| |
| ▲ | arximboldi 20 hours ago | parent | next [-] | | can the people that harvest the apple trees afford a house with a backyard large enough for a bunch of apple trees? perhaps exploitation has too overreaching connotations, but there is an inherent imbalance of power in the relationship that leads to systemic inequalities. | | |
| ▲ | tarsierscripter 19 hours ago | parent | next [-] | | Without ownership of property you just have a commons, where everyone picks all the apples off the trees, and then someone comes along with an axe and cuts the trees down for firewood, and then there's no more apples or apple pie for anyone. | |
| ▲ | somenameforme 16 hours ago | parent | prev [-] | | You're making a lot of assumptions about the owner that often don't really pan out. For example I have less than zero love for the Waltons but Walmart is just such a great example. Their gross profit margin is about 24%. That's how much they profit on each item sold. But then after you factor in their operating costs, labor in particular, it's down to 3%. So the Walton's money printing button comes from taking 3 pennies from each dollar, but at a very high volume. If Walmart wanted to e.g. significantly raise the wages they pay, they'd have to substantially increase the prices on everything sold. The balance of higher wages for some but higher costs for all would almost certainly be a significant net-loss for the lower half of society. And this issue is even more pervasive at smaller shops. Making ends meet is even harder for small business owners. The idea that somebody's just printing money because they own a business is unrealistic. Well it's kind of true for tech businesses, but I suspect we're going to see that change in the future - though that's another topic altogether. | | |
| ▲ | Timon3 10 hours ago | parent [-] | | I think it's telling that you're pointing at Walmart's margin without pointing out 1) what percentage of the operating costs are down to labor, and 2) how much wages could be raised using those 3%. Like, just because the Walmart owners own a company in a low-margin high-volume sector, they're suddenly entitled to the 3% profit, while the employees often need government assistance to keep themselves afloat...? | | |
| ▲ | somenameforme 9 hours ago | parent [-] | | I'm not saying their percent of labor costs because it's not public information. It's buried in operating expenses, but it's going to be the majority of their costs, by a wide margin. Fortunately your other question is much easier to answer. WalMart's 3% profit margin is about $21 billion. Coincidentally they also have 2.1 million employees. So the math works out perfectly - a one-time raise of about $10k per year per employee, at which point the business would be unprofitable and no longer sustainable. The margins in non-tech businesses are not at all like most people think. They're slim with massive sounding outcomes (like $21 billion a year in profit) coming exclusively from scale. Redistribute that back to the employees to the point of self destruction and it's certainly a substantial amount, but far below the level many seem to think. The irony is that it's the companies that people think are 'generous' that are hoarding massive amounts of $$$. Apple makes something close to a million dollars in profit per employee, so they could afford to literally buy every single one of their employees a new Ferrari, every single year, and still be rolling in profit. But these sort of insane tech margins are not normal. More controversially, I think they're also not sustainable in the longrun - and the longrun just got a whole lot closer with LLMs. | | |
| ▲ | Timon3 9 hours ago | parent [-] | | > I'm not saying their percent of labor costs because it's not public information. It's buried in operating expenses, but it's going to be the majority of their costs, by a wide margin. So that would be what, 60-70%? IMO that's wildly unrealistic, I'd need to see actual evidence to believe they are so far off the norm. > WalMart's 3% profit margin is about $21 billion. Coincidentally they also have 2.1 million employees. So the math works out perfectly - a one-time raise of about $10k per year per employee, at which point the business would be unprofitable and no longer sustainable. How is a company that's breaking even no longer sustainable? | | |
| ▲ | somenameforme 8 hours ago | parent [-] | | 60% of your operating expenses being labor is pretty typical for a labor heavy industry, and WalMart's kind of the epitome of labor heavy with some 2.1 million workers. Their most recent reported operating expense was $148billion. If we assume 50% of that's labor that'd imply an average labor cost per employee of 148,000 * 0.5 / 2.1 = $35k. That's likely a significant lowball figure so the typical 60%+ is a reasonable ballpark. The reason that breakeven companies aren't sustainable is because there's variance in most things, certainly including sales. WalMart's net profit margin varies from around 1% to 3%, so they're currently at a 'high'. Cut that down by 3% and you literally don't have enough money to pay your employees next year when you swing low. Let alone little niceties like performance incentives, raises, etc. I think people just don't intuit how huge the world is and so how bizarre things get at scale. If you could earn just $1 from every person on Earth you'd be a multi billionaire. Even if you just limit yourself to Europe and the US, you'd be a billionaire. This sounds absurd, but it's true. It's because our intuition is just worthless for sufficiently big numbers. |
|
|
|
|
| |
| ▲ | pydry 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-] | | >have a bunch of apple trees in my back yard. I hire a a few guys to go harvest them and then sell them to a bakery which eventually turns them into apple pies, who in the world is getting exploited? No matter how cute you try to make it sound, when one person owns the land and the other person works it in exchange for pay it's the person working it who is exploited. Some people like to hand wave the question of who owns land and why they own it away but control of that wealth is always rooted in historic violence. | | |
| ▲ | somenameforme 11 hours ago | parent | next [-] | | You've yet to explain how or why anybody is being exploited, and instead are just engaging in circular logic-> 'employment is exploitation' -> 'how is this employment exploiting anybody?' -> 'because employment is exploitation.' You can take away any and all land. Imagine somebody thinks a public park is in nasty shape, so they hire a few guys to go help them clean it up. Is that still exploiting people? This all just makes no coherent sense whatsoever. | | |
| ▲ | pydry 7 hours ago | parent [-] | | unequal land ownership is what made employment exploitative in that example. capitalism is founded on the divide between those who work for a living and those who own for a living. governments pay people to clean parks. it's not something a private citizen would typically ever do. |
| |
| ▲ | badpun 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-] | | Take two people. One saved for 30 years and bought a small piece of land. The other one partied for 30 years, and always spent his entire surplus and ends up with no capital. It's true that now the saver can "exploit" whoever rents from him, but at the cost of previously exploiting himself during the previous 30 years to build capital. | | |
| ▲ | danhodgins 9 hours ago | parent [-] | | Third guy had a silver spoon, didn't have to work to build capital, and spent the next 30 years partying with the other guy. | | |
|
|
|