Remix.run Logo
▲ binaryturtle an hour ago

I don't see any advantage of any of the new formats over the good old and proven formats, so I stick with PNG and JPEG (properly optimized.) I can fire up any old browser and it will just work.

▲ezfe an hour ago | parent | next [-]

JXL has clear advantages and saying you don't see them means you either didn't attempt to see them or willfully ignore them

▲smaudet an hour ago | parent [-]

I'm not sure if the parent comment means to say, but I could choose to interpret their meaning to be:

PNG/JPEG have strong support (nearly everywhere). I think of them almost as the modern TIFF - relatively simple, and almost everything supports one or both of them (few to no issues).

JXL may eventually get there (that indeed seems to be its goal), but for now I wouldn't drop e.g. PNG or JPEG support in favor of JXL now.

And arguably, perhaps never drop support; its such a prevalent format, even if all software (prevalent or otherwise) supports the format in 10 years, there will be such a huge stockpile of JPEG/PNG that something will need to be used to read/convert.

▲spider-mario an hour ago | parent [-]

> I think of them almost as the modern TIFF - relatively simple

TIFF is not simple at all. There is a joke that it stands for “Thousands of Incompatible File Formats”.

▲VanTheBrand 35 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

JPEGXL literally is able to display images and colors that jpeg and png cannot (32-but floating point, layers, emission independent transparency, spot colors, built im depth maps). It’s not just about compression optimization. So for those use cases standard JPEG and PNG alone will never work. There are “updated” versions of JPEG that support some of these like HDR but those won’t work with any old browser either so back to the same issue.

▲Mistletoe 3 minutes ago | parent [-]

Can the human eye even tell the difference? This feels like 8k vs 4k tv.

▲asddubs 25 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

biggest advantage for me is file size and lossless conversion of existing jpg images. In a network scenario that can meaningfully impact load times. Others will care about e.g. bit depth

▲RobotToaster an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

JXL supports extra channels for multispectral images.

▲copperx an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

You should add that line to your resume.

▲groundzeros2015 an hour ago | parent [-]

I’d hire him.