting in general.

▲Peaches4Rent a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm an swe who opposes AI. I don't think we should be spending so much non-renewable sources of energy on AI. These energy sources are taking from our future.

▲nl 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm very pro-AI but I also think we should be using this opportunity for energy transition.

Some countries are making laws about renewables requirements for datacenters. Generally they are structured as "gas is allowed as a backup but there are big fines if it is used more than X days a year", and then let the market decide what mix of solar + wind + batteries wins.

The US should do this too.

▲AgentME a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A developer's energy use from AI is generally tiny compared to their energy use from driving or eating meat.

▲mcv a day ago | parent | next [-]

Those are also things we should do less, but they're more ingrained and it's a lot harder to get people to stop doing that. Requiring green energy for all those data centers seems a lot more feasible, and would still help a lot.

▲bobsomers a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

An individual's use is low, but when everyone's use is concentrated in a few communities it absolutely destroys those communities for the people that live there.

▲adwn 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

That sounds like hyperbole to me. Which communities have been "absolutely destroyed" by an AI data center? I take "absolutely destroyed" to imply "literally unlivable", so if a community isn't literally unlivable, it can't have been absolutely destroyed.

▲AlphaCerium 12 hours ago | parent [-]

There's a lot of misinformation about data centers, and they're absolutely not "stealing our water", but operators frequently pollute water supplies through negligence, and the constant drone of generator noise is literally unliveable I would say. Claude found these articles for me with only a cursory search, so take them with a grain of salt, but there are real cases of them being a blight on communities. https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B1600/how-data... https://www.forbes.com/sites/victoriaforster/2026/07/09/meta... https://www.wftv.com/news/i-literally-just/UU6AMKIYRM6JLBTX7...

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲vips7L a day ago | parent | prev [-]

What aboutism. You should stop eating meat too.

▲AgentME a day ago | parent [-]

I've skipped a few burgers this year. That will have made a bigger difference in my energy footprint than me using AI or not.

▲anonreplier a day ago | parent | next [-]

have you tho

▲vips7L a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Great now never eat a burger again and lmk.

▲preg_match a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The energy used by AI is, frankly, negligible. The water too. It’s a rounding error as compared to agriculture and manufacturing. The water use of all AI data centers combined doesn’t even reach the change in water usage over the past year for agriculture. Never mind the base usage, which is orders of magnitude greater.

Moreover, big picture, software is getting built anyway. It’s not like if you don’t use AI then that energy use is gone. You need devs no matter what.

▲scott_weber an hour ago | parent | next [-]

For now. Atm all compute is like 1% of global energy usage. Until hyper scalers want to 100x their energy spend, which they'll might need to get AGI (to get a step change in capability for along scaling law lines, you need both 10x model size and 10x training data, 100x as much computation. They probably want at least 2 more step changes, so even assuming they 100x efficiency again, there's another 100x that needs raw compute hence energy). Then we're doubling global energy usage.

▲whiplash451 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

AI is a rounding error next to steel, cement, chemicals and food but calling its energy usage negligible is wrong in two ways: (1) it’s one of the fastest-growing sources of demand, and grid planning is driven by growth, not by share (2) it's highly concentrated -- in places like Ireland or Northern Virginia, data centres already use a double-digit share of local electricity.

▲CamperBob2 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Success at developing AI will save more energy than you can imagine. Half the cars on the road won't need to be there, if nothing else.

Edit: never mind what you don't want to see happen: what do you want to see happen?

▲platevoltage 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Half the cars on the road already don't need to be there. We put more resources into bootleg taxicabs and driverless vehicles than a functioning transit system.

▲defrost 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That's the upside of broadscale destruction of livelihoods, sure.

▲shakna a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Most of the SWEs I see opposing AI, are opposing it because it doesn't solve the problem. It creates patches that introduce more problems, faster, than if they just did it themselves.

▲denkmoon a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I’m paid to be a meat proxy because our problems are trivial. The only thing i offer is writing the prompts that say “implement this” and “you overcomplicated x, make it simpler” occasionally including the way I want it fixed. Important steps in the process and skill and experience still help not pushing slop but I’m not really “solving problems” anymore.

▲hirvi74 a day ago | parent [-]

You are solving the problem of someone else having to do that exact task.

That is why I think AI is more of a service than a tool.

I am not sure what real problem my barber is solving. I am physically capable of using scissors and clippers and learning how to cut my own hair. But at the end of the day, I rather just pay someone trustworthy to do it instead.

The money I pay is worth it for me to not have to deal with any of the previously mentioned tasks.

▲elcritch a day ago | parent | next [-]

> I am not sure what real problem my barber is solving. I am physically capable of using scissors and clippers and learning how to cut my own hair. But at the end of the day, I rather just pay someone trustworthy to do it instead.

That's a great point. It's easy to forget. I can also make food at home, but often prefer going out for convenience, skill, etc.

▲denkmoon 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

While I agree with what you’re saying and see the logic of it, it’s not exactly satisfying :/

▲ravenstine a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

SWEs aren't paid to solve problems (most of the time). They are paid because they are a necessary evil sitting between product owners and revenue. It doesn't actually matter that much if problems are solved. Their goal is to increase revenue, and there is not a linear correlation between solving problems and making revenue. Business leaders would absolutely love it if they could take a dump and have enough people buy their shit and eat it while not having to pay for the SWEs that they see as middle-men. If SWEs were paid merely to solve problems, the world would be a much different place. Corporate software engineering in the 2020s is as much about solving problems as advertising is about communicating the merits of a product.

▲dmz73 a day ago | parent [-]

Every single person, every product, every single "cost centre", everything is the necessary evil between "owners" and revenue. We should just optimize it all away and let "owners" print their money to infinity since that is the only thing they value and there is no need for anyone else to stand in their way by reducing their revenue. Of course, their money will be worthless but why is that a problem, they have it all! On the other hand, if you take the view that "economy" and therefore companies and products exist to help people then value != money. SWEs as they exist now already belong to 2 groups - "code shovellers" and problem solvers - same as any profession. LLMs can be used to shovel more code or help solve problems, most people will just shovel code (just look at python or javascript ecosystems) and few will continue to solve problems. Once LLMs can shovel code well enough then they will replace all other "code shovellers" but LLMs will never be able to solve problems, at least not on the same level as people. But I am sure that will not stop "owners" from thinking they can so every profession will be obsolete. Then there are two alternatives - everyone becomes a slave or we enter "Star Trek" style universe. I know which alternative is more likely (remember "Star Trek" is fiction).

▲Timwi 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> remember "Star Trek" is fiction

But so are all the cyber enslavement stories.

▲8n4vidtmkvmk 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't mind solving problems with AI. I'm worried about getting fired because they think they can do the job without me entirely.

▲croes a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

SWEs where paid to solve problems by writing code.

Solving problems is not distinctive characteristic of a software engineer, doing it by writing code was.

▲ravenstine a day ago | parent [-]

"Solving problems" is a meaningless thing to say, and seems to be the next evolution of "full-stack engineer". It's a result of dissolving what used to be a specialty with its own subspecialties. Make the role of an engineer as generic as possible so they become interchangeable, easier to replace, and eliminated when possible.

Plenty of software engineers are paid to not solve problems. Some are, but I would say that most are paid to do the thing. Orgs beyond the startup phase don't actually like problem solving because it introduces risk of instability. Just doing the thing isn't the same thing as solving problems. Business leaders would be very happy if they could eliminate the human from the doing the thing step, and not all of us can simply become the problem solvers because that's infeasible.

▲pesus a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We certainly solved the problem of companies having to hire as many of us or pay us as well.

▲vkou a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Some people resent that the problems they used to solve were technical, but overnight, turned into managerial.

▲0c3ca83 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

People who write comments like this forget that the product AI is selling is automated problem solving. In fact, generalized superhuman problem solving is the only way to justify their valuation.

Your comment is stating a belief that Anthropic will fail as a business.

▲pydry a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If only. AI pilled SWEs seem to have not noticed that the only problem "building agents nobody needs" is solving is how to satisfy an investor with FOMO.

I never thought I'd miss the days when executives used to rabbit on about customer obsession but the new fashion of AI psychosis is worse in just about every way.

▲rewgs 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I hate this comment.

AI-pilled folks seem to forget that SWEs are paid to develop _software_, which last time I checked was made from code.

No one merely "solves problems" in a vacuum. You have to engage with a domain, a medium, and the tools of both.

▲MiiMe19 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

born just in time to watch the singular thing i enjoy in life get automated away. I guess i get to be like every other person now and hate my job.

▲gmassman 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If you only liked the “writing code” part of software engineer, then maybe software engineering just isn’t the right thing for you. Luckily now is also the best time ever to explore alternative career paths! One of the amazing things about AI is how it’s lowering the barrier of entry into new fields.

FWIW I love not having to spend so much time writing code. I get to focus on solving problems for end users, which is way more fun and rewarding IMO.

▲MiiMe19 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I enjoyed getting to solve problems elegantly and I still believe, even if it is old fashioned, that writing and understanding good code is essential to building the abstractions for and design of a good product. Except for maybe things like webdev, where looks good ~= is good, I feel like humans writing code is still the best way to do things, but I feel like I am in a growing minority and might just need to drop the field and become a welder or whatever.

It wasn't so much coding that I loved, although I do love that, but being able to build and understand something far greater than myself, and the puzzle of trying to find the right abstractions and tools to make something beautiful.

▲rewgs 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> If you only liked the “writing code” part of software engineer, then maybe software engineering just isn’t the right thing for you.

Boy am I getting tired of reading this sentence.

You make it sound like the only thing that's gone away is the physical act of entering characters -- completely ignoring the fact that working through the problem and wrestling with the code (which included, among other things, typing it) were one and the same. Removing the "writing code" part and expecting the other parts to remain is just as sensible as believing that you can remove a swimmer from the water and expect them to keep their physique.

"Writing code" was one of the most important _mediums_ through which we practiced _deep thought_ about programs. It wasn't just typing.

> FWIW I love not having to spend so much time writing code...

Sounds like maybe software engineering isn't for you? Or rather, wasn't? You're lucky that the "one thing" you don't like about your career was removed. Try and approach those of us who are in the opposite situation with a bit more tact and compassion than "Luckily now is also the best time ever to explore alternative career paths!" What an absurd, tone-deaf thing to say.

▲MiiMe19 17 hours ago | parent [-]

I pretty much agree with the part about wrestling with the code. I'm not opposed to ai, but when I use it I use it as another opponent to wrestle against. Not as something to pump out code. AI has a place in software engineering, but I really think that, justifed or not, the way people think of and use AI at the moment is both less fun for me and detrimental to creating a good product as a whole.

There have been many times recently where, by choosing not to have ai generate code that at first glance seemed like it would be repetitive and boring, I have developed much better and more elegant abstractions for what I was trying to do because by working through the code and wrestling with the problem I found a better way to do it.

▲gmassman 7 hours ago | parent [-]

I appreciate both of your sentiment that we’re losing the human craftsmanship and connection to the code. I got into writing software because I like you also appreciate clean abstractions and puzzling out the best way to get the job done. I find your use of the phrase “wrestling with the code” particularly notable, because it’s struggle that leads us to understanding.

However, I don’t believe (and never really did believe) that writing code is the only means to understanding how to build good programs. I think best in prose and pictures, so writing requirements docs and thinking through abstractions with component diagrams has been my preferred way to work for years. Maybe I am the lucky one…

Apologies for causing any upset, I really do not wish to cause ill feelings. I want to see our field of software engineering flourish, and if that means trading a screwdriver for a chisel I’m all for it.

▲RAWGOD 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>singular thing i enjoy in life

If coding was it, you have a more serious problem than AI

▲NonHyloMorph 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The person you replied that to spoke for themselves, I still want to add to this from my perspective: I find this to be quite judgemental and also not a reply in good faith. Regarding the latter: To me it's kind of clear that the statement is made with a certain hyperbole. To blame someone for not dissociating the work they do from their existence, in a somewhat cynic acceptance of the equating of work and labour, and that in a way, where the formulaic way the statement is put forward being suggestive of a common sense of normative agreement, reminds of the "discourse" along the lines of the commentsection in feed. And to me that's not exactly high minded and as legit as you trying to make it sound. Someone conceiving of what they do for a big, if not the biggest, part of time in this life as a profession and not just another job, is in my perception considered as an ideal (you might not share it and that's fine). To do as I preach here: I see a point in pointing out that it might be reasonable to address the misery that the hyperbole implies, with a different lever then trying to find a solution to the potential vanishing of said profession, since at this point in time, it's fair to at least consider the possibility, that fading away might indeed be its fate. Decided to articulate my sentiment, just to give backing to the person behind the anonymity of this platform, in the face of the sort of automatic discoursivity (as I perceive it, might also just be you..) that that arises from the (un-)culture a commentsection seems to evoke habitually sometimes.

edited some typos

▲MiiMe19 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What can I say, I liked my job.

(I'm excluding trivial, hedonistic things from what I enjoy)

▲gdorsi a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The real goal, however, will always be to solve real-world problems. Engineering consists of whatever gets you there most effectively.

Love this statement, 100% agree.

▲larodi a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

me also remembers when c++ was thought slow, so we were doing a mixture of C and assembly. it took my friends years to agree to java, then it took him 15 more to understand JS works better for him. happily it took him only 2 years (of convincing) that he should try LLMs and he's not so stubborn anymore :D

▲dingdongditchme 16 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

...and safely. Engineering has strong and rightful tradition in safety. Perhaps it is many times not as crucial as in the medical profession, but it is very important for engineers to understand and be able to mitigate risks that are associated with whatever they are building. You don't want your bridges to collapse or planes to fall out of the sky afterall.

▲NonHyloMorph 15 hours ago | parent [-]

It's not like engineering wouldn't do some heavy lifting in the domain of medicine.. Would you trust a machine learning system with producing a platform for robotically assisted laparoscopic surgery? What about running the whole process of developing medication (including pre-clinical safety testing?)(latter depending on whether you see pharmacology and biochemical engineering as belonging to the domain of engineering ofc). Funny thing on the side: Met a person once who was tasked with avoiding injuries through brown ice, by having a planes internal it system keep track of where they are and anticipate pressure on the system that might necessitate.. releasing that planes pressure mid-air, lol.

▲dingdongditchme 14 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't know what brown ice is. Sounds interesting though. When I talk of engineering, software engineering is only a small subdomain but yes medical devices are notorious for their... let's call it tongue in cheek "safety moat" ;-)

▲Pokepokalypse 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>I'm old enough to remember . . .

yep

▲mitxela 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Every higher level brought worse craftsmanship but more products. Nobody programs like Mel, they don't need to make Blackjack run on 2k drum memory but the same lack of mindset makes PC video games 300GB big.

They're still relevant sometimes. ffmpeg core encode/decode routines are written in multiple different assembly languages. These very same LLMs run on highly optimized code on purpose-designed hardware (!) with plenty of symbolic manipulation to find the optimal execution routines.

3/5

▲0c3ca83 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm old enough to call you on your bullshit.

The best you can find is people claiming that it would reduce the amount of assembly people write, which was true. They also predicted programmers would lose their low level understanding of the machine. That was also true. They didn't predict anything about making human thought non-viable economically. And not one C compiler vendor said their product could cause human extinction.

If AI predictions have the same level of truth as C compiler predictions, then the doomers are right.

▲AnimalMuppet a day ago | parent [-]

So what, specifically, are you calling them on?

▲defrost a day ago | parent [-]

I can't speak for them, however:

   compiled languages like C were bemoaned by people because their skill at crafting assembly by hand was suddenly less important. 
doesn't ring a bell from the time I went through that transition; people used C and FORTRAN and happily dropped back into handcrafted assembler as needed, and applauded the fully assembler works of some, etc - but nobody (in my recollection, was seriously bemoaning compilers and calling for a return to 100% assembler).

   similarly with people who were brilliant with arithmetic, or symbolic manipulation, or manual drafting/lettering. 
My mother was a computer, she didn't pine for the days of rows of meat computers; I took drafting as part of engineering and worked to assist and eventually replace drafting rooms for cartography- that was a slow rotation out and perhaps had the greatest impact of all the things listed- but people weren't exactly clawing to have their ink stain jobs back.

Symbolic manipulation is an interesting one - I recall a general distrust of Monster Group proofs so large they involved software generation and checkers ... but things are still advancing through that same distrust with lean and so on. What I did see is "symbol manipulators" diving into creating automated symbolic algebra suites such as Cayley (now Magma) and still using them today to crack Quantum encryption candidates, etc.

ie. It comes over a bit hyperbolic

The points of significant difference between Ye Olde Days and now is the numbers (absolute and proportional) of people affected, the speed with which they are affected, and the availability of related and meaningful work into which they can transition.

▲complex_pi a day ago | parent | prev [-]

AI does not help stopping wars, ending poverty, solving climate wars.

▲scott_w a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I feel the same way. The discussion on commoditising programming skills has been going on since before I left school and what we saw was demand, and pay, skyrocket as accessibility of the profession increased. I believe it’s possible that making it more accessible makes problems that were uneconomical to even explore quite challenging but achievable.

▲roosterIllusi0n a day ago | parent | next [-]

The issue is that CEOs are allowed to grift. They can cut wages, under staff, and outsource to make themselves personally richer.

We had prevented this for 20 years in the 1950s and 60s with a 90% federal tax bracket that capped yearly incomes to $5 mil a year in 2026 dollars. Stock buybacks were illegal and we had a bunch more post-1929 regulations that were not gutted yet.

Restore the tax policy and financial regulations of the 1950s. CEOs would be stopped immediately. This is how we got out of the great depression.

▲rayiner a day ago | parent | next [-]

The 1950s and 1960s weren’t a golden age because of taxes. It was because America had no competition after World War II. In 1950, Europe’s industrial base was destroyed. And there were basically no industrialized nations outside Europe. You couldn’t outsource jobs to China, you couldn’t buy sophisticated products from Japan, etc. That gave American workers enormous leverage. You can’t bring that back just by taxing CEOs.

▲bluecheese452 a day ago | parent [-]

These are policy choices.

▲rayiner a day ago | parent | next [-]

They are the exact opposite of “policy choices.” They are geopolitical realities. In 1950, European companies couldn’t compete with IBM’s scale, and basically nobody outside the U.S. and Europe could build a commercial computer. The policy choices were downstream of that geopolitical reality.

On top of that: in the 1950s, you had 9 workers to tax per retiree, compared to 2.7 today. You had vast new suburbs being built in California. You had the industrialization of the south: in the 1930s, the income difference between Illinois and Arkansas was similar to the delta between the U.S. and Russia today. That gap started closing in the 1950s as the south industrialized, lifting a huge chunk of the country out of poverty.

▲bluecheese452 9 hours ago | parent [-]

My grandfather living in a bombed out communist European country was able to afford a house and 3 kids with no college education by 30. No IBM needed.

If we can’t afford the same in America with 80 years of additional technological progress and war never touching us that is a policy choice.

▲badpun 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Mine too. But, his wife also worked full-time six days a week, the house was a 40 sqft flat, and they (and everybody) were so poor, that e.g. had to save for months to buy a winter coat. But yeah, everybody who moved to a city eventually got a flat from the state (although the waiting list was sometimes two decades long). I doubt that Americans would be happy with such life though.

▲bluecheese452 an hour ago | parent [-]

Yeah mine had an actual house and his wife didn’t work. And that was life for a typical guy in a communist country. For americans life was way better.

But I guess this is just a fact of the world that life will be worse 80 years later. Somehow bombing europe made the average american and european rich. Not the post war policy choices.

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲rcpt a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The reason we got away with those brackets was because back then it was very easy to do a little paperwork and dodge taxes

▲woah a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is as invalid as arguing that the 50's were so good because segregation still existed.

Using the 1950's as a justification for policies you support is disingenuous because the real reason the 1950's were so good is because the USA had just won the largest war in history without any damage to the homeland and had the only industrial base that wasn't bombed out and exported a huge amount of manufactured goods to the entire world.

The policies you advocate would just privilege the existing holders of capital by making it impossible for anyone new to join their class. It would also lead to all manner of bizarre forms of perks, kickbacks, and other non-monetary forms of lifestyle benefits and power, sort of like you see in the ruling class in communist countries.

▲iqp a day ago | parent | next [-]

(West) Germany: Lost the war, every single city in ruins, yet emerged as an industrial powerhouse after WWII. Your argument just doesn't hold water.

▲quesera a day ago | parent [-]

Marshall Plan, so again: USA.

▲iqp a day ago | parent [-]

Disagree. The UK and France each received ~2x more money from the Marshall Plan than W. Germany yet the latter's economy grew faster. Source: https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R45079/..., page 8.

▲opo a day ago | parent [-]

West Germany had Ludwig Erhard. The UK did not.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_Erhard

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirtschaftswunder

▲nullstyle a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The interstate system did not get developed because the allies had just won WW2; It was built because the USA was in a cold war with the USSR. Your take on history is just as incomplete as GP's.

▲jordanb a day ago | parent | next [-]

It was actually built because Eisenhower had been on the US army's first attempt to cross the nation with a truck convoy when he was a junior officer.

It was a bit of a disaster.[1]

Then he saw the Autobahn in Germany.

He also was Sir Arthur Tedder's superior at SHAEF when Tedder developed the strategy to destroy Germany's railroads.[2]

It is not surprising that Eisenhower was committed to the creation of a national highway system.

Then you have him the reins of the massive public works machine built by the new dealers, and the interstate highway system is practically the inevitable result.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcontinental_Motor_Convoy

[2] https://uncpress.org/9780807858509/the-collapse-of-the-germa...

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> the 1950's were so good is because the USA had just won the largest war in history without any damage to the homeland

So why did the UK also see the emergence of a strong middle class which has since eroded?

▲lazyasciiart a day ago | parent | next [-]

Largely the same reason, I would guess. Millions of homes damaged, some infrastructure and factories damaged, ~50k civilian casualties total, and a touch under a million total casualties. Industrial output was not destroyed and was quickly repurposed to civilian benefit as society adjusted, and women were able to fill the labor needs.

▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent [-]

Yep, a labor power story in both cases.

▲BobaFloutist a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan#United_Kingdom

▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent [-]

So the UK government took out a bunch of debt and spent it on something other than war and capital gains tax cuts.

▲loeg a day ago | parent | prev [-]

The US gave the UK something like $8.8 billion in aid ($69B in 2019 dollars).

▲bs7280 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The day stock buy backs were legalized is the day our country switched from capitalisism to an oligarchy.

▲loeg a day ago | parent | next [-]

Buybacks are functionally equivalent to dividends. It literally does not matter.

▲dillondoyle a day ago | parent | next [-]

It matters greatly & it's not functionally equivalent.

stock owners gain a lot more from buybacks than dividends. Juice your gains. Die. Dont pay taxes.

Buybacks likely also increase liquidity/market efficiency which is a stock owners benefit [0] (companies buy when price is low to prop it up. increase liquidity. also sort of relevant to today i was learning how the ANT greenshoe works).

Even if you do eventually sell you've basically gotten an interest free loan from the govt in deferred taxes over your hold time. that's huge.

what matters more to me is that it probably drives inequality.

100% proven to definitely decrease tax take (found different sources from about ~400-850bb 10 years). That's universal pre-k + universal childcare. Or free community college + school meals for all. OR pfml + dental and hearing in medicare.

One study [1] compared the same person same stocks > taxable v. IRAs/401ks: "Effective accrual tax rates for stocks that experience substantial appreciation are substantially below the statutory tax rate on long-term gains." e.g. lower effective tax rates/ever shrinking revenue sources

the 1% tax in IRA barely makes a dent.

This study is a triple wammy of gross [2]:

- illustrative of executives who get comp in stock seem to be more likely to make selfish short-term stock price driven decisions - use last-minute buy backs to juice earnings (prob voids the put benefit) - at the expense of R&D and re-investing for innovation

" share repurchases that increase earnings per share (EPS) is sharply higher for firms that would have just missed the EPS forecast" "EPS-motivated repurchases are associated with reductions in employment and investment"

[0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2506671 [1] https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/00028280577501446... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03044...

▲matwood 10 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> stock owners gain a lot more from buybacks than dividends. Juice your gains. Die. Dont pay taxes.

This isn't a buyback issue, but a step-up basis issue.

▲Danox a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I bet you don’t like stock splits either.

▲derektank a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Also, buybacks have never been illegal. Stock manipulation is illegal and has been for nearly a century, but buybacks were never inherently illegal. They became more popular in the eighties when the SEC provided additional clarity on when buybacks were explicitly legal (such as when stock repurchases are below a certain percent of daily trading volume), and then they became more popular again in the 90s when capital gains taxes were cut.

So yeah, that is actually the one area where they’re not equivalent to dividends, tax treatment. Though that’s changed in the last twenty years as well as some dividends are no longer taxed as individual income.

▲barchar a day ago | parent | next [-]

Even with qualified dividends buybacks are much better from a taxation perspective because shareholders aren't being forced to take the income.

Buybacks will select for frequently traded shares that have little gains, as well (this is just another way to say the above).

Ofc the elephant in the room w.r.t. capital taxation is tax advantaged retirement accounts, which have much, much higher contribution caps than was ever intended (how many people can save 80k net per year? Not many). Something like 75% of all public equity (by value) is held in advantaged accounts and exempted from capital gains taxes completely.

▲Danox a day ago | parent | prev [-]

If they weren’t illegal up until 1982, they were greatly frowned upon, and most companies did not do it, but the Reagan era ushered in a new period. of manipulation.

https://boomersbrokeamerica.com/stock-buybacks-illegal-1982-...

https://www.investmentwatchblog.com/stock-buybacks-have-only...

▲Terr_ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If, as you say, it truly "does not matter", then we'd already be in a different world where:

1. Companies wouldn't have a preference for it.

2. Nobody would defend/lobby-for the practice.

▲matwood 10 hours ago | parent | next [-]

As a shareholder, I have a preference for buybacks so I can better control my tax exposure.

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲digitaltrees 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Companies have taken out debt to buy back stock. That literally takes future dividends from stockholders to boost stock prices that are the basis of executive pay immediately.

▲loeg 16 hours ago | parent [-]

Any dividend payment is a payment to current shareholders that takes away from future shareholders... duh?

▲digitaltrees 6 hours ago | parent [-]

By using debt a company is able to buy more shares than the cash on hand would allow thereby extending the time horizon of reduced profits. They pull future earnings into the present using debt to enrich themselves.

▲Danox a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I would rather have the dividend and pay taxes on it, a buyback just basically floats into outer space. Owner of some dividend paying stocks.

▲platevoltage 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No, it's just capitalism. No need to try to sanitize it.

▲runarberg a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Nahh, capitalism is fundamentally aristocratic, and thus will always trend towards oligarchy.

You may argue that regulations, such as banning of stock buy backs, could hinder such a trend, perhaps so, but over time the more capital and power accumulates, the more the laws and regulations will stack in favor of the capitalist class, ergo oligarchy.

▲Danox a day ago | parent [-]

Which was also one of the biggest reasons for deregulating the banking industry. Just an expansion of oligarchy.

▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Capitalism is a softmax function. It pushes with enormous, exponentially compounding strength towards concentrating wealth and power.

Buybacks are not necessary. The same exponential compounding happens just as easily with dividends or even just growth and a trusting valuation. It's the compounding r>g that is the problem.

▲oklahomasports a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You think .002% of people paying a 90% marginal rate explains the difference between our 2026 economy and the 1950 economy

▲loeg a day ago | parent [-]

And that the 1950 economy was in any way better! It's, uh, a take.

▲loeg a day ago | parent | prev [-]

This is a basically false narrative.

CEOs are allowed to do all of these things, but they do not necessarily maximize business returns, and therefore their own incentives. Nothing has changed here from 2020, 2015, or 2010 -- a period over which SWE compensation has skyrocketed. No reason to believe this gets worse with AI.

The 50s and 60s marginal tax rate was (1) mostly paid by no one; rich people instead received business income not subject to personal income tax; and (2) other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war. There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

It's easy to hate the rich and want to punish them for being rich, but it doesn't help the poor to do so.

▲tadfisher a day ago | parent | next [-]

"Punishing" the rich by making them pay higher taxes in order to fund programs that help the poor absolutely does help the poor. Some rich folks don't view this as a punishment, even.

▲loeg a day ago | parent | next [-]

This is a sleight of hand. The rich aren't rich enough to fund the kind of broad programs you're talking about, even if you punitively taxed them at 100% of assets.

▲triceratops 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Obviously taxing anyone at 100% of assets is wrong. But you're just repeating bad math.

The top 1% owns 50% of all public equities. The current US stock market's value is around $80 trillion. Taxing the 1% at 100% of assets would raise $40 trillion, even only counting their stakes in public companies.

The US federal government spent about $7 trillion last year. Only a tiny fraction of that is "broad social programs" that are funded out of general tax revenue (Social Security and Medicare have their own tax).

A more reasonable 1% of assets for the top 1% would net $400 billion annually (again only their public stock holdings). That's almost half the defence budget. And 1% is nothing; the stock market goes up 8% annually on average so they still come out ahead.

"Selling pressure" you say? Because the top 1% are liquidating 1% of their portfolio every year. Right.

Let them pay in shares and put the shares into a sovereign wealth fund. Black box, government gets no votes in any of the companies, whenever it needs some money and dividends don't cover it, the Treasury sells something at random.

▲Eisenstein 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Which programs are we talking about and how much would they cost?

▲rayiner a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The push to tax CEOs and billionaires is motivated by punishment, not because these are the biggest aggregate sources of revenue. AOC’s 70% tax rate proposal is projected to raise around $30 billion a year, which is a rounding error.

If the goal was “helping people,” you would raise money the same way European countries do: high taxes on the upper middle class. It’s a multi-trillion annual tax base that we refuse to appropriately tax.

In Ontario, income on capital gains is taxed at 23%. In California, the top long-term capital gains rate is 36% (13% state +23% federal). Canada isn’t paying for universal healthcare by “taxing billionaires.” It does so by charging people a 13% sales tax and very high marginal tax rates on the upper middle class (above $250k) from 46% in Ontario to 53% in BC.

▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Elon was bitching about paying $500M in taxes the other day on Twitter. He didn't mention that he's been stacking $200B a year and that he was complaining about paying 0.25% of that in taxes.

0.25% is what today's billionaires consider "punishing." Absolutely wild. Many of us pay tax at more than 100x that rate.

▲jethro_tell a day ago | parent [-]

Or that he paid the same amount to try to avoid having to pay taxes.

It’s not spending or even loosing the money, it’s helping other people that he hates.

▲ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲mattdeboard a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Taxes aren't punishment.

▲loeg a day ago | parent [-]

roosterIllusi0n wants them to be a punishment! See the great-grandparent comment.

▲mattdeboard 4 hours ago | parent [-]

That is your opinion based on a read that assumes persecution rather than a systemic solve for a systemic economic problem. Economic measures to curtail behaviors that introduce instability into the economy are not punishments.

▲ux266478 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> mostly paid by no one

Correct, because the mechanisms of capital were different and the system encouraged utilizing it for material investment and keeping labor happy, which is where that business income went.

> other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war

What alternate timeline did you come from where the 1960s was not a time of major cultural rift in the US? Do you think the upper middle class was not a huge source of hippies?

https://archive.org/details/CSPAN3_20180512_120000_Reel_Amer...

> There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

What? Wealth and income inequality was at its lowest since the founding of the country. An effect which was established prior to the involvement of the US in the war, it began with FDR's new deal. And once they hit the floor in the early 1940s, the numbers were extremely steady and consistent until the financial system overhaul in 1975 at which point they shoot right back up again. There is no reason? Every single metric disagrees with that, except for racial inequalities. Enough with the neoliberal apologism, Gordon Gekko. The empowerment of financiers has been an absolute disaster.

▲loeg a day ago | parent [-]

> What alternate timeline did you come from where the 1960s was not a time of major cultural rift in the US?

The 60s is the tail end of that period, yes. Tax rates were cut significantly in 1964.

> What? Wealth and income inequality was at its lowest since the founding of the country. An effect which was established prior to the involvement of the US in the war, it began with FDR's new deal.

And yet, the poorest 10-20% didn't have refrigeration, ~1/3 didn't have indoor plumbing, 6% didn't have electricity, they had almost no healthcare to speak of, and many actually went hungry. The poor today are much better off -- inequality does not actually make their material conditions worse.

▲ux266478 5 hours ago | parent [-]

> The 60s is the tail end of that period, yes

The 60s is special because it was a great period of cultural divide, I pointed it out specifically because you were painting the period as a time of national unity, indicating you don't actually know what you're talking about. But the idea of a strong national unity is, in general, just rose tinted goggles and historical ignorance even beyond the 60s. It was the absurdity of explicitly using that decade as an example that deserved pointing out, because it demonstrates either ignorance or dishonesty in the argument to the highest degree.

> And yet, the poorest 10-20% didn't have refrigeration, ~1/3 didn't have indoor plumbing, 6% didn't have electricity

Also almost nobody had air conditioning.

Anyways, these are all drastically lower from what they were in the 1920s. Is that because the system prior to the New Deal couldn't distribute them? No, even though the system was measurable worse as far as equality is concerned. Even discounting the geographical confounding factor here, the build out existed and at a higher rate across the population, not just in the long tails. These numbers changed (though miraculously, still haven't hit 0, or even a vanishingly small number) in spite of a different system, which measurably was actually worse. Or were you actually going to elaborate on why this percentile was ONLY capable of receiving these amenities after the economic overhaul in spite of the clear trend of change pre-existing the overhaul? That's a rhetorical question.

> they had almost no healthcare to speak of

Access to healthcare has become worse, actually, not better. Virtually every single working family, not living in the middle of nowhere, had access to healthcare in the 1950s and 60s. That is no longer the case. Simultaneous to this, rural access to healthcare never really improved.

At the end of the day we have to consider your argument has now mutated into the idea that the absolute poorest are better off because the richest are richer. Relatively speaking, they seem be much worse off as a matter of fact. Your causality simply isn't justified, it doesn't even correlate, and when given the slightest scrutiny, all the arguments can't hold water without disingenuity and dishonesty. Especially when it's continuing the grave sin of focusing on the long tails.

▲yasnu5 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲fearthemachine a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

IMO a decent developer can pick up most other roles, especially non-people-manager roles (though some pick those up very fast, too) a hell of a lot faster and better than most people in other roles can pick up programming.

Part of this, I think, is because the people who had the inclination and ability to pick up programing have, for decades, been nudged into programming from whatever job they had before, by comp, co-workers, managers, and opportunity availability, so they’re already heavily concentrated in programming even if they’re perfectly capable of doing other jobs (perhaps with some brief re-training).

I think other roles need to fear programmers who studied a new role for a couple weekends more than programmers need to fear LLMs. If we’re bumped out of full-time programming… guess where we’re going, and what we’ll be way better at doing than them?

[edit] part of that I wrote unclearly: the main thing about people being siphoned out of other roles into programming for the last 3ish decades is that most of the people with the combo of willingness and ability to get decent at programming… are programmers. It’ll tend to be harder to train other people to be good enough at using their computers to maximally benefit from LLMs (they already usually aren’t very good at using their non-LLM computer tools, it’s not like this is a new problem) than to shift programmers into other roles, if programming as a dedicated job in-fact is diminished in a durable way and at a mass scale.

▲decidu0us9034 a day ago | parent | next [-]

Most firms are in a very risk-averse mood as far as hiring. They don't want to take on the liability associated with this sort of workforce development stuff, and don't want to train and onboard people they might not need in a few years. At least not in the current monetary environment (which isn't going anywhere any time soon)

▲boorang 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've had similar thoughts. I feel like with the context engineering skills I've built, I could theoretically go to quite a few types of white collar jobs (non-sales/people skills type jobs) and shadow their experts and slowly build up their workflows and heuristics in a job specific context harness. And then I could train myself to do their jobs.

But once people catch on to this dynamic, I doubt people are going to be helpful in these onboarding the AI guy jobs... It's a reaping, boil down the heuristics they spent a career building into a document tree, then push them out.

▲mmcnl a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I agree. The transition will be messy though.

▲ffsm8 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The issue is, there are going to be less and less people willing to give you money that you can make a living to address those infinite wants

▲jazzypants a day ago | parent | next [-]

Most normies don't like having to explain what they want to an LLM. From what I've observed, after the initial euphoria of creating something from nothing fades, they eventually get frustrated with the first version of a vibe coded app, and they have trouble explaining exactly how they what it want to change.

I think almost every new business will have at least one person whose job is to deal with the technology. There might be fewer of them, and they might be a weird amalgamation of sysadmin and web developer, but there will still be jobs for nerds like us who actually like doing this stuff.

▲pampas a day ago | parent | next [-]

You know what is worse for 'normies'? Waiting. I don't want to wait hours or days for results from an SWE/accountant/lawyer/architect etc who will just be forwarding my words to an LLM anyway. LLM's can spit out results in a matter of seconds and let me iterate.

And if I still want professional help then there will be a excess of labour due to the above for most tasks.

▲jazzypants a day ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, exactly. You'll still hire someone.

▲fn-mote a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> You know what is worse for 'normies'? Waiting.

Disagree.

What is worse is having to learn and do it yourself because the people you hired won’t do their job properly.

Waiting = not paying attention to the issue = nobody cares (unless it’s some emergency). So what if your taxes are done two weeks later??

▲jimbokun a day ago | parent | prev [-]

You are in the minority of workers.

▲yasnu5 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[dead]

▲RunSet a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The same people who can't give you directions to the next intersection expect they will be able to describe patient management software.

▲raincole a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Explaining what they want to an LLM - something that can understand badly organized word salads with infinite patience - is frustrating? Then imagine how they'd feel if they have to explain what they want to a human...

▲jazzypants a day ago | parent | next [-]

The key differences are that humans can better anticipate people's needs, communicate through body language, understand social cues, maintain critical information even as it changes quickly, and interact with the real world effortlessly.

▲nextaccountic 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Intellectually, I don't see how humans will stay better at anything for too long. And with a bit of robotics, I don't see how humans will stay better at manual work either I'm talking about 10+ years down the road, a blip in the history of humanity. We don't stand a chance.

Capitalism is inherently broken if people don't get paid wages, because then they don't have money to buy stuff. Fortunately, capitalism doesn't need to exist forever

▲b112 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

For now. Wait a couple of years.

▲ratelimitsteve a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

"I want it to search and be fast"

vs

"I want to pre-sort during idle time so that I can effectively implement a binary search"

You can tell me either of these and get the same product. You can pick one of these and tell an LLM to do it three times and get three different products.

▲blobbers a day ago | parent [-]

And the LLM can also implement something way better than idle pre sort.

Sorry, this cope.

▲tyg13 a day ago | parent [-]

Left to its own devices, the AI may choose to implement things efficiently and correctly, or it may choose to implement things inefficiently and incorrectly. Without clear guidance, acceptance criteria, and hand-holding, it will make assumptions that are wrong, and as the demands of the product grow, it will continue to build off of those wrong assumptions. This is my experience with Gemini, Claude, GPT -- any of the models. They need guidance or they will build crap.

Now, this may be acceptable (tons of businesses are built on broken products), but what is absolutely cope is this moronic idea that the LLM is always smarter than the average engineer and will magically produce the most efficient and correct solution.

▲ratelimitsteve a day ago | parent [-]

> Without clear guidance, acceptance criteria, and hand-holding, it will make assumptions that are wrong

Yeah but the person you're replying to isn't gonna see that because they already made several assumptions about the problem I put in front of them

▲techpression a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A big part of the job is to not have them do that though.

▲bigfatkitten a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is an entire profession of people who make good money doing this for a living. They are called business analysts.

▲dominotw a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Are you saying you presonally explained all your needs to apple to get the laptop or phone you used to type that comment?

▲throw-the-towel a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Most normies would like giving $insane to you to prompt the LLM even less.

▲ElProlactin a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Most normies don't like paying $200+/hour to techies who refer to them as "normies".

▲graemep a day ago | parent [-]

Other terminology is available......

▲lallysingh a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Oh no, the opposite. So many people will be writing software via claude now. So many more software-based, or at least, software-integrated businesses are going to pop up. And when as they grow, LLMs aren't going to be enough.

What's going to change is that we'll have to focus on the actual hard problems of software development: making sure the software does what it's supposed to, isolating nontrivial bugs, finding ways to make it perform better.

▲decidu0us9034 a day ago | parent | next [-]

I don't understand the vision of the one-person Claude-powered business. If it can be done with one person, it can be done with zero more efficiently. What seems more likely to me is the emergence of a few (or one) massive vertically-integrated everything firms, who can afford more inference than anyone else seeking to enter the market. What we call AI, is more than that, it's accummulation, capital, systems of power, and these juggernauts will simply have more of it. Agents will continually do research to seek out areas of market inefficiency and octopus into them. They can outline business requirements, spec them out, and delegate to other agents. Other agents can continually research perf improvements, hunt for vulns, and so on. Once the race to the bottom kicks off, there's no undoing it. It seemed absurd to me a few months ago but every time I've thought capabilities were limited in some fundamental way I've been proven wrong

▲akmiller a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> actual hard problems of software development: making sure the software does what it's supposed to, isolating nontrivial bugs, finding ways to make it perform better.

These are exactly the things LLM's outperform all of us on.

▲lallysingh a day ago | parent | next [-]

My experience is exactly the opposite. 30 years writing software for my job, been using claude/grok for most of this year. At first they were really amazing. A real lever for higher output. But, I spend most of my time now telling them how to design high-performance systems and how to manage high concurrency and low contention.

They'll shove out a pattern quickly, but no matter how new and magical the latest model is, they will just put out some tweaked variant of existing designs. I find myself treating it like a junior-mid engineer. "Add rdtsc-based timers around major parts of the code to whittle down what's taking too long." "Use that to figure out where the transfer amount is way too small to justify the time taken without copying the payload." etc.

But concurrency bugs from large LLM-developed codebases are a major issue. They constantly find bugs they wrote. I eventually told it to start writing formal models of the concurrent uses and to (a) validate the models; (b) verify the code implements the models; to make it work.

So yeah, I stand by my words. For simple commands and tiny codebases, it /can/ do those things, but even small projects (50 KLOC) are a mess of making it fix its own mistakes, reconcile basic logic in requirements analysis, and everything has to be taken over with a fine-tooth comb to make it any good.

▲saguntum 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The async code issue resonates with my experience. I spent the better part of a day trying to get one of the Claude models (high 4 version or Opus 5, I don't recall) to try to implement a bidirectional gRPC stream of some complexity correctly in Go. I ended up just writing it myself. I am not anti-AI by any means, but I was surprised it struggled with something there are ample examples and documentation for online.

The tools are amazing, but I think they are most amazing when you can have deterministic verification loops. Async bugs aren't always encountered, so it's a little more difficult for the LLM to prove its work and iterate. At least, that's my current hypothesis for why it tends to degrade so much for this type of problem.

▲CamperBob2 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

My experience is exactly the opposite. 30 years writing software for my job, been using claude/grok for most of this year.

If you don't specify the model you are talking about, you have written a sentence with near-zero information content. If that's your habit, well... that's likely part of the problem.

I promise you, Fable and Neon are better than you are at pretty much whatever. Sonnet 4.X and MechaHitler, well, maybe not.

▲lallysingh 8 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Opus 4.6/grok 4.7 at work, Fable at home for personal (50 KLOC) projects. I'm still waiting to be impressed.

▲Tanjreeve 16 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I just got sent around In a loop by fable for several hours on solving some more complicated rust lifetimes. It's not magic. It's a more powerful reasoning model. But to use them in an automated process it's still an exercise for the user. Again it's fine.

In a similar vein public clouds contain the components to built any software you can think of. But that doesn't mean that all the solutions possible spring into existence just because AWS exists.

▲chrisco255 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> making sure the software does what it's supposed to

If you've tried to build anything nontrivial with LLM you know this just isn't true.

▲akmiller a day ago | parent | next [-]

I've been a developer for 27 years and have built many non-trivial things with LLM's (that's all I do anymore). I'm sorry, but anyone down-voting my comment can't be serious.

Why is much of our legacy software suddenly failing us if we are so much better at finding intricate bugs than the LLM's? Why are all of us easily capable of speeding up our software by orders of magnitude in small amounts of time utilizing them. Yes, they are better at verification as well.

▲javier2 a day ago | parent | next [-]

The thing I still see as the biggest issue with the current LLMs is that they never say "NO". They will try very hard to fulfill your every wish, and nobody stops to ask if they should even be building it. Up until about april this year I was certain AI and LLMs was just gonna be another tool in my toolkit, but now I am not so sure anymore. Relatively non-technical people can get some pretty neat stuff built if they are determined enough. I am not sure what my future or if it will involve coding, but I hope so. The thing about coding, is that many non-technical people still seem to believe it was writing code that was the difficult part. That hasn't been hard for 15-20 years. Modern tooling was already great. The difficult part was reading over enough code to make write the changes in the right places to achieve the requirements you need.

▲lallysingh a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because we have a new tool that finds certain classes of bugs way better than our old tools. That's it. Sanitizers and linters had similar impact - they just happened early enough that there was less computer-dependent infra that was impacted.

▲reisse a day ago | parent [-]

I've yet to see a sanitizer able to generate a full RCE chain from an out of bounds write it found.

▲CamperBob2 20 hours ago | parent [-]

A couple of days ago I had DeepSeek 4.1F 1017 do just that, rooting my Synology box when they announced a CVE without any details.

▲chrisco255 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You bring 27 years of experience and context to every single LLM session you open, so every session you have with an LLM is already going to be far more productive than someone starting from scratch with zero experience in application development. You're able to understand how to map business requirements to technical outcomes and you can competently direct the LLMs to the desired outcome. That is the high-value part of your job that has always existed. It never was about coding the solution in whatever esoteric Turing-complete language you used.

As for legacy software suddenly failing us, what you're really talking about are active systems like Microsoft 365 (it's not legacy code). Those systems have always been complex. That they are "suddenly" failing could be an indication of a number of things, but I'd pin a large part of the responsibility on organizational debt (even beyond technical debt). Maintaining complex software systems is hard, software mostly isn't a static thing it has to constantly evolve. It could also be an indication of over-reliance on LLM competency, for all we know about those system's internals. We just don't know enough to make an assessment.

There have been some zero days discovered by LLMs. There have also been many socially engineered, regular old exploits that have been impressed on us as indications of AI breakouts.

As for speedups, most software is comically unoptimized and has been for some time. We made an explicit trade-off in software development as CPUs and machines got more capable: we started coding in simpler languages with higher levels of abstraction (Python, Ruby, JS, Java, etc) sometimes costing us 10x or more in resource utilization, in exchange for the iteration speed that bought us. Converting those to more efficient languages like Go, Rust, C, etc alone buys you so much. On top of that, there are a number of algorithmic optimizations most developers never implemented that map to well known access patterns in hardware. Lots of low hanging fruit.

▲bodeadly a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

LLMs are good at conventional things and much less so at unconventional things. While this goes far beyond for loops, http calls and concurrency checks, there are nuanced unconventional things that LLMs are not good at. I spend 8-10 hours a day in claude and I am constantly steering it away from turning the codebase into a incomprehensible mess.

▲platinumrad a day ago | parent | prev [-]

LLMs are better than people at finding intricate bugs, in part because they do not tire or get bored, but people are still much better at designing coherent systems.

▲Archer6621 a day ago | parent [-]

That's because LLMs are incoherent by design, and need extensive guardrails to be useful for tasks that demand coherence.

I share a similar experience with bug finding; I think it also helps that LLMs can simply hold much more context at once than a human, as seeing a much larger portion of the codebase simultaneously makes it much easier to spot discrepancies.

▲akkad33 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't know most times claude picks up edge cases I never thought of. I spend a non trivial amount of time telling it this edge case doesn't happen

▲chrisco255 a day ago | parent [-]

Well, correcting LLMs from overanalyzing is part of your value in the loop.

▲rvz a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If you are building software that has no risk, then it's not important enough for anyone willing to pay for it and they will believe it is safe enough to build it themselves.

Examples are: Note taking apps, voice recording apps, calendar apps, video games, etc.

▲LtWorf a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> These are exactly the things LLM's outperform all of us on.

If you throw an excessive amount of money at the problem yes.

▲tripleee a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've been hired for good money by people who had the skills to do the work themselves (the best people to work for!), simply because it took time and they had a lot on their plate already.

Wages might decrease if the work becomes easier and more people are able to do it, but I'm not sure jobs will actually go away until true AGI.

▲geraneum a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> less and less people willing to give you money

How does this work? Care to elaborate? Doe the wants remain infinite but no one willing to pay?

▲lIIlllIlIIIlIll a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

English speaking software engineers are firmly in the 0.1%

We'll be fine. Move to a lower cost of living area, start a business. There's millions of companies in need of software expertise.

All this moral panic about software work is unseemly. Maybe the easy "learn JS/frameworks" path to wealth is closed. Whatever. Good, actually.

▲gnz11 a day ago | parent | next [-]

Starting a business is easy, maintaining one is incredibly difficult. I would not bank on that as some kind of a fallback. Starting a boutique software business sounds even more risky in this climate compared to even just few years ago.

▲lIIlllIlIIIlIll a day ago | parent [-]

That's just one thing one might do.

We'll be fine, we're the most prosperous worker class in the history of working.

Besides the job never was churning out code and if there was a bloat of such positions it was only ever a temporary distortion.

▲tripleee a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Anyone saying "just start a business" as some kind of easy alternative has almost definitely never tried "just starting a business".

▲lIIlllIlIIIlIll a day ago | parent [-]

You'll notice the conspicuous absence of the word "just" in my comment.

▲ a day ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲CodeMage a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> Move to a lower cost of living area, start a business.

This reminds me of that viral clip with Ben Shapiro saying that if the sea levels rise, people will just sell their homes and move. The clip went viral because of the response: "Just one small problem. Sell their houses to who [sic], Ben? F*cking Aquaman?"

> All this moral panic about software work is unseemly.

You know, it's funny how the history keeps repeating. This will be far from the first time a technological breakthrough left a group of people obsolete and scrabbling to deal with it.

Every single time this happens and ends up being a net positive for the society, the suffering of those people is ignored at the time and then we eventually look back and end up expressing empathy for them. And every single time we express hope that maybe next time we can do better as a society.

And every single time it happens, we not only fail to do better, but we have people condemning the very idea that we should even try to do better.

> Maybe the easy "learn JS/frameworks" path to wealth is closed. Whatever. Good, actually.

Wait, I could have easily amassed wealth by "just" learning "JS/frameworks"? Wow, and here I had the wrong idea about the causes of wealth distribution inequality. It's clearly those parasitic JS devs' fault.

▲rokhayakebe a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Correct, but there are now more people willing to give you $10-$80 monthly for your vibecoded product. I would give $30 monthly before I sit down and vibecode a crm.

▲Danox a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The issue today is that after 1945, starting with the Korean War, those days of extracurricular interference overseas is coming to an end. The country, like Great Britain before it, can no longer afford it. The cash register is moving over to tilt no more…

▲maxdo a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

And more people willing to do your job . For my FDE opening I got people from accounting background, guess what , why not ?

▲gloosx a day ago | parent | prev [-]

you can just ask llm to make you some money so you can make a living then?

▲willy_k 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This seems relevant! Wow, this is 1951.

> Let us now assume, for the sake of argument, that these machines are a genuine possibility, and look at the consequences of constructing them. To do so would of course meet with great opposition, unless we have advanced greatly in religious toleration from the days of Galileo. There would be great opposition from the intellectuals who were afraid of being put out of a job. It is probable though that the intellectuals would be mistaken about this. There would be plenty to do, trying to understand what the machines were trying to say, i.e. in trying to keep one’s intelligence up to the standard set by the machines, for it seems probable that once the machine thinking method had started, it would not take long to outstrip our feeble powers. There would be no question of the machines dying, and they would be able to converse with each other to sharpen their wits. At some stage therefore we should have to expect the machines to take control, in the way that is mentioned in Samuel Butler’s “Erewhon”. "Intelligent Machinery, A Heretical Theory" (1951), from a BBC radio discussion programme, The ’51 Society.

▲veqq 19 hours ago | parent [-]

The mentioned Butler wrote Darwin among the Machines in 1863:

> we find ourselves almost awestruck at the vast development of the mechanical world, at the gigantic strides with which it has advanced in comparison with the slow progress of the animal and vegetable kingdom. We shall find it impossible to refrain from asking ourselves what the end of this mighty movement is to be

> What sort of creature man’s next successor in the supremacy of the earth is likely to be. We have often heard this debated; but it appears to us that we are ourselves creating our own successors; we are daily adding to the beauty and delicacy of their physical organisation; we are daily giving them greater power and supplying by all sorts of ingenious contrivances that self-regulating, self-acting power which will be to them what intellect has been to the human race. In the course of ages we shall find ourselves the inferior race. Inferior in power, inferior in that moral quality of self-control, we shall look up to them as the acme of all that the best and wisest man can ever dare to aim at. No evil passions, no jealousy, no avarice, no impure desires will disturb the serene might of those glorious creatures.

▲vekker 15 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I hold the same optimistic view, rooted in Jevon's Paradox. However, it's not a law of nature, it still requires demand elasticity. That is what makes me more nervous, as what is playing out now in both the US and EU is a shift from monetary to fiscal dominance, with significant disruption of white collar occupations that has been predicted even within a world without modern generative AI.

So the question is if demand for software will expand by more than the productivity improvement it creates, in this fiscal environment. I think it will, but it will be for Software as a (Specific) Solution rather than the classic Software as a Service (delivering measurable outcomes vs. delivering tools for people to use), and this will come with a shift in the types of roles hired for. Less "routine" software developers, more people in product design, more domain specialists, more system architects and integration engineers, QA, security, compliance & auditing, etc...

Just anecdotally: I am finishing up on a project proposal for a company that would pre-AI probably never considered this, but if it's greenlighted, I will need a team in two months and I'm already nervous that I may not find the right selection of people... Many such initiatives are started now because AI makes everyone more ambitious, wanting to automate everything but reliably, which requires skilled software engineers in conjunction with AI workflows.

▲sanderjd a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah, it seems to me that nobody is better positioned to use these tools effectively than people who have already been building software "by hand". I still have some concern that we might hit a point where there is no human in the loop at all. But I don't feel very threatened by non-technical people vibe coding me out of a job.

▲wolfinterval a day ago | parent [-]

I don't know. The FM-1 music synth has just up ended the music hardware synth market in the last month because of vibe coding.

This very specialized audio DSP programming that was in short supply is now something almost anyone can do.

You need the synth domain knowledge but the software programming is solved for all intensive purposes.

The DSP programmer of course will be the best firmware vibe coder but they surely were better off when they had this rare skill vs everyone now having that skill.

▲sanderjd 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

There is definitely an argument that people with specialized domain knowledge will be the larger beneficiaries. But I think software people are better positioned than most to figure out how to apply AI tools to various domains.

▲senordevnyc 10 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah, but here's the thing: I know literally nothing about the music hardware synth market, and the chances that I'd ever go invest the time to develop any of that specialized audio DSP programming skill was essentially zero.

But I googled this FM-1 thing and watched some Youtube videos and it seems pretty cool! I might get one to play around with for the fun of it.

And I doubt I'm alone. So maybe the DSP programmers are worse off, or maybe their market is about to explode because it's so much more accessible, and there will be all kinds of new niches and opportunities for their skillset in this much larger market.

Maybe not, I have no idea, but my own reaction to seeing this was interesting, so I figured I'd share.

▲sanderjd 7 hours ago | parent [-]

Right. It's so hard to say! I can't sit here and tell people who are very worried that they shouldn't be. I think that's a good chance that we all should be! But I also see so many opportunities opening up to me that would have been out of reach before... And that seems like it might be really good?

But I dunno, I'm very ambivalent about it.

▲quesera a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> for all intensive purposes

One of my favorites; pardon the pedantry: "for all intents and purposes". :)

▲ummonk a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah I don't think the gravy train is gone for software engineers; it's just starting.

I feel very negatively about the rise of AI for many reasons, but personal economic prospects is not one of those reasons.

▲menaerus 12 hours ago | parent [-]

Could you please elaborate? If AI solves most of the SWE problems as of today 100x faster, and costs 100x less than a typical SWE, why do you think both economic prospect and amount of work done by humans are not going to be heavily impacted?

▲andriy_koval a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> There is no shortage of problems that can be solved

there is shortage. You can just jump on problem you want to solve, because distribution channels are saturated/occupied.

▲smattiso 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is not infinite demand for software. And certainly not infinite demand for software that costs money. In my opinion we are hurtling towards a world where, outside of the huge tech monopolies, nobody invests in or pays for new software because making new software (even using AI) takes work and skill , but copying existing software takes relatively no work and no skill.

So someone invests time and energy into figuring out good UX, sensible architecture, and releases a good product. Then a swarm of clones come about and depreciate the value nearly instantly. Who wants to invest in making good products?

If you’ve used AI extensively you realize how easy it is to copy relative to create.

▲mjdiloreto 20 hours ago | parent [-]

1. There IS a combinatorially explosive demand for software, when you consider the universe of customizations and compositions that software will take.

2. Businesses still want to offload cognitive effort elsewhere (such as software vendors), if that software is not what the business does. Copying mature software with your AI is a terrible business plan, and wastes your money and time. And I'm not going to choose one of the swarms of clones, why would I? Your view is like saying why would anyone pay $$$ for a well made purse when there are thousands of knockoffs that look exactly the same?

3. Software that touches the real world will never be exhausted, because the detail and complexity of the real world is unbounded and constantly changing.

▲matwood 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding

One of the biggest uses of vibe-coding that I've seen is non-technical users creating throw-away tools to help them solve their current problem.

▲sandeepkd a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I am more than convinced that the folks who understand how LLMs work, what they are good at and what their limitation are would make it out on top. Anyone who is still hands on would do just fine.

Within couple years there is definitely going to be a shortage of people who understand how systems work. The only black swan possibility is the enterprise industry getting too small cause of heavy consolidation.

▲sterlind a day ago | parent | next [-]

within a couple of years I expect LLMs to understand how systems work well enough, and to be autonomous enough, that deep understanding of systems becomes largely irrelevant. right now LLMs can't manage the technical debt they create, but that's a problem that can and will be RL'd away. it probably hasn't already purely because the trajectories to sample are uneconomical to generate.

of course, I'll still be doing systems. maybe from my cabin in the woods, hiding from the machines, but I'm in it for the love of the game.

▲sandeepkd a day ago | parent [-]

I highly doubt that, at the same time thats always a possibility, going in the direction of machines ruling the world

▲mycall 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Systems might become even more opaque and morph in the next few years as AI models begin to make their own stacks for solution designs. I for one would welcome simplifying the overly complex stacks upon stacks of abstractions we have today. Instead, move back to having well-formed, proved unikernel blobs of execution (e.g. Symbolics). The sky is the limit.

▲sl0wbrainRot a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Can be solved and must be solved are not the same thing

Are you solving a shared agreed upon real problem or just doing leetcode on arbitrary meaningless data structure?

There will still be jobs but orders of magnitude fewer jobs.

Closer to reality that existed before the 08 crash and ZIRP fueled ponzi schemes fueled the web SaaS mania.

US doesn't need 4+ million software devs

World doesn't need 50+ million software devs

...when big tech is just shipping black boxes that boot models to handle local inference

It just needs enough jobs to solve that big tech production pipeline

▲boogieknite a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong, even with strong and capable models.

just happened on a client call yesterday. our work had been postponed because a new system was being introduced. our routine calls kept being cancelled and we started to worry. the customer finally showed up after a few months and told us the new system was demoed and "was clearly vibe coded. everything went wrong. they were asking claude questions during the demo" so were back in contract again

> reliably deliver them better than 50% completion

everyone has ideas. being able to program helped separate ideas from execution and i thought llms would remove that barrier but there seems to be some ingrained half-ass mentality in the self-proclaimed "idea guy"s ive met which prevent them from finishing things

▲thunky 10 hours ago | parent [-]

> the customer finally showed up after a few months and told us the new system was demoed and "was clearly vibe coded

Next time, the client will skip you and have AI do it. Why bother paying and waiting for something they could have done better themselves?

Then later, their client will skip them.

Until you get to the actual user.

▲boogieknite 5 hours ago | parent [-]

i expect youll end up right, but there does seem to be some inability to finish things for many people trying this now. "many" being the operative word as there are exceptional shining stars who finally have the LLM tool they needed to get things done. ive never met one, but they must be out there, right?

im not sure if its just that LLMs will get better to the point where everyone WILL achieve their goals, or if its always going to be the case where everyone COULD achieve their goals but most simply dont. will tech solve this, or is a human problem?

▲willio58 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong

Anecdata I’ve seen this too a few times. Major issues where a significant number of engineers had to stop important product work to un-jankify something a non technical person created. In every case those product people felt the heat so bad they basically stopped.

▲nevster a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The funny thing is, people have been saying the same thing about programming for years.

In the 80's, when I was about to start a computer science degree, a friend said his father thought it was a dead end because the computer would be able to program itself soon. This was the era when 4GLs were beginning to be a thing.

So much of the job is just helping the business people figure out what they want and trying to regularise their ridiculous arcane manual processes.

▲jquery 21 hours ago | parent [-]

In the long run, your friend’s father may have been right.

▲lenkite a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Its pretty clear that software services companies will need to pivot to offer "slop fix" services. We offer Great Deals to Maintain AI Generated Software! Clean up your Code! Delete your Technical Debt! Cheap Contracts!

▲jquery 21 hours ago | parent [-]

You joke but this is actually good idea.

“Is your vibe coded ATC system grounding flights nationwide?”…

▲wat10000 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

On the one hand, the models are definitely not good enough to replace human coders in all areas. I get great results from them, but they need some back and forth to get there. I'm in no danger of being replaced right now.

On the other hand, just two years ago they were practically useless for anything non-trivial. In that time, they went from "might be cool someday" to "can do most of the work, but still needs handholding." What are they going to look like two years from now? Five years? Ten?

So much depends on where we are on the S-curve. If we're getting into diminishing returns, then we may top out at a point that isn't too far beyond what we have today, where they're highly capable but need that human judgment and oversight. If we're at the bottom of the curve, it's hard to know what the future would look like. I have no idea which one is closer to being true, and I don't think anyone else does either.

▲citizenpaul a day ago | parent [-]

Its not a curve, its a cliff. The second that LLM's no longer need human oversight that is it, 99.99% drop in white collar employment in probably less than a year.

I think we actually are there in some areas but the bureaucratic/social structures are actually blocking it. If you asked me 2 years ago I would have laughed.

▲bbor 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I strongly disagree with your optimism about the extent to which our profession will continue to exist --much less offer the best effort/reward ratio for the top ~10% performers of any major profession by far-- but I do love and appreciate you for quoting Mr. Turing. I have an another, far more relevant quote to offer in response though, from an under-appreciated essay:

  Let us now assume, for the sake of argument, that these machines are a genuine possibility, and look at the consequences of constructing them.
  To do so would of course meet with great opposition, unless we have advanced greatly in religious toleration from the days of Galileo.
  
  There would be great opposition from the intellectuals who were afraid of being put out of a job.
  
  It is probable though that the intellectuals would be mistaken about this.
  There would be plenty to do in trying, say, to keep one's intelligence up to the standard set by the machines, for it seems probable that once the machine thinking method had started, it would not take long to outstrip our feeble powers.
  There would be no question of the machines dying, and they would be able to converse with each other to sharpen their wits.
  
  At some stage therefore we should have to expect the machines to take control, in the way that is mentioned in Samuel Butler's *Erewhon*.
In case it's not obvious: things do not work out in Erewhon :(
▲righthand a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You have not had to seek a new job in this market. I’ve had 2 interviews in 4 months. Where is my LLM optimism for niche problems that will save me?

▲mmcnl a day ago | parent [-]

The transition will be incredibly messy.

▲LegitShady a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

An example to counterbalance this is art. Art had a market of people willing to pay for it - some private, some companies - art including graphic design etc.

But the thing is that with AI the number of people willing to pay you to solve their art problem has dramatically fallen. The total number of jobs in art in general has plummeted. The opportunities to make a living or develop yourself with art have similarly plunged.

So there will always be another problem but that doesn't mean there will always be someone willing to pay you to solve it if they can get by without you.

▲elevation a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

"You can train an LLM on all the notes in classical music up to the 18th century -- but will it ever invent jazz?"

▲pmg101 a day ago | parent | next [-]

That's right. But 99% of what software devs have been paid to do is just churn out classical music notes in slightly different orders, over and over again.

There's been the very occasional breakthrough, but it could have been done by just a handful of brilliant people at key moments. The rest was just filler and AI will do it better than we have been anyway.

▲notJim a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

But most economically valuable software is not inventing jazz, it's applying well-established rules to new or neglected domains.

▲pydry a day ago | parent [-]

This isnt true. The economically valuable software does invent jazz.

The existence of companies like airbnb or uber or spotify confuses matters because they pretend to be software companies with valuable software but their real USP is some kind of legal/regulatory/market dominance and their software is nothing special.

▲evenhash a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How do humans innovate?

They only know about things they’ve seen before, how could they ever come up with something new?

▲ElProlactin a day ago | parent | prev [-]

"You can train an LLM on all the hip hop up to 2000 -- but will it ever invent mumble rap?"

▲bayarearefugee a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> There is no shortage of problems that can be solved (in fact, wants are infinite), and LLMs may actually enable our profession to reliably deliver them better than 50% completion.

Seems like copium to me if we're being honest.

Why would anyone pay you to solve the problem when they can just throw it at a cheap LLM?

And if the answer is that you have some sort of special taste or domain knowledge, once your solution is out in the world how are you going to stop someone from using an LLM to copy it and then undercut you in an immediate race to the bottom for everything?

▲kenferry a day ago | parent | next [-]

I agree with poster regarding "we're not running out of problems, and therefore we're not running out of jobs". I'm not sure whether the jobs will be "programming" though. And if I had to bet, I would say they will not be. I would guess that domain experts will be able to handle their own programming tasks most of the time. Which is cool! The same way people don't need dedicated typists anymore to transcribe text.

My grandfather worked at NASA, and my impression is that a significant portion of what he did was actual calculation. Nasa still employs people, they just don't do that particular work anymore.

▲ccppurcell a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If that analysis is correct (I tend to agree with it but I'm not sure) then we're heading for a world where no company can exist except for anthropic, openai etc. because if you're solving some problem with LLMs, and I am your customer, I can solve the same problem with LLMs and cut out the middle man. At the very least, there will be a race to the bottom until nothing is left.

If that happens I guess the whole thing hinges on how powerful and user-friendly open source models become.

▲benashford a day ago | parent | next [-]

This is one of the fascinating unanswered philosophical questions. If LLMs become more intelligent (albeit limited to certain types of problem solving) than any human, and we all have access to the same LLMs, are we all equally intelligent?

If the answer to that is "yes", then there's literally no point in anyone hiring anyone for any knowledge work. And that applies to other businesses. Why give a SaaS company recurring revenue if they're just a thin wrapper around Claude anyway?

The answer I think is that few companies are so thin. Most offer something else, some other kind of moat that has nothing to do with problem solving, or some kind of lock-in.

But there are definitely some (mostly small) companies that only exist to sell relatively simple specialist software to customers that don't have their own developers. Their moat against competitors was the relative scarcity of good developers, and the difficulty of motivating them even if you could hire them. In the post-LLM world, those small companies suddenly have competitors for the first time...

▲ccppurcell 17 hours ago | parent [-]

I think there are certain areas where you will hit the metaphorical bedrock. This pill cures cancer, the LLM says so. No thanks. But it's very limited.

In my necks of the wood (mathematics and foreign language education) we seem to be plumping for "human understanding and communication" as the new USP. I don't have too much faith in that supporting a lot of jobs but we'll see.

▲psadri a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think that is essentially the bet around Anthropic / OpenAI

▲californical a day ago | parent | next [-]

Which is weird because there are so many things in society that will break up these companies rather than allow them to become bigger than governments.

It’s not possible for them to grow as big as their boosters want them to. There would be so much resistance, and if that resistance fails, then we’d already be in the middle of techno-dystopia hell anyways, where money wouldn’t matter.

▲andriy_koval a day ago | parent [-]

> than allow them to become bigger than governments.

government will be their puppets, and what can I do then?

▲steelframe a day ago | parent [-]

Join the revolution.

▲andriy_koval a day ago | parent [-]

or accept that democracy is not sustainable society management style and will be always corrupted one way or another..

▲TyadorB a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Why would they not be replaced as well?

▲johndhi a day ago | parent | prev [-]

other options you're forgetting:

if your scenario starts happening, we break up anthropic and openai for antitrust reasons, or people do other things so that they don't become kings.

▲ccppurcell 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Not forgetting, I think that is exactly what will happen. But we will head towards the world where only they can exist until eventually there is some sort of collapse. Either what you outlined or their business model crumbles for a separate reason.

▲tarballing a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because those people have their own jobs and they don't care enough about software to treat it like a second job

▲deadbabe a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You create secret workflows, skills, and solutions that you never give others access to. Already doing this at work, 65% of my tooling is not available to any other employee.

▲coffeebeqn a day ago | parent | next [-]

One of our staff engineers tried that but I just took one of the outputs they shared and told the same model figure out how to prompt and what to set up to do this and his super power was mine in an hour or less.

I don’t know what moats we can have at this point. I’m trying to build a side hustle with vibe coding something because if it’s a backend only you can access at least you have a tiny moat. If you’re just prompting slightly more cleverly at your employers Claude account you do not have a moat

▲_aavaa_ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As they say, this doesn't seem like a durable moat.

▲kodoman a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I agree but then you have to make sure your prompting of the model does not expose the special technique, if your running local fine otherwise someone can just work out your tools or simply just pinch you skill markdown files.

▲_superposition_ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is an anti pattern and you are a bottle neck.

▲siva7 a day ago | parent [-]

sure, but in this new age? closed source is the new open source

▲ratelimitsteve a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

ooh shit i remember security through obscurity from back in the 90s. i wonder how well it will work in the age of fully automated reverse engineering and smart guess and check.

i also wonder if there's something in your employment agreement about the things you make on company time and who they belong to.

▲etherlink a day ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲arrowleaf a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I can see that you've been using Claude too much lately if you only read the first sentence/paragraph to decide what the entire comment says. You must not be working on sophisticated enough problems to see the rip current form as described. It (technical and cognitive debt) exists, just below the surface, and once it takes hold there's no swimming back to shore (a stable maintainable system) without extreme effort (refactors and first principles redesigns).

▲johndhi a day ago | parent | prev [-]

call me crazy but you appear to be suggesting:

(1) LLMs can solve any human problem; (2) that #1 would be a bad thing if it were actually true because some SWEs can't get the same job they had before

if the LLMs are that great, tell them to find the SWEs a new, better job. if they aren't, and LLM+SWE is > LLM, then #1 falls apart.

▲bayarearefugee a day ago | parent [-]

> (1) LLMs can solve any human problem;

Certainly not every problem, but enough problems that we currently consider economically valuable to cause a very large negative disruption in labor.

> (2) that #1 would be a bad thing if it were actually true because some SWEs can't get the same job they had before

I wouldn't say some SWEs I'd say almost all SWEs.

> if the LLMs are that great, tell them to find the SWEs a new, better job. if they aren't, and LLM+SWE is > LLM, then #1 falls apart.

Again, I don't think LLMs will solve every problem. Just enough problems that they put about 80% of all knowledge workers out of work in a relatively short timeframe, which is going to be economically disastrous in a way that expands far beyond just knowledge workers.

▲tgreg0ry a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I have been in software development for over 30 years and when people mention AI taking over jobs, I keep coming back to the demand problem. Where will the money come from to pay for anything if no one has a job?

▲wavefunction a day ago | parent | next [-]

It could be an ongoing project where say... the population who is not willing to grift their way to the top is subjected to ongoing environmental pressures which the people at the top are benefiting from directly financially, then offering or even demanding money for solutions to the problems they've caused. Meanwhile attrition has set in to the general population as their quality of life falls further and further and the people at the top use their position to vote themselves even more power, and the cycle propagates further. I feel like all I've done here is describe the past few decades in the US at least.

▲bigfatkitten a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think the risk of enormous segments of the population ending up on the street is overblown.

Right now there are mass layoffs in the IT industry partially as a correction to the pandemic hiring spree, and also to redirect capital from salaries to AI initiatives.

It is fashionable right now for tech CEOs to pretend that enormous amounts of work being done by humans is now being done by AI, but none of these are companies where the velocity at which code was written was ever the main bottleneck in getting products out the door. They’re mostly just lying to the market to pump their stock prices.

The software field is overexposed because there are a lot of people earning hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to add fields to CRUD apps. These folks are in enormous danger, but when the dust settles the skilled professionals solving difficult problems will do just fine.

▲taybin a day ago | parent [-]

There is a middle ground between people adding one more damn field to an already existing built app and the people inventing new math to solve DSP or whatever. How much danger are the skilled professionals who know how to architect complicated workflows so that they can guarantee correctness and be easy to change? Not easy, not the most difficult thing either. Also the sort of skill where maybe the lack of it doesn't become apparent in the product until it's too late.

I guess I kinda resent your implication that the "skilled professionals", the worthy, you know, us, will be fine. I think the real danger is for the people who care. And for the rest of us who rely on the people who care.

▲AeroNotix a day ago | parent [-]

It's also laughable that most people on HN are even in that bracket of people working on elite niche problems that AI can't trivially replace.

Just look at the job offers and the responses they get on here. It's all trivial crap.

▲LtWorf a day ago | parent [-]

I mean… most job offers here are for startups… what did you expect?

▲AeroNotix a day ago | parent [-]

You know as well as I do that HN likes to paint itself as some sort of elevated group of elite thinkers. It's just not true if you actually pay attention to what's being said and what people interact with.

▲LtWorf 11 hours ago | parent [-]

Lol true. It's weird. I get the same vibes as r/Gifted sometimes (which I read for entertainment purpose mostly).

▲AeroNotix 11 hours ago | parent [-]

In some sense I'm glad that the SWE and software in general is imploding. Massive salaries for people too thick to understand they're suffering from Dunning-Kruger effects is frankly insufferable.

▲LtWorf 10 hours ago | parent [-]

btw in europe we don't earn more than accountants or doctors

▲AeroNotix 5 hours ago | parent [-]

That's why if you were in Europe you would contract for US firms :)

▲cmiles8 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well somewhat ironically the main job AI now makes mostly obsolete is SDEs. Impacts elsewhere are much less clear. So folks will have jobs, but most of the SDEs of the world will likely need to find new jobs.

▲asdff 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Companies paying other companies and skipping the step of putting it into peoples pocket first.

▲ranguna 15 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Welp certainly not from you as a SWE.

▲linhns a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Apparently, some governments think you can just print it

▲jacquesm a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Easy: just get rid of the people. Start a war, maybe a famine or a pandemic (or two, if the first one doesn't do the job). After all, it's for the greater good... /s

▲ptidhomme a day ago | parent | next [-]

You can just remove the "/s". There's no escaping the fact that a majority of human lives will be considered worthless (or worse, a danger) to the billionaire establishment. And they don't have your well being at heart.

▲platevoltage 18 hours ago | parent [-]

I think we are past "will be".

▲senordevnyc 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

This is so ludicrous. Your mustache-twirling villain story about rich people is embarrassing. Do you actually know any truly wealthy people? I do, and in general they're no worse than the average poor or middle class person I know. They're certainly not plotting to genocide 90% of humanity or whatever.

Seriously, you need to go outside dude.

▲Marczelloni a day ago | parent | prev [-]

My conspiracy theory is they are doing everything in their power, teamed up with Trump admin to speedrun a recession by causing a labor shortage, perfect time for the rich to get richer and push us back to feudalism?

▲pavlov a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[dead]

▲yt-sdb a day ago | parent | prev [-]

What do you mean "a couple years ago"? Opus 4.5 isn't a year old yet. I don't necessarily disagree with your take, but starting off by saying you updated your view two years ago seems... outdated?