Remix.run Logo
▲ wcfields 6 hours ago

They’re (the Japanese makers) are getting cooked by the Chinese makers like BYD who make 75%-85% of their parts in-house[1].

Depending on the car, some estimates say that only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come from outside suppliers.

[1] https://www.electrichybridvehicletechnology.com/features/fea...

▲torginus 4 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I think there has been hardcore China scaremongering in the auto industry for some reason, which I feel like has brought people on board with it (and unlike other doomsday trends, this has resonated in Europe ). I feel like the narrative is not even nearly true if we look at the evidence:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automotive_manufacture...

This includes China afaik. Japan is winning so much its not even funny. Besides, every car review of a Chinese car I've watched goes like this: great interior quality, low price, tons of extras (some of them weird), but the car is generally weak on 'core' specifics - ride quality, real-world efficiency/charge speed for EVs, interior space efficiency, ergonomics.

I think that exposes a couple things - I can get a door handle at a hardware store for like 8€ - it'll be made from metal, finished quite well etc etc. So putting in the widgets into cars that make an interior feel great doesn't cost that much, and people care about it a lot. Existing manufacturers have engaged in market segmentation based on this, but the Chinese saw this as an easy win and took it. That's one of the reasons why Chinese cars seem a lot better than what they cost.

▲txdv 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

Do most of the people care? It doesn't feel as nice, you still get from A to B and have shiny screens, that is all they want.

▲cloudbonsai 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This take is somewhat off. The basic context here is that Japanese automakers experienced tremendous supply chain stress due to recent geopolitical events (such as the US-Iran war; you should remember the Strait of Hormuz crisis!)

So JAMA (Japanese automakers’ industrial association) asked what they could do. Their answer was to standardize basic components so that they could reduce bottlenecks.

▲jfsebastian 44 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Toyota decided after the events of Fukushima that their supply-chain has to be way more resistant against external events. I assume they build up up to 6 months (I even remembered 18 months, but couldn't find evidence) of parts to make sure their production is not falling apart.

▲sigmoid10 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

If everyone uses the same parts and components, wouldn't that put even more stress on their respective supply chains in times of crisis? I feel like it would be better to diversify parts and their production more globally, to become independent of individual geopolitical hotspots.

▲andy_ppp 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If you have 10 suppliers all making the same wind screen wiper motor it's obviously better and cheaper than 10 suppliers all making different versions of essentially the same thing. You might argue that this will eventually lead to fewer suppliers because one will manage to undercut the others. Maybe it's on the car manufacturers to source from a wider net even if things are slightly more expensive to keep a stronger ecosystem.

▲cloudbonsai 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The parent comment is schematically correct. Right now each automaker uses its own quality standard for steel. So it’s non-trivial for a steel plant to supply materials to both Toyota and Honda.

Note that the scope of standardization is fairly limited at least for now. JAMA’s initial targets are steel, resins and wires.

▲formerly_proven 22 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's curious that the Japanese OEMs are so far behind on this.

▲sigmoid10 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

>If you have 10 suppliers all making the same wind screen wiper motor it's obviously better and cheaper than 10 suppliers all making different versions

That's a non sequitur. At least unless the whole world switches to the same standard or they all only had one customer to begin with. If those suppliers have to change, adapt or extend their production to accommodate a standard while still shipping their original product to other customers, the end result will be more expensive. And it would have done nothing to relieve the geopolitical issues brought up by the parent comment.

▲awesome_dude 41 minutes ago | parent [-]

Wait - you're saying that because they all change their product, that even though their market size jumps (they don't sell to one car manufacturer, they can sell to all) that that automagically increases costs?

Can I introduce you to peaks, troughs and shoulders?

You're likely to respond that the market stays the same, because its now split up by the wiper manufacturers that were creating specialised systems - fair.

Except nobody is ordering in an even cadence across the year, most orders will be higher at some points, and lower at others. And, the success of a given wiper manufacturer would be coupled hard to the success of the car (model[s]) they build for.

Now, the wiper manufacturers will be able to plan their output, coupled not to a given model(s) success, instead to the Japanese car industries success overall (less variable, still not deterministic though, to be fair)

That brings us to the peaks and troughs section - they dont have to have capacity for the peaks, which goes to waste (idle plant/staff) during the troughs, instead the other customers will fill the shoulders (more even output)

That's significant cost savings for the homogenised (wiper) manufacturers, with the one off cost of refitting their lines (which will be cheaper to do than normal because... multiple of them will be doing it...

▲sigmoid10 30 minutes ago | parent [-]

>even though their market size jumps

Why would it jump? Overall demand doesn't increase under the given assumptions. They'd be selling the same thing in a different form. Producing more forms costs more money.

▲awesome_dude 28 minutes ago | parent [-]

> (they don't sell to one car manufacturer, they can sell to all)

And also:

> You're likely to respond that the market stays the same, because its now split up by the wiper manufacturers that were creating specialised systems - fair.

> Except nobody is ordering in an even cadence across the year, most orders will be higher at some points, and lower at others. And, the success of a given wiper manufacturer would be coupled hard to the success of the car (model[s]) they build for.

Please try to have an honest read before misrepresenting posts.

▲numpad0 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Just imagine the Apollo 13 carbon dioxide scrubber cartridge situation, but it's literally for 30k parts. Of which ~10k are ICE related.

(so, an EV without powertrain may have up to 30% less parts, or as many as 70% as an ICE. not like 10x less, at all. And this is before adding back in 7000 battery cells each made of few parts and the motor itself so... the parts count is actually the same? Interesting)

▲LadyCailin 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Standardizing parts does not imply centralizing production. That may happen due to the inherent pressure to monopolize things, which companies seem to face, but they are orthogonal.

▲falserum 2 hours ago | parent [-]

If there is cause-effect relation, are they actually orthogonal?

▲Retric an hour ago | parent [-]

The cause effect is unrelated to standardization here. Having 2 different types of steel each of which have a single supplier is not meaningfully different than having 1 type of steel and a single supplier.

▲serial_dev 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Which one is easier to get, a USB-C cable or (insert esoteric cable config)?

▲TeMPOraL 2 hours ago | parent [-]

OTOH, once you have a source for "USB-C cable" / "(insert esoteric cable config)", which one's gonna be more reliable experience ordering repeatedly?

Chances are, the esoteric crap comes from one plant and has one major customer, so every bit is gonna be the same.

With USB-C cables, Who the fkkk knows what you'll get? The only bit guaranteed identical between two USB-C cables is the connector shape. Everything else is lottery.

At this point I think EU should introduce a mandatory labeling scheme for USB-C cables, so that each cable is stamped both on packaging and on the cable itself, with the very same stuff USB-C cable tester shows it. And since the "better" cables have chips on board, we could enroll them in the same "Battery Passport" / "Digital Product Passport" thing, with steep fines to all the importers or resellers who waste people's time selling fake cables.

▲awesome_dude 34 minutes ago | parent [-]

> which one's gonna be more reliable experience ordering repeatedly?

Conversely - in the esoteric world, if the manufacturer is disinclined to produce "quality" - what exactly are you going to do about it?

▲gniv 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't think this is a parts story fundamentally. The Japanese are behind in electric vehicles. They are trying to survive using these tricks but unless they start getting serious about making EVs they are doomed.

▲drnick1 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

In some markets, the US notably, electric cars are kind of a curiosity. I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla. At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.

▲AnthonyMouse 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla.

The problem there is you're comparing a Corolla to a Tesla and not e.g. a Chevy Bolt, which has a lower TCO than both.

> At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.

There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.

The main issue with trucks is that to give an electric truck a reasonable range when hauling a load, it needs a much bigger battery, and then to justify that you have to be actually using it as a truck full-time rather than as a truck-shaped car. Which is fully justified when you are, because then the fuel savings are enormous.

Whereas the people not really using it as a truck don't really need the bigger battery and then it doesn't have to cost that much. And even that isn't going to matter if the battery prices keep going down.

The other option which the US companies seem to be leaning into is to use the smaller battery and offer a range extender that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a gas generator.

▲verisimi 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.

Right. It's subsidies/incentives. And, of course, operating within the legal/governance structure, you can 'fine' the vehicles you don't like - have special clean air zones with fees for entry, high tax for oil/petrol, etc.

I hope you didn't mean this was something to do with costs. It's just the government using licensing, laws, taxes, etc to direct proceedings as they want - nothing to do with the underlying costs.

▲AnthonyMouse 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Large delivery trucks get like 10 MPG when they run on gasoline, and even worse than that in stop and go. Operating one full time puts its fuel consumption in the tens of thousands of dollars a year. Eliminating two thirds of that by using EVs pays for itself straight away without any subsidies.

▲eru 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla.

The main issue is that the US effectively bans imports of electric cars from the most efficient suppliers on the planet.

▲adrianN 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car though. It costs twice as much as a Dacia Spring and Chinese models are much better value, or so I’ve heard.

▲ErroneousBosh an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car though.

It's a luxury *price*. It is not luxury *quality*.

They're pretty crappy cars for the price, lots of flimsy plastic and bling.

▲speedgoose 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It depends what you value. If you value software quality and UX too, Tesla still has a competitive offer.

▲Lio 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Tesla also comes with massive political baggage in the form of Musk.

His interference in elections and the war in Ukraine hasn’t gone unnoticed in many markets. Tesla comes with weaker residual value because of the brand damage.

Now that other manufacturers are moving away from soft-screens towards tactile controls software UX is much less important too.

Personally, I’d much rather have “knob per function” than have to go menu diving through a GUI at 80mph.

There’s many great alternatives now that really are great value. i.e. Renault, Nissan, Skoda, VW, BMW, Dacha.

▲fodkodrasz 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Support the free world: Just buy European. Or a Japanese (I don't like those so much).

The US and China can go play their rivalry and soft and proxy wars somewhere else.

▲speedgoose 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I drove a VW ID recently and you have plenty of physical buttons everywhere you look as the driver, yet some important features are behind the touch screen.

If you ignore the ongoing nazi car brand aspect, which is pretty hard to I agree, I am not convinced the traditional car brands you mentioned are better value. And they have a nazi past too. But that’s a while ago so it’s okay.

▲coryrc an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Dieselgate stochastically killed a lot of people recently.

▲Lio 20 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

OK, if don’t like German car brands because of their past there’s still Renault (French) and Nissan (Japanese).

Both have reasonably priced, well engineered EVs in their range now.

Both use Android Auto and IMHO that works very smoothly and without jank. Plus they have physical controls.

Personally it’s a company’s present and future behaviour that I care most about rather than stuff that happened in the 1930s and 40s no matter how horrific.

▲f6v 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What a load of bs, people have the attention span of a fruit fly. Saw one clown put a sticker "I got it before Elon went crazy!" on their Tesla in Copenhagen, but that's about it. Danish are buying Teslas like there's no tomorrow.

▲Symbiote 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Danes are buying EVs as fast as they can before a possible tax increase next year, but preferring European and Chinese vehicles where possible.

If they can't get something else, they settle for a Tesla.

Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV sales in October 2026 in Denmark.

▲retsibsi an hour ago | parent [-]

> Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV sales in October 2026 in Denmark.

Is this figure really for EVs only? I don't find this article[0] absolutely clear, but in context it seems to be referring to Tesla's share of all passenger car sales:

> Norway remained a bright spot for Tesla. The carmaker recorded its best October on record and was the country's top-selling car brand with a 9.8% market share, according to OFV. Chinese brands continued to expand their footprint, accounting for 22.5% of new passenger car registrations, their highest monthly share on record.

> [irrelevant quote]

> By contrast, Tesla's market share in Denmark was only 0.73%, behind BYD (002594.SZ), Leapmotor (9863.HK), Xpeng (9868.HK), and SAIC-owned MG (600104.SS), which captured between 1.6% and 5.5% of the market each.

[0] https://www.reuters.com/business/tesla-registrations-surge-a...

▲Symbiote 39 minutes ago | parent [-]

I think you're correct, but with EV sales at over 80% of car sales in Denmark it doesn't make much difference.

▲retsibsi 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

Thanks, I hadn't realised the EV market was that big. You're of course right that the difference is therefore very small.

▲shoobiedoo 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

And politicians associated with Chinese makers are clean as a whistle?

I've got no love for the cringe machine that is Elon, but c'mon. Would people really buy from a Chinese maker over Tesla based on some kind of political stance?

▲Lio 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

That’s a good question that I can’t answer but for the sake of argument there’s plenty of other EV manufacturers in the European EV market at least.

▲Garlef 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes

▲happymellon an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Personally? Absolutely!

The Chinese haven't been spending a lot of money to support right wing authoritarian governments in my country.

Buying Tesla does. So you don't have to be "clean as a whistle" to be a massive improvement.

▲pepperoni_pizza an hour ago | parent [-]

But they are heavily supporting Russia which is definitely spending money to support right wing authoritarian governments in you country.

Worse than Musk? Probably not. Better than Musk? Also probably no.

▲Symbiote 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

At least regarding Denmark, Chinese leaders and EV CEOs haven't threatened to invade the country.

▲adrianN an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm under the impression that even among the outliers that are people who buy new cars instead of used, most buy cars because they need to go places. How many of those are willing to shell out an extra 15k or so for something as vague as software quality?

▲viraptor 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's very little difference between Tesla and BYD day to day. I'm also going to have Android Auto open virtually all the time so couldn't see any difference.

▲MobiusHorizons 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I think Tesla doesn’t have Android Auto or Apple CarPlay. I have never driven one, but that’s what I read.

▲kakacik an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I would never pay twice the price of the car for those, and tesla has made some properly stupid hostile UI decisions like moving turn lights into steering wheel.

Plus tesla is poisoned by nazi owner who is extremely hostile towards Europe for whatever reasons and feels like he needs to interfere in global politics, that brand is burned for good regardless of products. Something about having actual morals and spine and voting with wallet and not supporting evil actors if you don't have to.

▲oblio 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Honest question: what do people need software quality for? What exactly are they doing with their cars that need all that in-car software? A phone attached to the center column offers a better software experience than any car maker could offer. Are people really paying that much to play games on their car screens?

▲kuerbel 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

No. I own a tesla and what I value is the integrated dashcam and sentry mode. Next comes route planning (which is gmaps under the hood but on a larger screen so easier to see). Energy information so that I can check how much I used and when.

▲drnick1 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> integrated dashcam and sentry mode.

Unfortunately, that footage does not stay on your computer/car.

https://www.drive.com.au/news/tesla-shared-private-camera-re...

▲kakacik an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

This is common in every major chinese EV manufacturer now, maybe apart from rock bottom cost tier.

I've sat in my friend's 600 HP Zeekr few months ago and saw all you mention in some form or another plus much, much more than in my colleague's tesla 3.

▲Symbiote 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For an EV, planning a longer route where a charging stop is needed.

Ideally that should work to your preference, for example a restaurant vs fast food nearby.

▲speedgoose 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It’s more about having something that works well than a crazy feature set.

▲sandmn 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That is if automaker supports Apple CarPlay/Android Auto. Tesla (and some other companies) does not.

▲numpad0 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If EVs are "curiosity" in the US, it's dead. I think almost all the countries EVs have been successful are places that have lower population densities than the global average(not G7 or European average), including the US and not including China.

▲Lutger 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

TCO in Europe for EV is beating ICE for a while now, that isn't the case in the US? Why not? Is it because Americans like big inefficient cars more, or is gasoline that much cheaper?

▲fodkodrasz 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Also larger distances, and everything laid out inefficiently with bad zoning. Basically motor-lobby ruined it for them.

Just bought a PHEV (Peugeot), and if you can charge at home it runs rounds around ICE cost-wise, eves with it being relatively power-hungry compared to some alternatives (but so comfortable and sleek). With public charging it is marginally cheaper than ICE, pricing of public charge points swallowed the price advantage, but I guess it is not free to build that infrastructure, so its okay I guess.

▲goosejuice 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla

Atlas Policy has the 2024 models within a few grand of each other at 7 years. It's not significant and the Tesla is a much nicer car. Hybrids are expensive to maintain.

▲huijzer 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I have owned a Tesla for a year but have now switched back to petrol simply because of range. I’ve spent way too many hours at fast chargers. And this was in the Netherlands and Germany. US distances are typically much longer from what I understand.

▲cheapcheerful 40 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

This sounds very strange to me. My Model 3 goes 550km on a single charge. I use the charger at home and charge it like my phone. I've used a fast charger twice in 3 years, only as a curiosity.

I'm guessing maybe your problem was that you live in an apartment which doesn't provide a parking space with electricity, so fast charge was only option? Definintely an issue, especially in some countries where the usual home isn't a standalone single story like Australia where I live.

▲consp 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You should also realise you are the outlier. Most people travel far less than the range of their vehicles (petrol or EV).

▲gertrunde 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This does tie into a good point - EVs get surprisingly expensive if you charge away from home.

The price difference between home charging vs a fast charger can be extreme, 6-7p/unit vs 80-90p/unit.

▲gniv 14 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Yes but this too is temporary. If you think how much cheaper it is to install a charging station than a gas station there is no reason competition will not drive down prices in the future.

▲kuerbel 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I exclusively charge away from home since I don't own a wallbox. I also regularly drive from north Germany to Switzerland, in my model 3 Highland that means 2-3 charge stops. Which I would do anyway.

Usually I charge when I go grocery shopping. I can't remember the last time I drove to a charging station just to charge.

▲seibelj 3 hours ago | parent [-]

[dead]

▲kees99 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Whle I obviously can't know exact GP's situation in particular, statistically speaking they are not necessarily an outlier, for the region they are from.

Typical Dutch driving pattern is strongly bimodal - a lot of everyday short trips (think commuting), plus several holiday trips per year - Austria, south of France, Italy, you name it. That would be the trips where "too many hours at fast chargers" would be a problem for me personally.

▲ 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲Brian_K_White 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The fact that most people only drive a few miles most of the time is true exactly like most people don't have house fires most of the time.

It's a true statement, they don't. Yet everyone, not just people with jobs and hobbies that cause fires, still needs smoke alarms and fire extinguishers and building codes that demand multiple exits from bedrooms etc.

This "outlier" argument that a lot of people think makes sense, doesn't. It's completely invalid. Most people could actually get by with a golf cart most of the time. Except no they can't, because most of the time isn't good enough.

▲Lio 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Out of interest how much range do you need?

BMW just launched an i3 with a 567 mile range. Is that enough?

Personally I think I’d be pretty happy with 300 to 400 miles.

Range will increase over time.

There’s still lots of efficiency improvements to be made like replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.

We will get to a point where EV range is greater than on ICE cars.

▲MobiusHorizons 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.

There are a lot of drawbacks to this strategy btw. Unsprung weight gets a lot worse, and expensive high voltage parts become much more exposed to elements and shock loads. The benefits seem unlikely to outweigh the drawbacks for most applications.

▲Lio 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> Unsprung weight gets a lot worse

Not necessarily. Where it gets interesting are the prototypes with lower unsprung weight than the equivalent braking system.

They’re not there yet but it shows there’s definitely new avenues to explore.

▲Lutger 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't own a car, never have, but for everybody I know who has an EV (in the Netherlands) this is not an issue at all. After you need a recharge people need a coffee break too, and 20 minutes fast charging is enough to get you there. Maybe you have different needs or don't take breaks from driving that much?

▲Revanche1367 38 minutes ago | parent [-]

I don’t know about Europe, but it’s quite typical in the US to drive for 1-1.5 hours for a regular commute. I drive to grad school 2-3 times a week for ~50 minutes typically for example, can easily be an hour on some days, no stops at all because that’s a relatively short distance. For longer journeys, we typically don’t stop except maybe every 2-3 hours. We would only stop for 20 minutes or more for a lunch break, not coffee, and once in the middle of a 5-8 hour road trip with smaller 5-10 minute stops sparsely placed.

▲hdgvhicv 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I do 35,000km a year / more than twice the average in the U.K - and have used a fast charger 5 times this year.

▲fc417fc802 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> US distances are typically much longer from what I understand.

Ehh that's complicated. They're much _much_ longer once you get out into the sticks. In the suburbs I imagine it varies. But in urban areas AFAIK they're fairly similar and as it happens those are the areas where you benefit from EVs the most while also being where people with highly paid jobs tend to be located.

▲awestroke 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The US banned the import and sales of chinese EVs like BYD. Who knows what american roads would have looked like otherwise?

Only 16-20% of cars on the road in the "u"s are trucks, so not really relevant anyway.

▲inemesitaffia 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm pretty sure the Ford CEO owns a Chinese car

▲bell-cot 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Roughly yes:

https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/didn-t...

But the rules may differ for those of us who are not major automotive CEO's.

▲dzhiurgis 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

For sure and kinda understandable (i get - i just don’t get it, like the gun thing). But Toyota does sell different cars for different markets, why can’t they EVs for markets that want them. It took them 1.5 decades to make EV that’s finally competes with others makers.

▲anovikov 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It means firing a lot of people (labor intensity of EV production is much lower) and Japanese automakers can't do that for a multitude of reasons. They are cooked, they will just go out of business. Fast.

▲gniv 11 minutes ago | parent [-]

Germany is currently going through this transition. It will be interesting to see what happens.

▲modeless 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah, it's not clear to me why people are just taking it as gospel that this will improve competitiveness. IMO it seems like it would lead to stagnation as it becomes more difficult for a single company to change anything.

▲AngryData 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I think it very much depends on how this is implemented. Some things simply don't need to have design changes almost ever because it it is a solved problem. Some things just need to share attachment points to be swapped with other or better versions. Like why do we need 20 different oil filter styles for 20 different cars? Why is one car battery 1/2 inch longer so it doesn't fit in another cars battery tray despite being the same capacity? Why do we need 20 different tierod ends on 20 different cars when a single design would work with 80% of them?

▲dmurray an hour ago | parent [-]

Several commentators mention batteries. Is this an issue in the US?

In Europe every car I've had has had roughly interchangeable batteries. There might be two or three different sizes for family petrol cars. That seems like a reasonable amount of useful variation for manufacturers to choose between when playing Tetris with all the components they need to fit alongside the engine.

▲rootsudo 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Agree and disagree, a framework of standardized motor and frame, unibody or frame on body would be great.

Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?” At the same time this means they can still customize the sheet metal, for different trims and types but the motor is the same, transmission is the same, seat is the same, etc

And for those parts, do we really need new part numbers every year? Heterogeneous is great? But something something Henry ford you can have any color as long as it’s black is also ok.

Plus it isn’t really new, brand engineering is this. Toyota grabs the bmw z4 and makes it a Supra, Mazda grabs the rav4 and makes it the cx50, etc

▲MBCook 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Tesla has basically proven the answer is no.

And personally I think most cars have been getting uglier. I would’ve been happy if they stuck with what they had 10 years ago.

So yeah, if you wanna save money, stop wasting it on a new redesign every few years. Don’t waste the money retooling to change random things every year.

▲jeffreygoesto 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Trabant and Wartburg also have, long ago ;).

▲numpad0 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Those and 911 had proven it's an ok engineering decision and a commercial suicide at the same time.

▲poisonborz 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

^ This commenter enjoys real cars

▲bdangubic 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Tesla is an example of an actual opposite. Their best-selling model is the last one released, the refreshed Models Y and 3. Ones they try to keep selling year after year have been discontinued.

▲skybrian 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Wasn’t the last one released the Cybertruck?

▲heyjamesknight 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Refreshed Y and 3 came out after the Cybertruck

▲munch-o-man 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

wasn't the last one to release the cybertruck?

▲bigfatkitten 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Car manufacturers have been doing this since the early 1900s. They call these designs “platforms” or “vehicle architectures.”

They might do a cosmetic facelift every couple of years but the platform will typically stay in production for a decade or so.

GM in particular are famous for using the same chassis, drivetrain, floorpan etc on half a dozen or more models across their marques.

▲14 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For me someone who does most of my car maintenance and repairs this would be very attractive knowing that parts were standardized and by doing so would guarantee that there would be a huge aftermarket parts marker since one part could target multiple models and this would mean competitive prices thus lowering the cost of repairs.

Still, however, as great as cheap available parts would be.. the major car brands desperately need to find ways to significantly lower the price of their cars. New cars and trucks are reaching the prices of like a big down payment you could put on a house. Standardized parts would definitely reduce costs but would that be enough? Even many 2 income households struggle to get ahead. In my opinion the number one priority of these companies should be how can they make an inexpensive car that the average person can afford.

▲BoingBoomTschak 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Well, at least in Europe, the cost problem may be due to regulations and safety gimmicks. Look into the madness of GSR2.

▲ExoticPearTree 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?”

The problem that I have with cars in general is that they use pretty old technology and you want something new that actually works OK and it does not have that much lag. While I understand the myth about manufacturers using old components because they are proven, they should get over it and use circuits made in the 21st century. Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).

Another thing is the subtle but annoying differences in cars in different geographies: in one country you have a 360-degree camera system, but in others they don't even offer it as an add-on. For the same car. And other little things.

What I would like to see though would be to have the ability to upgrade the hardware in the car every 2-3 years. Like replace 2-3 "boxes" full of components and have "an almost new car" with improved technology.

▲fc417fc802 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).

This is a rather unenlightened take. The electronics used in cars aren't typical consumer gear - the parts are much more rugged. This is for good reason. The same car could start life parked on the side of the road in the nevada desert (wild temperature fluctuations), go on a roadtrip through death valley in the summer, and a few years later be parked on the street in florida (ridiculously humid) or somewhere in north dakota (extreme cold). Meanwhile we expect not to have any major electrical issues over a 20+ year product life. It's actually fairly absurd when you stop and think about it.

▲marcta 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'd prefer them to keep using the old parts if they work. That way I am more likely to be able to take it to an independent garage who will have compatible parts, rather than taking it to the dealership & paying a premium as well as waiting for ages for them to ship the brand new part in.

▲lazide 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

For them to stay competitive as independent companies? Of course! Otherwise they look identical and have the same parts, and their only competitive difference is what? Pricing? On the same parts?

They might as well merge now and save the drama.

▲VorpalWay 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If they standardize internal components like tie rods, wheel bearings and battery trays, I doubt anyone would think the cars look the same. In fact, I think this would be great: standardise the jelly bean parts that don't really change much and don't see much innovation. There is absolutely no reason that different cars should use different incompatible 12 V batteries when the capacity is identical.

▲jnellis 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Otherwise they look identical

Hasn't this ship already sailed?

▲lelanthran 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> For them to stay competitive as independent companies? Of course! Otherwise they look identical and have the same parts, and their only competitive difference is what? Pricing? On the same parts?

What makes you think they'd look identical? You think the only parts in a car are cosmetic parts?

▲powerapple 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For most parts, they are actually just (unnecessarily) designed to be not compatible so that the manufacturer will take profit from parts as well. Incompatibility becomes a feature for profit, not for anything else. This might actually be good for competition because now a small company can start with less money and standardized parts and focus on things they can actually make a difference.

▲WalterBright 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Ferrari would use parts from other car companies. What Ferrari cared about was the engine.

▲hinkley 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Part of the reason Japanese cars had trouble getting a toehold in the Midwest is that American cars already had suppliers in common so it was more likely they had a set of rotors for your random Ford and they had to order them for your Subaru. That was also before people read some of the books on supply chains so those orders took longer.

▲mahirsaid 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

if the US market thought it can compete or win certain markets then the door would be open. FOR: Smartphone, Software, AI models, EV Cars, Routers, etc,

The reason is because Cybersecurity is a priority for us and the Chinese are spying on us blah blah. I know for sure that cybercrime was no where as frequent as today, and with that not only is it from china anymore along with a much larger scale of intrusion and theft.

▲wurstburst 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Is laughable seeing people from the US blaming their incompetence accusing others.

The thing is that China entered in your capitalized game and won.

Accusing any one of spying as a justification for your failures is kind of ridiculous.

The all powerful US creates sanctions, extreme protectionist and a lot of economic obstacles for everyone.

You guys are living in a dystopian world for ages. Your “free market” and free competition is an hallucination that you decided to believe.

The disasters the World had to accept in favor of the US “superiority” are far more terrible than you not being able to compete with EV.

▲andy_ppp 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The Chinese makers are heavily subsidised both by stealing process from Tesla and just plain old cash ($230bn since 2009) and also the ingenuity and hard work of the Chinese people. Beijing even promoted an Audi engineer to be in charge of developing EVs and supporting the businesses, we have nothing like this in the west to cut through the layers of bureaucracy in the way of doing anything useful.

But yes I guess building everything yourself cuts out the middle man but obviously if the Japanese government spent $10bn (probably in Japan more like $20bn purchasing parity) into subsidising electric vehicles parts, robotics and supply chains I'm pretty sure it would have helped. Instead the Japanese government invested about 1/10th the amount of the Chinese.

My point is saying sure the end result could be vertical integration, however it's a million different things they did and number one was getting the right person into a position of power rather than a corrupt politician.

▲IrishTechie 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

There’s a fairly good chance that had Japan provided funding to the likes of Toyota they would have used it to increase their funding of climate denial, anti-EV disinformation campaigns and boondoggles like hydrogen passenger cars to distract from mass roll-out of EVs.

I’m very concerned about ceding auto manufacturing to China as we are doing, but as you say there have been a lot of factors involved and some of them very much self inflicted.

▲faangguyindia 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>The Chinese makers are heavily subsidised both by stealing process from Tesla

Elon Musk himself claims, "you are free to clone our satellite and car manufacturing; we only file defensive patents"

▲gpt5 43 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

To be fair, Musk did not sue BYD, despite some widely considered clones of his cars and processes. Other manufacturers did. For example, in the EU, you can't sell the BYD Ti7 because a court ruled it violated Jaguar Land Rover IP.

▲stuaxo 42 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

He says all sorts of things.

▲origini an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

The industry knows by now how to build cars.

Pointing out Tesla feels overstated.

▲WorldPeas 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

the toyota/byd bz3[1] seems similar to the NUMMI efforts made in the 90s by GM/Toyota, GM seems to be doing similar things with luxury brands more popular abroad like GM/Cadillac[2] though there may be a wean-off for those due to tariffs

[1]https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/exclus...

[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAIC-GM

▲xeonmc 2 hours ago | parent [-]

More background:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjxZ2Eh9GrA

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gung_Ho_(film)

▲_s_a_m_ 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Funny how BYD has the inverse strategy of German car makers, who are obesessed with fossile fules and make absolte nothing in-house. They are cooked.

▲bpodgursky 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

EVs are simpler than ICE, much less hybrids, and Japan has been infamously slow to build pure EVs.

So yes, but the drag is downstream of highly conservative product positioning not incompetence.

▲hyperation 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Subjectively, I think Japan was smart to not go full on EV, given the constraints they have; charging infrastructure, battery sourcing, and range. At the time when Tesla was selling under 500k cars (2020 and earlier) a year, there wasn't a problem with battery supply (they were able to ramp up). During the same time Toyota (e.g.) would be selling close to 10 million, and converting their customers to EV would cannibalize their own sales. Additionally, the current charging infrastructure can't even supply the EVs today if we add just 10% more on the road.

Even worst, if you're in California, the per mile price to charge an EV at home, without solar, is greater than filling up a hybrid Prius on today's gas prices.

▲grumbelbart a few seconds ago | parent | next [-]

> Even worst, if you're in California, the per mile price to charge an EV at home, without solar, is greater than filling up a hybrid Prius on today's gas prices.

Do you have a source for that? So all sources I find say that the energy cost per mile on electic is around 1/3rd than that of gas.

▲rebuilder 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The difference between the electric/gas price comparison depending on where you live is pretty wild. Here in Finland it’s completely the other way around - charging at home is about 1/10 the price of gasoline, assuming a relatively efficient gasoline vehicle. That’s just the cost of energy of course, EVs are expensive to purchase.

▲hdgvhicv 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

US gas prices are heavily subsidised by military interventions throughout the Middle East, and don’t factor in any externalities. On the other hand electric is massively abstractive and cheap electricity has major political blocks. Regulations and other punitive measures means US Solar panels cost twice that of Europe.

▲DaedalusII an hour ago | parent [-]

US gas prices are most heavily subsidised by domestic energy production since fracking was commercialised, military interventions havent been a major factor in the last decade or so

▲hdgvhicv an hour ago | parent [-]

I’m looking more at the last 80 years as a whole. The manner of subsidy has always changed, but the subsidy remains.

Oddly though some types of energy as massively taxed. Taxation on solar in the US means that it costs 3-4 times the price in Europe and Australia. This is a political choice the US population made to have more expensive energy.

▲fc417fc802 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

TBF it's much cheaper pretty much anywhere that isn't california. Their electric grid has been about as mismanaged as I think it's possible to be while remaining a highly developed country. But one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_Fire_(2018)#Infrastructur...

▲adrianN 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If you don’t risk cannibalizing your own sales you risk other companies eating them.

▲bell-cot 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, but human emotions. Other companies are long-term external enemies. Cannibalism is treason within your own group.

▲hdgvhicv 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Nissan sold the first mass produced (100k) EV from 2010 onwards, and still sells them, it had sold about 500k by 2020.

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲Paradigma11 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Same way it was smart for Kodak not to cannibalize their analog camera and film sales by migrating to digital.

▲SAI_Peregrinus 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Hybrid transmissions are simpler than ICE transmissions. More complex overall drivetrains than EVs, they're intermediate complexity.

▲simondotau an hour ago | parent [-]

This is largely true of Toyota-style power-split e-CVT hybrids and series hybrids such as Nissan e-POWER, both of which eliminate (or dramatically simplify) the mechanical complexity of conventional transmissions.

Most other hybrid architectures are built around a conventional transmission and retain all of the mechanical complexity of an ICE drivetrain while adding substantial electrical complexity on top.

▲ExoticPearTree 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Depending on the car, some estimates say that only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come from outside suppliers.

Until they grow big enough to make their own glass.

For tires it does not make sense to integrate that too. Unless someone has the bright ideea to sell unconventional sizes, like 18.2" or something crazy like that.

▲dyauspitr 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What does that even mean? They’re definitely not making their chips in house they can’t be making their vision systems in house. Even the wires, I don’t think BYD is making its own wires. Unless I’m completely wrong and BYD is just that vertically stacked.

▲oefrha 2 hours ago | parent [-]

They're definitely making their chips in house, see BYD Semiconductor Co Ltd. Just not all their chips. And they have a subsidiary making sensors.

▲youre-wrong3 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[dead]

▲vibebingo 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]