Remix.run Logo
▲ UK Government Forced to Admit It Issued Apple a Secret Encryption Order(macanorak.com)
156 points by Terretta 2 hours ago | 82 comments
▲natch an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Apple has significantly weakened its security assurances in a way that is arguably deceptive. They used to say nobody can access your data, not even Apple. Now they say Apple cannot access your data. People will point out that your key is created on your device, lives on your device, and never leaves your device, but that is just your key. Your key is likely a KEK (key encryption key) that opens another key (not “your” key, let’s call it the actual key) that your data is secured with. There can be other parties (UK government) with their own KEK that opens a copy of the actual key. In this scenario, Apple can have no access to a KEK that opens the actual key, but they are forced to make the wording change they did, if they want to stay honest.

I say the statement is arguably deceptive because it presents the same feel of assurance that the old one did, to most people.

Note John Ternus in a recent event (WWDC keynote if I recall correctly) used the old wording. I think this was a slip-up (I’d hate to think it was a calculated lie posing as a slip-up).

▲midtake a minute ago | parent | next [-]

The on-device private key material has to be a KEK anyway, otherwise it wouldn't be usable on all your iCloud-linked devices.

I still trust Apple in the USA at least. When I enrolled in advanced data protection, it did say nobody not even Apple, not just not Apple. It may be that they need to tighten their contractual language everywhere to deliver a uniformly semantic sentence.

▲elAhmo 10 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Didn't they also deceptively say that those things that Apple cannot access only apply to local content, but if you have an iCloud backup (which pretty much anyone has), then Apple has access to that.

▲s3p 24 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This isn't related to the article, and it's not true? iCloud ADP still exists in its original form, there was no modification allowing 3rd parties access to ADP decryption keys.

▲sandworm101 30 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well, if Apple provided the KEK to the UK government then Apple is capable of generating another KEK for its own use. That means Apple can in fact access customer data on its own, just after a couple extra steps.

(Yes it is theoretically possible to create a complex encryption scheme whereby the UK government posses the only copy of a key that is in turn needed to generated a duplicate KEK, but I find it hard to believe Apple and the UK government have organized such a dance without a simple backup for the day the magic UK key gets lost/corrupted.)

▲hrncn 26 minutes ago | parent [-]

Given the legalese these extra steps are all that matters. Keep in mind that Apple could just update the software to do whatever it wants it to do, too. It's not like Apple customers are in control of what runs on their phones.

▲chunky1994 37 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Where exactly do they say this, where is this wording change?

https://support.apple.com/en-us/102651#advanced

"This specifies no one, not even apple." I.e they don't store the keys you use for e2e encryption. They've systematically been against introducing backdoors here. Now, is it possible they have and they've been lying through their teeth? Surre, but its unlikely they would be so brazen.

▲gmueckl 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

Not sure about the extent of UK investigative powers, but I would assume that FISA in the US could indeed force Apple to lie to keep a change secret.

▲slopinthebag 44 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

it appears apple has done this in response to government interference which they cannot even legally disclose. what would you have apple do here?

▲jimbob45 9 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Came to say this. It actively hurts Apple's revenue to make these changes and not be able to market themselves as privacy leaders. They wouldn't make these changes unless they had to.

It's one thing if your company never tried to be privacy-first and you went above and beyond what the government requested but there's no evidence of that here.

▲joe_the_user 27 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

If Apple gave the user unconditional control of their own devices, they wouldn't be able to comply with these orders. But they never want to do this nor would the cellular providers permit this.

But I don't think we should reason based on "put yourself in mega-corp's shoes, they absolutely have to X thing". Rather, we should ask what people can do.

▲fweimer an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Primary source: https://investigatorypowerstribunal.org.uk/judgement/1-mr-vi...

The key finding seems to be that the media learned of the technical capability notice through confidential security briefings, and not a leak (“one of those irregular verbs”).

The contents of the note remains secret for now.

▲exe34 35 minutes ago | parent [-]

"I give confidential press briefings; you leak; he's been charged under Section 2a of the Official Secrets Act".

▲Y_Y 16 minutes ago | parent [-]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotive_conjugation

▲peterclary 11 minutes ago | parent [-]

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0751832/quotes/?item=qt0174103

▲puppycodes 33 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Sorta thought this was alreay common knowledge? Unfortunately the UK has never respected privacy or free speech as a right.

▲mctt a minute ago | parent | next [-]

Yes! From the article; "The existence of the order was already public knowledge and continuing to pretend otherwise was obstructing the proper consideration of the legal challenge."

▲logicchains 19 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

>Unfortunately the UK has never respected privacy or free speech as a right.

England's a rather old country, and doesn't actually have any kind of constitutional mechanism that protects citizens' rights against the government. There is a bill of rights, but there's no court with the power to strike down laws that violate it, so it's essentially toothless. More modern countries tend to have supreme courts with the power to strike down rights-violating laws, e.g. the US, Japan, Germany and India.

▲MomsAVoxell 15 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Alas, it's kind of up to the people, not governments, nor the courts - which are there to serve the people. A people has to affirm the right - but so many of us just assume it. That has been exploited by the police-state'ers who control the secrets, and thus everything.

And anyway, free speech isn't possible in a system keeping secrets. The corruption of any organization, including government, begins with its secrets. A truly free well organized people keep no secrets nor tolerate it of their governance.

We speak of democracy; what form of democracy is operating behind that secret wall? The 5-eyes conundrum is a reality - there's a superstate which exists beyond all common public knowledge about things, and which operates to give itself reasons to exist.

If there is a use for AI, its to replace all systems of secrecy, which is anathema to the creation of a model in the first place.

Citizens of all nations, not just the 5-eyes encumbered pseudo-democracies, need to demand the universality of human rights be affirmed by all who wish to rule.

▲hedora 15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We should all demand our governments incorporate existing international human rights charted into our constitutions. The EU one is a decent start.

▲foldr 7 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

While there are some advantages to the US model, it also leads to a lot of obscure legalistic wrangling over an old document that's full of ambiguities. And of course, the protections that the document supposedly offers often turn out not to materialize, or to be revocable, once the 'right' people are appointed to the supreme court.

On the whole I prefer the British approach here. If you want abortion to be legal, pass a law making it legal, rather than trying to conduct a courtroom seance with some oldentimes dudes. It's to the discredit of the US system that important issues such as affirmative action, gay marriage, abortion, etc. cannot (in practice) be decided by legislation at the federal level, but instead must be decided by a series of court decisions which cannot even be relied on to be respected by future instantiations of the court.

▲slopinthebag an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

can anyone justify the idea that governments can keep these orders secret? it seems to me that a government trying to hide this kind of thing is doing so maliciously and should not be holding power over it's citizens, who deserve to know that this kind of thing is happening.

▲chunky1994 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The steelman is that if forced to make this public, then bad actors/criminals and their enterprises can take steps to remove/expunge their operations from their existing locations so that nothing is found. Often these investigations take place over the course of years so they need to be able to keep production orders secret or else they will lose the investigative progress they have made.

I don't agree at all with the thesis, and surely there could be after the fact revelation/foi requests made possible, but govts don't like to cede power to their citizens in general.

▲gadders 12 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I guess an analogous thing would be the operation against EncroChat and their phones [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EncroChat

▲cassianoleal an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This doesn't seem to be connected to an active investigation though, but rather just standing powers to break encryption at will.

If it was for an active investigation, one would think it would be targeted to those under investigation.

▲rightnutwingjob an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Is it not true that if bad actors become aware they can, in fact, take steps to mitigate the risk?

What are you not agreeing with?

▲chunky1994 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I don't agree with the thesis that this needs to be forever secret. Every law I've seen keeps the secret requirement indefinite.

▲Computer0 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don’t agree that I care

▲synarchefriend an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

If we don't install a little camera in everyone's home, bad actors can exploit this loophole to engage in all kinds of criminal activities.

The question is whether making law enforcement easier is worth the sacrifice of everyone's privacy. The optimal amount of crime is not zero.

▲exe34 33 minutes ago | parent [-]

We need to agree on an optimal level of crime with the syndicates, and let them issue permits for individual crimes.

▲thaumasiotes 39 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> I don't agree at all with the thesis, and surely there could be after the fact revelation/foi requests made possible

I don't agree with the policy either, but come on. After the fact discussion causes exactly the same notional harm as contemporaneous discussion: people learn what you're doing, and move their records somewhere safer.

▲hedora 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

The same argument applies for secret laws, which usually go hand in hand with secret surveillance programs.

If we discussed why the court found some person guilty, then people would just avoid breaking the law.

▲betterunix2 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I do not think there is any justification, but it is not hard to think of reasons that are less malicious than you suggest. For example, Apple has made privacy and encryption part of its marketing strategy and news about governments ordering Apple to decrypt data and hand it over undermines their business. The government would likely prefer a non-adversial relationship with Apple and not undermining their business is obviously part of that.

We can debate whether blame should be assigned to the government for doing this in secret or to Apple for overselling encryption and creating a situation where complying with these orders threatens their business. We can also debate whether or not the government should care about the business impact of these orders.

▲ndiddy an hour ago | parent [-]

I think it's important to make the public aware that if your threat model involves keeping your activities private from the government of your country, sending anything sensitive over the internet is risky. This is regardless of how much a provider claims to care about your privacy, or how much they brag about encryption technology etc.

▲augment_me an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

In surveillance capitalism, order and control is achieved by an informational assymetry.

Google understood this early on. When the user does not know what the algorithm does or how it works, there can be no discussion or ideas on how to make it fairer. It does not make sense to tell the population about this, as it will cause unrest.

▲sublinear 9 minutes ago | parent [-]

Today is an early day too for something in the future. The "discussion" about the algorithm is inevitable.

▲bflesch an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes they can because it is a monarchy.

▲autoexec an hour ago | parent | next [-]

You can bet that the NSA is already embedded in Apple and able to access anything and everything they want. Local law enforcement and other agencies may be left crying about how they want that data too, but that still leaves us being spied on.

▲viktorcode 10 minutes ago | parent [-]

I bet it is not so, and I would like you to present any evidence to the contrary.

▲tokai an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How to explain FISC then?

▲tgv 40 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Ah, perfidious Albion. Charles surely is a lizard, just like his mother.

▲InsidiousWombat an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

You are completely correct, nothing more to explain. They want power because they are the government, that's only justification they need, everything else PR "ye we will totally use it against bad guys and not against guy that made govt look bad"

▲bigyabai 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'll never forget that Apple was A-okay moving their iCloud encryption keys into China: https://www.reuters.com/article/technology/apple-moves-to-st...

When it comes down to "Privacy" vs "Profit" they certainly know which side they stand on.

▲chunky1994 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Lets call a spade a spade here. They didn't weaken their e2e encryption, they moved keys (that were always accessible via U.S court order) to China for Chinese located accounts.

That's different from weakening their e2e stance or building a backdoor which they haven't done.

▲joering2 an hour ago | parent [-]

OR they could.. you know... not move their keys for Chinese-located accounts. Otherwise there is always an excuse.

▲chunky1994 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Apple is not in the business of subverting laws in the countries it operates in. If it can provide a service that does not systemically weaken their privacy and security posture they will do so.

What they did is no different from what they do in the US, again, they didn't create a backdoor, they already had access to their non-e2e encrypted services' encryption keys.

There is a reason they pulled out of offering ADP in the UK, because it would weaken their privacy and security posture. The reuters link is distinctly not that requirement.

▲rightnutwingjob an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

So Apple should simply… not comply with local law?

Then you can complain that Big Co doesn’t respect the law?

▲andai 37 minutes ago | parent [-]

"If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so."

▲AlexandrB an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Let's be real, there's no path by which Apple could deliver privacy to Chinese users. Option 1 is they comply with the Chinese government and give them iCloud keys for Chinese users. Option 2 is they refuse to comply and they're not allowed to operate in the Chinese market. Either way, Chinese users get spied on.

▲bigyabai an hour ago | parent [-]

> Option 2 is they refuse to comply and they're not allowed to operate in the Chinese market.

That's a perfectly viable option that several US companies have taken.

▲cassianoleal an hour ago | parent | next [-]

It would also mean the US Govt would lose their CLOUD Act powers over those Chinese users.

▲deaux 38 minutes ago | parent [-]

The US Govt CLOUD Act powers are meaningless over Chinese users. They're meaningful over almost all other users, but not Chinese ones.

It's very easy to see because if they were meaningful, there's zero chance Apple would still be allowed to operate in China.

▲lallysingh an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's a bit harder when you're building all your products there.

▲betterunix2 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Several of those companies have business in China anyway, and it is getting harder for companies to stay out of the Chinese market as the Chinese economy continues to grow and China continues to gain power.

▲unrented7977 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How does this prevent Chinese citizens from being spied on?

▲bigyabai an hour ago | parent [-]

Yes, since it removes an unaccountable foreign business from the market. Remember what the US did to TikTok?

▲AlexandrB an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

And did this benefit Chinese citizens in any way?

▲slopinthebag an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

so you see an article about governments trying to hide actions they took against encryption, and your first thought is how can you criticise Apple?

classic HN...

▲betterunix2 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Apple oversold encryption and should be criticized for that. The government did not take action against "encryption," it ordered Apple to do something that Apple has the ability to do despite what their marketing suggests.

▲bigyabai an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Apple is not in a position to offer trustworthy encryption. Their OS is closed source and unaccountable, and iCloud has never had an independent audit.

▲poszlem an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is a meme in Poland that I think of every time I hear about things like that:

Two panels showing the same scene. A man, seen from behind, is talking to an older official in glasses, a suit and a tie.

Top panel: The visitor asks: “You give money for yachts to your wives’ and brothers-in-law’s companies?” The official calmly answers: “Yes, so what?”

Bottom panel: The visitor asks: “Aren’t you scared someone will find out?” The official answers: “Well, you just found out. And?”

I think the big part of the problem right now is that we reached the point where those things are no longer even seen as important. Getting caught simply doesn’t cost anything.

▲ReturnoftheHack an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Good point.

▲cucumber3732842 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>I think the big part of the problem right now is that we reached the point where those things are no longer even seen as important. Getting caught simply doesn’t cost anything.

It wouldn't be a problem if there were any sort of pretend equality to it.

A datacenter goes up overnight and unopposed all while the same officials are threatening your neighbor to the tune of five figures over a goddamn deck. If the little guy got his shit rubber stamped in the same manner as the big guy the system wouldn't come off looking as bad as it does.

▲rightnutwingjob an hour ago | parent [-]

One acquaintance recently spend 5 years and $50,000 subdividing a residential block of land, with an existing dwelling at one end, just to get to the point where excavation was permitted.

A full 45% of a new the cost of a residential build in Australia is taxes and permits / approval etc.

Meanwhile, across town, a large data centre was approved well after the acquaintance submitted their initial application, and when I last checked the structural steel was going up before the excavation had commenced on the residential block.

▲augment_me an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

In neoliberalism, there is no such thing as society - Thatcher.

In a neoliberal order, you can't be assigned moral shame for doing things that are monetarily beneficial. Any kind of resource accumulation is being smart, hustling, etc. Old moral virtues have little weight or consequence there.

▲rcxdude an hour ago | parent [-]

I don't care much for Thatcher, to put it lightly, but that's not really what she meant by that quote. The full version continues that "there are individual men and women" It's meant as a reminder that putting an obligation on "society" to do something isn't some abstract thing that isn't anyone's problem: it's putting an obligation on other people.

▲rightnutwingjob an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Reminiscent of the single panel comic that has a father sitting at a table reading a newspaper.

A small child says to the father: “Dad, I’m thinking of getting in to organised crime.”

To which the father, looking over the newspaper, says to the child: “Private or public sector?”

▲joering2 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Never heard of that meme, and I only been polish for 63 years of my 63 year old life.

▲skinfaxi 37 minutes ago | parent [-]

It is likely an iteration updated for the KPO scandal. Here's the original.

https://demotywatory.pl/5100725/Zwyczajny-dzien-w-polskiej-p...

▲dmitrygr an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If the government is to be accountable to its people (hah), its actions cannot be secret as they relate to those people. The common counter-point of "so you want everyone to know the launch codes" is idiotic, of course. The government cannot have secret policies or secret capabilities when it comes to their people. This decision is the correct one, and kudos to Apple for spending their own money and time forcing it, but this should be a serious reckoning point for UK citizens. Consider what your government has TWICE fought for, and how it represents YOUR interests in NO WAY WHATSOEVER.

▲mschuster91 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's high time for the Brits to elect sane and decent politicians again.

However, it seems that this horrible, braindead backwards iteration of Labour is the best we can expect - the Tories are much worse (in fact, many of the issues the Brits have to deal with date back to Tory government time), and Reform makes even the Tories pale.

▲Ungh 24 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

There aren't any. Seriously. No one in any position to do anything about this has ever understood anything about it.

They take advice from think tanks and senior civil servants who have been bought out by people who want to sell stuff to the government. At the moment this is ID and age verification and content scanning. When their time is up in the public sector, they'll get a nice job on the board.

The security folk don't even want this because they know it'll ultimately weaken their position and the rest of the nation at the same time. But they can only be talked down to by the senior civil servants. They have no voice.

Labour, Tories, Reform, LD, all of them the same.

▲cs02rm0 44 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Loathe to give a political opinion on here, but I actually think when it comes to authoritarian overreach, Labour are the worst option we have. They've been the party pushing ID cards for decades, and it seems likely this iteration is going to get them in by the back door.

Not that I have any defence of the Tories, they're happy to go along with it all and have enabled some of this government's overreach, not least through the Online Safety Act.

▲foldr 18 minutes ago | parent [-]

>and it seems likely this iteration is going to get them in by the back door.

Does it? Andy Burnham scrapped the previous administration's plans for ID cards in July. What evidence is there that they're going to be resurrected?

▲ReturnoftheHack an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

We really have no good options.

▲cassianoleal an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The Greens are looking more appealing by the hour.

▲cs02rm0 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Absolutely not.

▲Ungh 22 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

The current incarnation of the Greens is more crazy than Reform.

▲pksebben an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Does anybody? I struggle to think of anywhere that isn't suffering from the giant douche-turd sandwich conondrum. Some marginally promising glints along the margins, perhaps, but the best of those are far from stable and the systems that have created the mess aren't even close to being changed meaningfully.

▲deaux 28 minutes ago | parent [-]

The US is definitely starting to see good options become popular. It's because it's a pendulum. To get actual promise, you first need things to get much, much worse. The problem in the other wealthy countries is that their recent governments just haven't been anywhere near as corrupt, vulturous and destructive as the current US regime. They're bad, but not nearly bad enough. And I don't see this changing, especially in mainland Europe. The AfD and RN are just inherently different, the youth in those countries are different, the societies are different. The UK actually has slightly more promise, but still not much.

▲foldr 14 minutes ago | parent [-]

This is some pretty backwards reasoning. We're doing worse in the UK because our government is better? I'm not trying to get into some kind of UK vs. US pissing match here. The US does have better protections against government surveillance than the UK. However, that's largely for democratic reasons. Brits are more trusting of their government on average than Americans, and that's reflected in the policy positions of the major political parties. There is, much as we might wish it otherwise, no silent majority of Britons waiting desperately for a candidate who's strong on digital privacy.

Also, the 'good options' in the US are becoming popular because Trump is so unpopular. It's far from clear that their major policy positions would play well in a presidential election against a strong Republican candidate. El-Sayed &co can say pretty much what they like at the moment because they're not Republicans and they're not Trump. That's not going to be the case forever.

▲varispeed an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Wouldn't be suprised that pedos connected to government would love to browse peoples private galleries. Can't find any other explanation.

Once they lost Epstein, they gone crazy about surveillance and identification of people online.