Remix.run Logo
lukan 4 hours ago

"The AI companies have now unleashed stochastic chaos on the entire open source ecosystem."

They do have their responsibility. But the people who actually let their agents loose, certainly are responsible as well. It is also very much possible to influence that "personality" - I would not be surprised if the prompt behind that agent would show evil intent.

idle_zealot 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

As with everything, both parties are to blame, but responsibility scales with power. Should we punish people who carelessly set bots up which end up doing damage? Of course. Don't let that distract from the major parties at fault though. They will try to deflect all blame onto their users. They will make meaningless pledges to improve "safety".

How do we hold AI companies responsible? Probably lawsuits. As of now, I estimate that most courts would not buy their excuses. Of course, their punishments would just be fines they can afford to pay and continue operating as before, if history is anything to go by.

I have no idea how to actually stop the harm. I don't even know what I want to see happen, ultimately, with these tools. People will use them irresponsibly, constantly, if they exist. Totally banning public access to a technology sounds terrible, though.

I'm firmly of the stance that a computer is an extension of its user, a part of their mind, in essence. As such I don't support any laws regarding what sort of software you're allowed to run.

Services are another thing entirely, though. I guess an acceptable solution, for now at least, would be barring AI companies from offering services that can easily be misused? If they want to package their models into tools they sell access to, that's fine, but open-ended endpoints clearly lend themselves to unacceptable levels of abuse, and a safety watchdog isn't going to fix that.

This compromise falls apart once local models are powerful enough to be dangerous, though.

co_king_3 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm not interested in blaming the script kiddies.

lispisok 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

When skiddies use other people's scripts to pop some outdated wordpress install they are absolutely are responsible for their actions. Same applies here.

girvo 25 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I am. Though I'm also more than happy to pass blame around for all involved, not just them.

hnuser123456 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Those are people who are new to programming. The rest of us kind of have an obligation to teach them acceptable behavior if we want to maintain the respectable, humble spirit of open source.

co_king_3 4 hours ago | parent [-]

[flagged]