Remix.run Logo
▲ hirvi74 20 hours ago

Do you mind helping me understand a couple of things about your perspective?

> The transition we're in includes a substantial disengagement of thought.

While I think you are more correct than not, a cheeky part of me cannot help but think that humanity might be better served if some thoughts were never engaged with in the first place.

1.) I apologize if this is a rather blunt question, but how much of your identity is based on your own perceived (and perhaps exemplified/actualized) intelligence?

   I have had a fortunate enough life to have befriended many people who I consider to be far more intelligent than myself. Of these many individuals that I remain in contact with, I have noticed the ones that are the most adamantly opposed to the LLM frenzy, the "death of thought", etc. are the ones that have the strongest attachment/most pride in their own intelligence. I suppose it is a rational reaction, but I think LLMs are hurting a lot of people's egos. 
> For those of us who like thinking, this is something to mourn.

2.) That statement is what I am most curious about. Do you mind elaborating on what thought there is to mourn? What exactly is being taken away from you? I hope I am not about to come off as condescending, but what is actually preventing you from engaging in deep thought? One is not compelled to use AI outside of their own volition. Even in instances of employer mandates, one is not forced to use AI outside of their occupation.

▲byronturncoat 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm not the person you're responding to, but I think that you're searching for a correlation that does not exist. There is a universe of nuance in why someone might believe that LLMs cause the death of thought that has nothing to do with their ego. Perhaps they've seen it directly affect engineers on their teams. Perhaps they have themselves experienced the phenomenon. Perhaps they've read the numerous studies that have been published on the subject.

Just because someone doesn't believe the same as you, it doesn't mean that they've got a fragile or damaged ego. I, personally, think that people who don't see the death of thought are delusional, and it's got nothing to do with ego.

When someone spends 40 hours per week doing a thing, having the ability, motivation, and pleasure in solving problems they enjoy can and is being taken away. Yes, one can engage in "deep thought" in personal time, if you've got time for that with children, responsibilities, and other leisure activities. Not everyone has time to engage in deep thought enough in free time to compensate for the loss in the workplace.

▲hirvi74 17 minutes ago | parent [-]

> I think that you're searching for a correlation that does not exist.

I cannot provide evidence in favor or against my conjecture, so you very well may be correct.

> Perhaps they've read the numerous studies that have been published on the subject.

I feel it is necessary to push back on this point a bit. I will read any research you are willing to share, but from the studies I have happened to read, the "death of thought" would be a hyperbolic mischaracterization of observations. Most studies I can remember reading tend to measure performance on small, narrow sets of tasks. For clarification, what do you believe "death of thought" means? If you mean an atrophy in a particular skill being linked to outsourcing the skill to LLMs, then I am more inclined to agree with you. In other words, I do not disagree that using LLMs for any and all programming is linked to the atrophy of one's ability to program, but I would be more suspicious of claims that suggest that such usage of LLMs is linked to one's ability to think critically in many or most domains.

> Just because someone doesn't believe the same as you, it doesn't mean that they've got a fragile or damaged ego.

I am well aware. However, I never shared my opinions on whether I believe thought is dying or not, so I am not sure what disagreement you believe the OP and I have. I was merely sharing an observation that I have noticed amongst people I consider to be highly intelligent within my social circles. In hindsight, I can understand how the wording of some of my questions my be interpreted as subtly sharing a stance. Some people have a way with words, while others like me often struggle. My apologies.

> When someone spends 40 hours per week doing a thing, having the ability, motivation, and pleasure in solving problems they enjoy can and is being taken away. Yes, one can engage in "deep thought" in personal time, if you've got time for that with children, responsibilities, and other leisure activities. Not everyone has time to engage in deep thought enough in free time to compensate for the loss in the workplace.

Of course. That is true of any limited resource be it time, money, health, or what have you. Those that find themselves in such a situation have both my sympathy and empathy.

▲MiiMe19 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

disclaimer: Not the OP.

1. I feel like I have a decent amount of my identity tied up in being "smart". I have always enjoyed learning, have been good at solving problems, and have been able to get out of some pretty difficult circumstances that were definitely slanted against me in terms of being able to find a stable and high paying job through a combination of luck, being born decently smart, and hard work.

2. For my entire life I have been able to work towards or have a job where my purpose is to solve interesting problems and get paid well for it. I have been lucky enough to be in a position where I could paid to sit down and build solutions, understanding every intricate detail of what I made. And now, it seems like the entire industry is just throwing this away. Why engage with deep thought when everyone around is thoroughly convinced that the act of thinking is "last gen" or "going out of style"? If everyone else is wrong, that doesn't change the pressure to just stop thinking and ship 50 commits a day of unread slop. If everyone else is right, why bother thinking? I am just going to lose my job and be stuck doing menial labor until the AGI builds robots that can do my job. Either way I am unhappy. And sure, I do not need to use AI outside of work, but that does not change the existential dread of having the next 30-40 years of my career turned into something that I absolutely hate.

Overall, we have effectively built a machine or a widespread perception of a machine that rewards not thinking and not taking responsibility. Why bother trying to accomplish anything if a machine can do it better than you. I value solving problems, I value understanding, and I value working hard, and at least for me I feel that I may have to start mourning the fact that you used to be able to get paid to do all three. On the bright side, if anyone my age is poised to, by the stupid credentialism of our society, stay in the job market after this, it is me. So either I make a decent amount of money and escape the permanent underclass or all of society is cooked, in which case at least I won't be judged.