Remix.run Logo
▲ Animats an hour ago

Attempts at governance are futile until we recognize that we have built a machine and set it on its course. Instead, we pretend that the market is a natural phenomenon best left alone, and we fail to hold its mechanism designers to account. We need to tear down and rebuild that machine, reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.

This article has useful insights. It points out that capitalism is an optimization engine for something. Shareholder value and CEO compensation, mostly. It reminds us of something that many people would prefer be forgotten - capitalism operates under rules set by governments, and those shape the market. Tax law matters - what's deductible warps spending patterns. Bankruptcy law matters - who gets left holding the bag? Corporation law matters - how immune are executives from the consequences of their decisions? Labor law matters - do people go to jail for wage and hour law violations?

All of those are changeable by legislation. Most have become much more favorable to companies since 1970. That's not necessarily permanent. We had a New Deal in the 1930s, following the Gilded Age of the 1920s and the crash of 1929.

▲hn_throwaway_99 8 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

There is a popular health blogger, Dr. Jessica Knurick, who makes similar arguments regarding the generally very poor health outcomes in the US, and I think her arguments are very persuasive. That is, our poor health outcomes are the logical consequence (not some anomaly) of a system that is designed to prioritize corporate profits over all other considerations.

The thing I find most convincing about these arguments is that I often hear many "free market boosters" say that any intervention in markets is a foolhardy idea, and that individuals are best equipped to make their own decisions. But IMO this is a BS argument because it pretends that we don't already have tons of rules built into the system that prioritize specific values and outcomes (e.g. how corporate formation often protects individuals from some disastrous consequences of their decisions).

I think that's the most important idea in these discussions: we do not live in some "default" state of fair, open competition. The system we built is a consequence of the rules we laid down to bring it into creation, and we can change those rules if we decide the current outcome is not what we desire.

▲LPisGood 33 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don’t think capitalism is an optimization machine for CEO compensation. I think it is just for shareholder value; if shareholders thought they could pay a CEO less they would in a heartbeat.

▲ZnerflBerp 27 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

But the principal agent problem between shareholders and CEO is substantial.

▲thaumasiotes 10 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> I don’t think capitalism is an optimization machine for CEO compensation. I think it is just for shareholder value

When you say "capitalism", what do you mean? How would you determine whether any given phenomenon was or wasn't "capitalism"?

▲baggy_trough 38 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

The market starts as a natural phenomenon of voluntary trade. Various usually counterproductive strictures are then layered on top.

▲ElevenLathe 13 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Counterproductive doesn't mean worthless. Better distribution of fewer resources is, at a certain point, desirable contra massive inequality with higher overall wealth. Regulation can also create wealth, it's not impossible. There's no natural law that requires unregulated barter to be even a local optimum.

▲phreeza 29 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

"Voluntary trade" is just kicking the can down the road imo, it doesn't exist without some sort of rules being enforced around it.

▲unrented7977 16 minutes ago | parent [-]

Markets arise naturally from barter systems.

▲fleischhauf 11 minutes ago | parent [-]

there is no natural barter system, it used to be a system of given each other favors, the market was a later invention

▲thisoneisreal 10 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Fraud and lemon law strictures aren't counterproductive. The FDA isn't counterproductive. "Voluntary trade" reminds me of the idea that "all natural" products are inherently good. Nature (and other people) will commonly engage in toxic, exploitative behavior without intervention.

▲tmoertel 33 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The market is a natural phenomenon of voluntary trade.

But the market requires oversight to ensure that you have meaningful choices. Otherwise, monopolies and corruption will work to remove your preferred options, forcing you to pay rents.

▲matthest 3 minutes ago | parent [-]

Depends on how low the barriers of competition are. Restaurants have been capitalist markets for hundreds of years and have never devolved into monopolies, even though they exist under relatively little oversight. Because the level of competition is so high.

This is also true of a wide variety of small businesses.

More often than we think, monopolies arise out of well-meaning legislation that ends up restricting competition, resulting in oligopoly/monopoly

▲ 33 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]