I'm not nervous, I just don't see the utility. Perhaps you can elucidate this for me.

Espressosaurus 8 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You're communicating ideas across unknown thousands of miles with a stranger in near realtime and are able to comprehend each other, for one.

No cat or dog has managed that feat yet.

No cat or dog has managed to reproduce fire to the degree that evolution has changed their gut to adapt to the increase in available calories.

The big brain comes with down sides, but one thing it does have is utility.

Germ theory of disease has made it so a scratch isn't fatal anymore. Why, after all, do cats play with their prey? To tire it out so there's less chance of injury when they go in for the kill.

We just figure out how to farm it instead and mold it to our needs.

▲

MangoToupe 5 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't disagree with any of this, but what is the utility of viewing this ability as "more advanced"?

▲

throwaway2562 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

What is the utility of denying it?

What do you or anyone else actually get from such obvious absurdity, I wonder?

If it helps - and I have doubts - does (say) a working knowledge of Galois theory require more advanced mathematical cognition than arithmetic?

Would it be immoral to introduce such ghastly, hierarchical language? Etc.

I see you ignored the obvious rejoinder downthread, which stated that the utility of classifying behaviours or capacities is to help you predict outcomes.

How much more help do you need here? It’s not very complicated, but you prefer to showboat.

▲

munificent 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Let's say you're about to embark on a cross-oceanic sailing voyage. For safety reasons, you think it's best to bring another living being with you who can help if things go south or you are incapacitated.

Are you going to bring another human, or a goat? Can a goat navigate while you sleep? Can it apply first aid to you? Can it respond on the VHF radio if you get hailed? Can it operate the bilge pump?

▲

MangoToupe 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Embarking on a cross-oceanic sailing voyage seems to be a particularly human brand of tomfoolery. Why not just stay at home with the goat?

	▲	munificent an hour ago \| parent [-]
		I honestly can't tell if you think you're being funny, deep, or just trolling.

▲

antisthenes 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> I don't disagree with any of this, but what is the utility of viewing this ability as "more advanced"?

Because that's the most accurate description of what it is. The more accurately you describe something, the more effectively you communicate, an aspect of more advanced cognition.

▲

aoeusnth1 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The utility is that it's predictive of future observations, like all good language.

▲

goatlover 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Tool use allowed humans to colonize the planet and outcompete all rivals. We became a super predator species. We even gained the ability to look beyond our home. We look for evidence of other such advanced tool users in space.