Remix.run Logo
preisschild a day ago

And what if those "cloud based office tools", which would be using proprietary file formats internally, shut down? Or heck, what if they announce to raise their pricing? All of your docs gone. No possibility to migrate.

est a day ago | parent [-]

Hmm, I believe there're many open-source self-hostable office solutions.

And they don't share a universal format.

AnthonyMouse a day ago | parent | next [-]

When the original application is open source, its format is public and anyone who wants to create a converter to another format can either use the original code or inspect it to see how the format works.

When the format is proprietary, you get a blob of binary data that you have to reverse engineer through guesswork, made orders of magnitude more difficult if the original service isn't even available anymore.

est a day ago | parent [-]

The problem reminds me of pdf, the format is well known, there are tons of third-party readers, but they all glitch somewhat differently.

Also PDF is turing complete.

Modern rich content formats are hard. Open formats solves only small part of the problem.

I think the universal interchangable format is static HTML.

AnthonyMouse a day ago | parent [-]

PDF is a mess because it's an ancient originally-proprietary format based on a proprietary language and the Adobe "standard" didn't actually specify a lot of important things for a long time, leaving other implementations to try to reverse engineer them.

Meanwhile you look at actual standard formats like PNG or UTF-8 or, as you say, HTML, and the implementations generally do a lot better because there is a proper spec.

preisschild a day ago | parent | prev [-]

The Collabora Online Suite for example just uses the OpenDocument formats