Remix.run Logo
▲ throwitaway222 a day ago

This works better than all of the hepa purifiers on the market:

  1 20" box fan.
  4 20" mirv 13 filters (cheapest is likely costco or lowes or home depot - buy in a 4 pack to save money).
This is still expensive but the amount of air processing per hour is incredible.

More info Search "Corsi-Rosenthal Box" or click https://filterbuy.com/resources/air-filter-basics/how-to-bui...

Don't go hepa because it slows down the filtering too much. I use this technique in my house and it cuts down on pollen, smoke and mold. You'll feel a lot better than a tiny expensive hepa that has proprietary filters.

▲instaclay a day ago | parent | next [-]

True, but the MacGyver looking thing in the middle (or side,whatever) of your living room doesn't sit right with everyone. People pay money for aesthetics and take the hit on efficiency.

I'm seeing some 3d printed projects popping up that look to be filling this gap though.

▲rcoveson 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

All you need for aesthetics is to put the whole thing in any nice-looking piece of box-shaped furniture with some kind of breathable, obscuring fabric, grille, or louvre on two sides (or even just one side, if you're okay with an open back).

Find a free-standing cabinet at the thrift store or something. Will look way nicer than any minimalist-modern plastic thing from Temu (or anything 3D printed, not that I have anything against 3D printers in general).

▲cheeze 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm laughing at the comparison of that beautiful coway filter in the article and... a box fan duct taped to a furnace filter.

It's a cool hack, it doesn't pass the wife test.

▲wallst07 19 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm guessing there are a lot of single folks on this site and would wonder the opposite... if you've never been married you think of things WAY different.

▲AnthonBerg a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Filtering out the fines and ultrafines – the stuff that HEPA filters capture – makes a biiiiiiig difference in air quality.

A smaller supplementary unit made out of PC fans and N95s can do that. A 120mm Noctua fan's flow and pressure fits well for about three 3M Aura masks in parallel.

It's unhinged how good the air quality is in a room with a device like this.

▲Diederich a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We've been doing the $9 Amazon Basics fan with a good filter since wildfire smoke started really getting bad in the bay area, quite a few years ago now. We had a couple of big, expensive filter tower things, and they helped, but just a couple of the boxfans with filters duct taped on quickly and consistently annihilated PM2.5 and PM10 in our apartments.

Most surprising thing: all but one of those original Amazon fans is still running. They've had years of run time, at quite a bit higher stress than normal.

▲frakkingcylons a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I agree on principle. There are iterations on this concept that are much quieter, are visually more palatable, and still have high airflow.

Example: https://www.cleanairkits.com/products/luggable-ultra-air-pur...

▲Cthulhu_ a day ago | parent [-]

But that one costs $400, for that money you can buy a commercial / professional / design filter too. The Corsi-Rosenthal one is <$100.

If volume is a problem, I'm sure one can lower the fan speed below the lowest setting with some electronics knowledge.

▲frakkingcylons 5 hours ago | parent [-]

It's $230 with just the parts. Filters will cost about $40 for two. So like $270 and it's much quieter than commercial purifiers at a higher CFM.

▲vikramkr a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That rules! Looks like you can do it with like 3 filters so it's more triangle shaped which makes sense. That's so stupidly simple too. Also aesthetically pretty cool - would look great in a workshop where it's like function first/don't hide the mechanism. And I feel like there's gotta be clever ways to incorporate something as simple as "box fan but the box is made of air filter" into like a coffee table or stand or something else clever? Probably you'd want to hide the filters inside if they look grimy before you actually need to replace them so you don't feel obligated to waste money by replacing too soon but sounds like a fun time to figure out how to integrate that in a hidden way into whatever's your vibe without looking jank

▲xgulfie a day ago | parent [-]

You can also do it with 2 or 1

▲snk a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

In my bachelor days I put an air filter behind a box fan; women have higher aesthetic standards. mirv 8 works fine for me and I can pick them up grocery shopping, but my primary contaminant is a sheprador.

▲jedberg a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

My brother in law did this. It is boxy and ugly, but damn does it work.

▲CGMthrowaway a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What is the advantage of this over just sticking a merv13 in your HVAC and running the fan for 15minutes every hour? (assuming it's rated for merv13)

▲rainbowzootsuit 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

One issue beyond the flow rate others have noted is that if the fan doesn't cycle with the evaporator coil when in cooling conditions the wet coil will re-evaporate the water that is on it which will give higher humidity in the space. This is a climate and season dependent issue.

▲sailfast a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For me, it just doesn’t remove the particulates fast enough when they’re quite dense outside or the house is porous.

Better sealed homes might have better luck - it should work ok - but the best way to breathe filtered air quickly is to stick your head right above a filter.

▲schiffern 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Typical flow rates for HVAC systems are ~1 air change per hour, but to effectively filter the air faster than the dirty air leaks in, you need about 5 air changes per hour (AHAM recommendation).

If using the HVAC, run the fan continuously, and ideally use the 1" 3M 1900 filter. Other brands or models (including the supposedly 'better' 4" 3M 1900 filters) have fewer pleats, which works out to smaller surface area and worse airflow resistance. Check BJs website, usually they're $10/filter in a 4-pack.

Typically these need replacement every 3 months. The only way to really mess it up (and possibly break your HVAC system) is to completely forget to replace the filters, so I try to set redundant phone alerts with different family members.

▲gojomo a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You can drop a boxfan-filter combo anywhere, even where there's no forced-air HVAC.

▲xgulfie a day ago | parent | prev [-]

A box fan in a room will usually give you more air changes than typical HVAC

▲schiffern a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Better instructions without FilterBuy: https://cleanaircrew.org/box-fan-filters/

FilterBuy 'MERV 13' tested at MERV 7: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FKAVEek1YaSQ

TL;DR Filtrete 1900 performs best: https://www.bjs.com/product/filtrete-20-x-25-x-1-premium-all...

Also MIRV = Multiple Independently-targetable Reentry Vehicles, MERV = Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value. :)

DIY clean air is an awesome hack! Cheers

▲dcrazy a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I’m not dedicating 1600 cubic inches of my living space to an ugly homemade piece of furniture that I have to rebuild whenever I change a HEPA filter. I suspect I am not alone in this.

▲paper2d 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is exactly what I have done, but with 12" fans instead. It works exceptionally well and you are not locked into any ecosystem. For aesthetics, as everyone is crying about it, maybe one can 3D print a case for it.

▲gojomo a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I was wondering when one of the low-end 20" box fan vendors would add a slot for a 20"x20" filter... and it turns out Lasko finally did, creating an "AirFlex 2-in-1" product that's often knocked for price/noise but resolves the homemade look, for those that care.

▲conk a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Everyone wants the sound of a box fan and the looks of duct taped cardboard sitting in their living room...

▲philip-b a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I would build one but I live in Argentina and I have no idea where to get any of the components.

▲sushid a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I never get this take. Yes, you'd make this in a pinch but that thing is hideous to have around the house.

It's like telling someone they bought a car and pointing out that golf dimples with increase your mileage. No reasonable adult would have that thing in the middle of their living room!

▲joquarky a day ago | parent [-]

I'll never understand how someone can care more about aesthetics than their health.

▲MSKJ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Just replace the HVAC filter and run the fan

▲Whatarethese a day ago | parent | prev [-]

You can take it with you when your wife kicks you out of the house for making something so stupidly ugly even if its functional.