Remix.run Logo
▲ groos a day ago

I fail to see the economic case. You will need very large solar arrays and radiation hardened components, both of which make it uneconomical compared to a data center on Earth. This is another of Musk's genius ideas like the tunnels that were supposed to be carrying us under cities by now.

▲vlovich123 a day ago | parent | next [-]

The problem is that experiments into this by Google have concluded that radiation hardening is unnecessary. HBM memory far surpassed their expectations for survival, exceeding 5 years in their simulated proton beam on earth. Localized shielding for consumer equipment is more than enough, especially combined with ECC.

Solar power and power dissipation are similarly solvable. The only bottleneck currently is launch costs which is why it’s expected around 2030 is when these DCs will explode

▲gf000 a day ago | parent [-]

> Solar power and power dissipation are similarly solvable

So it is not outright stupid, just has a few extra costs.

So again, what's the economical benefit? Because you surely have no power and dissipation problem down on Earth, so why add a whole rocket launch into the equation? Because big fire goes brr?

▲vlovich123 a day ago | parent [-]

Because data centers take a long time to get through local regulations. By comparison launching a bunch of satellites into orbit is much simpler and you don’t get local political opposition you have to spend a lot of resources trying to overcome (not to mention secondary cost effects of needing a lot more staff to manage all the diffuse lobbying that needs to happen). Any political opposition to space DCs is going to be more diffuse and disparate since any problems are non local. There’s also that cooling is logistically easier in space and thus cheaper as it’s a small amount of mass vs the huge cooling towers since they’re cooling a rack directly instead of needing to cool the entire DC.

So what’s the economic benefit? As Suncatcher has predicted, the economic cost benefit flips to space DCs at a certain launch price/kg which is expected to be reached commercially by early to mid 2030s (spacex will be ahead because they don’t need profitable launches and can get ahead).

▲gf000 15 hours ago | parent [-]

We surely don't expect the same total computation throughput from one data center and a couple of satellites, right?

Like even if a single satellite launch is cheaper than.. building a whole building, I have a really hard time believing that putting that many satellites up would still be cheaper.

And even that hypothetical depends on that we need some very quickly growing need for compute, which somehow can't be managed by.. simply replacing the existing compute hardware every 5 years in data centers, and the relative slow build of new ones?

▲vlovich123 10 hours ago | parent [-]

Space is big. We’re not talking about a couple of satellites eithers. It’s probably many tens of satellites in close proximity. Enough to host a single LLM model for example. Then you put up enough of these micro DCs. There’s simply no need for a single constellation with thousands of racks like a terrestrial warehouse. The only reason you do it that way today is purely because that’s how permitting and construction makes sense on earth, not because there’s some inherent advantage.

▲gf000 9 hours ago | parent [-]

You can surely just put a single rack into every 10th office building in a city of your choice for faster connections, significantly larger compute per rack, and significantly cheaper price.

What's the point of going to space besides a scammer wanting his share price up?

And before you say "politics" and "legal", space is just not that regulated because there was no need for it. Why do you think it will not get regulated once "per kg transport" becomes cheap enough? How is the politics and legal all that bad for the data center case? Like maybe don't build it into stupid places harming the environment, but it's not that bad of a thing all together, no reason why they couldn't be built under normal circumstances.

▲vlovich123 8 hours ago | parent [-]

I imagine the cooling and power challenges of that is what inhibits this idea. But if it were economical, why don’t you try building a startup around it and find out? It’s easy to argue from the couch, much harder to actually validate your ideas against reality

▲postalrat a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'd imagine sometime in the future we will build processing wafers similar to monocrystalline solar panels. Data processed sequentially over a couple dozen feet. AI models hard coded into the silicon itself. The entire data center maybe a milimeter thick sheet.

▲drum55 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's difficult to imagine any sort of compute in space given the state of the art rad hardened processor is about as fast as a computer Apple sold in 1998.

▲emtel a day ago | parent [-]

You don’t have to imagine. The starlink constellation is a working and profitable massive deployment of orbital compute. (It doesn’t use rad hardened hardware as far as I can tell)

▲za_creature a day ago | parent | next [-]

Starlink is impressive but calling it compute is a stretch.

It's not that far off from a residential router with a bigger antenna.

▲kibwen a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Starlink satellites have such a low orbit that they experience non-negligible atmospheric drag, which is why they have to be replaced at such a rapid rate. All proposals for orbital datacenters propose placing them in sun-synchronous orbits for maximum solar exposure, which puts them right at the edge of the Van Allen Belt at best, meaning they'd be exposed to dramatically more radiation than a Starlink satellite.

▲pfdietz a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The PV at least can potentially be much less robust than on Earth, since it doesn't have to contend with wind and weather. CdTe thin films, for example, can be just 1 micron thick (the absorption length of solar photons in that material is ~0.1 microns). So potentially the material cost of space PV can be much less than the same peak power PV on Earth.

▲K3UL a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The bet that they are making is that, in the near-future, energy on Earth will be such an issue (especially if you want to scale) that DCs on Earth will cost more than components + launch costs

▲gf000 a day ago | parent [-]

Why would energy be an issue? The Sun is shining, wind is blowing, the ocean has waves, nuclear is nuclear. All of these will just get more efficient in using the same constant resource.

▲FireBeyond a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Musk's "genius idea" there was to (pardon the pun) derail high speed rail and other similar investments so he could sell more cars.

What are Hyperloop/Boring actually doing now? It doesn't take that much investment to human-drive a 10-20 Teslas up and down the Vegas Strip in a straight tunnel at normal speeds.