Remix.run Logo
bdbdbdb 4 hours ago

I keep coming back to this. The most recent version of chatgpt I tried was able to tell me how many letter 'r's were in a very long string of characters only by writing and executing a python script to do this. Some people say this is impressive, but any 5 year old could count the letters without knowing any python.

williamcotton 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

How is counting not a technology?

The calculations are internal but they happen due to the orchestration of specific parts of the brain. That is to ask, why can't we consider our brains to be using their own internal tools?

I certainly don't think about multiplying two-digit numbers in my head in the same manner as when playing a Dm to a G7 chord that begs to resolve to a C!

armchairhacker 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The 5-year old counts with an algorithm: they remember the current number (working memory, roughly analogous to context), scan the page and move their finger to the next letter. They were taught this.

It's not much different than ChatGPT being trained write a to Python script.

A notable difference is that it's much more efficient to teach something new to a 5-year old than fine-tune or retrain an LLM.

4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]