Remix.run Logo
▲ loeg a day ago

This is a basically false narrative.

CEOs are allowed to do all of these things, but they do not necessarily maximize business returns, and therefore their own incentives. Nothing has changed here from 2020, 2015, or 2010 -- a period over which SWE compensation has skyrocketed. No reason to believe this gets worse with AI.

The 50s and 60s marginal tax rate was (1) mostly paid by no one; rich people instead received business income not subject to personal income tax; and (2) other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war. There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

It's easy to hate the rich and want to punish them for being rich, but it doesn't help the poor to do so.

▲tadfisher a day ago | parent | next [-]

"Punishing" the rich by making them pay higher taxes in order to fund programs that help the poor absolutely does help the poor. Some rich folks don't view this as a punishment, even.

▲loeg a day ago | parent | next [-]

This is a sleight of hand. The rich aren't rich enough to fund the kind of broad programs you're talking about, even if you punitively taxed them at 100% of assets.

▲triceratops 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Obviously taxing anyone at 100% of assets is wrong. But you're just repeating bad math.

The top 1% owns 50% of all public equities. The current US stock market's value is around $80 trillion. Taxing the 1% at 100% of assets would raise $40 trillion, even only counting their stakes in public companies.

The US federal government spent about $7 trillion last year. Only a tiny fraction of that is "broad social programs" that are funded out of general tax revenue (Social Security and Medicare have their own tax).

A more reasonable 1% of assets for the top 1% would net $400 billion annually (again only their public stock holdings). That's almost half the defence budget. And 1% is nothing; the stock market goes up 8% annually on average so they still come out ahead.

"Selling pressure" you say? Because the top 1% are liquidating 1% of their portfolio every year. Right.

Let them pay in shares and put the shares into a sovereign wealth fund. Black box, government gets no votes in any of the companies, whenever it needs some money and dividends don't cover it, the Treasury sells something at random.

▲Eisenstein 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Which programs are we talking about and how much would they cost?

▲rayiner a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The push to tax CEOs and billionaires is motivated by punishment, not because these are the biggest aggregate sources of revenue. AOC’s 70% tax rate proposal is projected to raise around $30 billion a year, which is a rounding error.

If the goal was “helping people,” you would raise money the same way European countries do: high taxes on the upper middle class. It’s a multi-trillion annual tax base that we refuse to appropriately tax.

In Ontario, income on capital gains is taxed at 23%. In California, the top long-term capital gains rate is 36% (13% state +23% federal). Canada isn’t paying for universal healthcare by “taxing billionaires.” It does so by charging people a 13% sales tax and very high marginal tax rates on the upper middle class (above $250k) from 46% in Ontario to 53% in BC.

▲smallmancontrov a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Elon was bitching about paying $500M in taxes the other day on Twitter. He didn't mention that he's been stacking $200B a year and that he was complaining about paying 0.25% of that in taxes.

0.25% is what today's billionaires consider "punishing." Absolutely wild. Many of us pay tax at more than 100x that rate.

▲jethro_tell a day ago | parent [-]

Or that he paid the same amount to try to avoid having to pay taxes.

It’s not spending or even loosing the money, it’s helping other people that he hates.

▲ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲mattdeboard a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Taxes aren't punishment.

▲loeg a day ago | parent [-]

roosterIllusi0n wants them to be a punishment! See the great-grandparent comment.

▲mattdeboard 4 hours ago | parent [-]

That is your opinion based on a read that assumes persecution rather than a systemic solve for a systemic economic problem. Economic measures to curtail behaviors that introduce instability into the economy are not punishments.

▲ux266478 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> mostly paid by no one

Correct, because the mechanisms of capital were different and the system encouraged utilizing it for material investment and keeping labor happy, which is where that business income went.

> other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war

What alternate timeline did you come from where the 1960s was not a time of major cultural rift in the US? Do you think the upper middle class was not a huge source of hippies?

https://archive.org/details/CSPAN3_20180512_120000_Reel_Amer...

> There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

What? Wealth and income inequality was at its lowest since the founding of the country. An effect which was established prior to the involvement of the US in the war, it began with FDR's new deal. And once they hit the floor in the early 1940s, the numbers were extremely steady and consistent until the financial system overhaul in 1975 at which point they shoot right back up again. There is no reason? Every single metric disagrees with that, except for racial inequalities. Enough with the neoliberal apologism, Gordon Gekko. The empowerment of financiers has been an absolute disaster.

▲loeg a day ago | parent [-]

> What alternate timeline did you come from where the 1960s was not a time of major cultural rift in the US?

The 60s is the tail end of that period, yes. Tax rates were cut significantly in 1964.

> What? Wealth and income inequality was at its lowest since the founding of the country. An effect which was established prior to the involvement of the US in the war, it began with FDR's new deal.

And yet, the poorest 10-20% didn't have refrigeration, ~1/3 didn't have indoor plumbing, 6% didn't have electricity, they had almost no healthcare to speak of, and many actually went hungry. The poor today are much better off -- inequality does not actually make their material conditions worse.

▲ux266478 5 hours ago | parent [-]

> The 60s is the tail end of that period, yes

The 60s is special because it was a great period of cultural divide, I pointed it out specifically because you were painting the period as a time of national unity, indicating you don't actually know what you're talking about. But the idea of a strong national unity is, in general, just rose tinted goggles and historical ignorance even beyond the 60s. It was the absurdity of explicitly using that decade as an example that deserved pointing out, because it demonstrates either ignorance or dishonesty in the argument to the highest degree.

> And yet, the poorest 10-20% didn't have refrigeration, ~1/3 didn't have indoor plumbing, 6% didn't have electricity

Also almost nobody had air conditioning.

Anyways, these are all drastically lower from what they were in the 1920s. Is that because the system prior to the New Deal couldn't distribute them? No, even though the system was measurable worse as far as equality is concerned. Even discounting the geographical confounding factor here, the build out existed and at a higher rate across the population, not just in the long tails. These numbers changed (though miraculously, still haven't hit 0, or even a vanishingly small number) in spite of a different system, which measurably was actually worse. Or were you actually going to elaborate on why this percentile was ONLY capable of receiving these amenities after the economic overhaul in spite of the clear trend of change pre-existing the overhaul? That's a rhetorical question.

> they had almost no healthcare to speak of

Access to healthcare has become worse, actually, not better. Virtually every single working family, not living in the middle of nowhere, had access to healthcare in the 1950s and 60s. That is no longer the case. Simultaneous to this, rural access to healthcare never really improved.

At the end of the day we have to consider your argument has now mutated into the idea that the absolute poorest are better off because the richest are richer. Relatively speaking, they seem be much worse off as a matter of fact. Your causality simply isn't justified, it doesn't even correlate, and when given the slightest scrutiny, all the arguments can't hold water without disingenuity and dishonesty. Especially when it's continuing the grave sin of focusing on the long tails.