Remix.run Logo
sublinear 3 hours ago

Most people don't eat enough fiber, eat way too much processed junk, and have vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Yet still the overall risk for colon cancer is surprisingly low and takes a long time to develop for everyone but the unluckiest.

Earlier screenings are just compensating for poor education. It's not a solution to anything but the question of how to raise insurance costs for young people.

Just eat your damn vegetables!

butILoveLife 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

After a ton of research, I think the generic suggestion 'Fiber' is not helpful.

Some things to consider:

>There are classifications of fiber, insoluable vs soluable

>Even those classifications are overly generalized, and can/should be broken down into basically individual foods.

>Fiber and the various types have impact on your gut bacteria. If your gut bacteria is bad, you might be fueling growth of bad bacteria.

>You don't actually need fiber

>You don't actually need a colon

>I think gut bacteria management will probably be the next big thing. A combination of more scientific probiotics + fiber/prebiotics.

>I'm guessing the colon cancer thing is probably due to pollutants. Not necessarily air, but could be from food.

hombre_fatal 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

"Fiber from food" seems good enough. It's hard not to fibermax without incidentally improving your diet substantially. For example, beans are one of the best and easiest sources of it.

Splitting hairs beyond that, like insoluble and soluble, is the kind of thing that just confuses and intimidates people about nutrition advice.

It's a bridge you can cross once everyone is eating 50g+ of fiber per day, has chiseled physiques, and are looking to min/max.

butILoveLife 43 minutes ago | parent [-]

This is hubris. I actually think I got my first colon issue because I ate too many beans.

cindyllm 40 minutes ago | parent [-]

[dead]

h4kr1 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>I'm guessing the colon cancer thing is probably due to pollutants

> You don't actually need fiber

Hey, you know what fiber is good for? Speeding up gut motility! You know what a faster gut motility is good for! Getting toxins out of our body quicker!

butILoveLife 43 minutes ago | parent [-]

In that case, wouldn't you want to include things like sorbitol?

I want to emphasize I'm not making any grand claims of advice. I'm more being skeptical of traditional advice as someone who had/has a colon issue and tried everything under the sun.

appplication 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Of the three people I personally knew who died of colon cancer in their 30s, all were athletes or vegans. I'm not saying that caused it, but I do think it is potentially more complex than just fiber.

Qem 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Just eat your damn vegetables!

At least if you can find some not previously doused in poison.