Remix.run Logo
holoduke 3 hours ago

For an experiment i created multiple agents that reviewed pull requests from other people in various teams. I never saw so many frustrated reactions and angry people. Some refused to do any further reviews. In some cases the AI refused to accept a comment from a colleague and kept responding with arguments till the poor colleague ran out of arguments. AI even responded with fu tongue smiles. Interesting too see nevertheless. Failed experiment? Maybe. But the train cannot be stopped I think.

teiferer 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> till the poor colleague ran out of arguments

I hope your colleague was agreeing to partake in this experiment. Not even to mention management.

pjc50 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I never saw so many frustrated reactions and angry people.

> But the train cannot be stopped I think.

An angry enough mob can derail any train.

This seems like yet another bit of SV culture where someone goes "hey, if I press 'defect' in the prisoner's dilemma I get more money, I should tell everyone to use this cool life hack", without realizing the consequenses.

grosswait 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I think the prisoner’s dilemma analogy is apt, but I also concur with OP that this train will not be stopped. Hopefully I’ll live long enough to see the upside.

otikik 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Did you at least apologize?

RuggedPineapple 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The train is already derailing. The thing that no AI evangelists ever acknowledge is that the field has not solved its original questions. Minsky's work on neural networks is still relevant more then half a century later. What this looks like from the ground is that exponential growth of computing power fuels only linear growth of AI. That makes resources and costs spiral out incredibly fast. You can see that in the costs: every AI player out there has a 200 plus dollar tier and still loses money. That linear growth is why every couple decades theres a hype cycle as society checks back in to see how its going and is impressed by the gains, but that sustain just cant last because it can't keep up with the expected growth in capabilities.

Growth at a level it can't sustain and can't be backed by actual jumps in capabilities has a name: A bubble. What's coming is dot-com crash 2.0