As someone who migrated from macports to Homebrew, I'd like to see a third option (or maybe re-investigate macports again to see what's changed recently).

Homebrew's insistence on leaving OSes behind that they deem to be "too old" is becoming a problem as the years click by. One of the reasons to use third party software and a third party package manager is to avoid Apple's own insistence on abandoning old OSes. Homebrew following their example is very disappointing.

EDIT: From the linked issue:

    "Intel support is coming to an end from both Apple and Homebrew."

I actually migrated from Homebrew to Macports after ending up in dependency hell in Homebrew with Postgresql + Postgis, and not being able to fix this properly even with my own brew recipes.

So for now that works a lot better in Macports. The portfile stuff needed some digging to understand, but that's doable.

Not sure what made you move from Macports to Homebrew. (Should I worry?)

"Homebrew's insistence on leaving OSes behind that they deem to be "too old" is becoming a problem as the years click by"

Indeed! I have a VERY usable Macbook Pro from 2015. Even with the newest version supported macOS version (11) Big Sur (which is still quite modern) it doesn't have any binaries for apps, which means it has to compile every single app and dependency.

I managed to update to macOS 14 (with the help of OpenCore Legacy Patcher).

But this just buys me one year to use Homebrew. Next year they will retire macOS 14.

And my machine is still very usable, but it will become junk from a developer perspective unless I have homebrew (or something similar).

It annoys me because I think this problem is fixable. Either community repos or more donations to homebrew to compile apps for older macs.

> I'd like to see a third option

Nix, perhaps?

Honestly conda does a lot of heavy lifting for me. I know people have strong feelings about it on here but it works great for my purposes.