Remix.run Logo
▲ deaux a day ago

The US is definitely starting to see good options become popular. It's because it's a pendulum. To get actual promise, you first need things to get much, much worse. The problem in the other wealthy countries is that their recent governments just haven't been anywhere near as corrupt, vulturous and destructive as the current US regime. They're bad, but not nearly bad enough. And I don't see this changing, especially in mainland Europe. The AfD and RN are just inherently different, the youth in those countries are different, the societies are different. The UK actually has slightly more promise, but still not much.

▲foldr a day ago | parent [-]

This is some pretty backwards reasoning. We're doing worse in the UK because our government is better? I'm not trying to get into some kind of UK vs. US pissing match here. The US does have better protections against government surveillance than the UK. However, that's largely for democratic reasons. Brits are more trusting of their government on average than Americans, and that's reflected in the policy positions of the major political parties. There is, much as we might wish it otherwise, no silent majority of Brits waiting desperately for a candidate who's strong on digital privacy.

Also, the 'good options' in the US are becoming popular because Trump is so unpopular. It's far from clear that their major policy positions would play well in a presidential election against a strong Republican candidate. El-Sayed &co can say pretty much what they like at the moment because they're not Republicans and they're not Trump. That's not going to be the case forever.

▲deaux a day ago | parent [-]

It looks like you entirely misread me.

> Also, the 'good options' in the US are becoming popular because Trump is so unpopular

That is broadly what I was saying.

> It's far from clear that their major policy positions would play well in a presidential election against a strong Republican candidate.

There will not (or really, cannot) be a strong Republican candidate in 2028, exactly because of the current regime. That, again, is part of the point. It's like wondering, before the last UK elections, whether Starmer would do well against a strong tory opponent. This was a moot point - at that point the situation was such that it had become impossible for there to be one.

I do also disagree with the premise. Lots of research showing that their major policy positions are very widely popular in and of themselves. This isn't particularly news and has been known for years, though they have indeed become even more popular.

There's similarities with the UK here, as well as the rest of Europe. There is no party that broadly supports widely popular policies on the top five issues (as ranked by voters). In that sense, the cries of "populism" common in modern European political discourse are very ironic. If only there would be a single actually populist party! There just isn't. In much of Europe, this would be socially somewhat conservative - but nowhere near far-right - and economically what most would call socialist. There do exist far-right parties who love to claim that they support this, but their voting records show that to be a lie.

▲foldr a day ago | parent [-]

> There will not (or really, cannot) be a strong Republican candidate in 2028

A bold statement. I hope there isn’t, but the Republicans will want to win, and they may find someone in the next two years.

> Lots of research showing that their major policy positions are very widely popular in and of themselves.

That’s what people here said about Corbyn, but it doesn’t work that way. Voters often don’t like those positions in combination as advocated by a single “extreme” candidate, even if the policy positions poll well individually.

> There is no party that broadly supports widely popular policies on the top five issues (as ranked by voters).

I doubt this. What’s your basis for saying so?

▲deaux 11 hours ago | parent [-]

> That’s what people here said about Corbyn, but it doesn’t work that way. Voters often don’t like those positions in combination as advocated by a single “extreme” candidate, even if the policy positions poll well individually.

It does work that way. Corbyn was up against a very strong tory candidate. Starmer was up against an incredibly weak tory candidate. This explains almost the entirety of the gap. "Candidate" here includes "party", rather than just the person, though it's very much a combination of both.

This factor is consistently, enormously underrated in countries with effectively a two-party system such as the US and UK. It's like how a football team losing 1-0 to Arsenal, to keep with UK analogies, is a better result than beating Kettering Town 1-0. People understand this for sports, but very few recognize the exact same in politics. The politician losing that first match actually did _better_ than the second politician who won. Outside of people very deep into politics, this is barely ever recognized.

Another thing is that policy is very separate from image. The exact same policies can gain or lose votes depending on how they're conveyed, the messaging, and the image cultivated by the politician in question.

> I doubt this. What’s your basis for saying so?

Genuinely tons of research, this is not controversial. If you need some queries, "political surveys policy voter importance", "political surveys policy popularity", "political parties spectrum chart". Add the name of the country you're interested in. As I said I primarily meant Europe including the UK, but it applies to many other countries too.

▲foldr 10 hours ago | parent [-]

Theresa May was a very strong candidate? You must be joking.

>Genuinely tons of research, this is not controversial

I did google the kind of thing you suggested, but didn't find support for your specific claim.