Remix.run Logo
▲ walt_grata 2 hours ago

Can you show me where the general citizens have the same degree of oversight and can impact the board or c suite that they have over elected officials? If you can demonstrate that I'll hop on that they're the same.

▲delichon an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Personally I feel entirely powerless to exercise oversight on either. I believe that no vote I have every made has made any difference. From down here they do look very much alike.

▲myersj 35 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Why do you think your oversight rests on your vote alone, and not that you, as an individual, have the power and ability to run for office, campaign on behalf of those running, or participate in any vague way in local elections that typically actually affect your life in meaningful ways and generally come down to a few hundred votes, which you could influence, if you cared at all?

I'm so tired of this "I'm powerless because I don't get to personally pick the President" crap. It's defeatist, childish nonsense.

▲viklove an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

The problem is your perception, not democracy.

▲wpietri an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Agreed. The US has just gone though an election that served as a major rebuke to the party in power. It's such a dramatic swing that the world's richest man suddenly changed his tune.

Or we could look at Hungary, which in April booted out a 16-year authoritarian regime again due to elections. And there are plenty of other examples.

I get that many people don't feel individually powerful under democracy. But that's pretty close to the point of democracy.

▲lioeters an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

The problem is reality and facts, not the illusion of choice.

▲HeatrayEnjoyer an hour ago | parent [-]

The 2026 midterm election results are not an illusion.

Defeatism isn't a plan, but sometimes is a subversive weapon.

▲brightball an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes. It’s called voting with your wallet.

When you disapprove of a corporation, you stop spending money with them and go to a competitor.

You have no such choice with government. Regulations tend to be marketed with good intentions while simply raising the cost for competitors to enter the market, further reducing your options and entrenching the existing companies.

▲JDups 38 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Corporations will lie as much as they can to hide anything consumers might not like. With no regulation or treat of legal action then they'd just be incentivized to make voting with your wallet even harder than it currently is.

And the reality is that products and services you buy have so many contributions from different corporations at all levels of their production, it's impossible to be a truly informed buyer. Say buy some random knick-knack from walmart, do you know if the plastic was produced by a company that treats it workers ethically? Does that company get it's products from a refinery that poisons the community it was built in? Does that refinery purchase oil from a company that paid off militias to get the land it's extracting the oil from?

▲_petronius an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Governments collapse all the time because legitimacy is withdrawn by the electorate (from recent history alone: Arab Spring in various countries 2010-2012, Ukraine 2013/14, Bangladesh 2024, South Korea 2025, Nepal 2025, Serbia 2026, etc. etc.).

Corporations usually collapse only due to insolvency, and these are basically never driven by "voting with the wallet" -- the very concept is something of a fallacy, because it assumes the primary financial concern of a large global company is revenue from individual consumers, which is largely not true.

Believing that electoral politics is ineffective but corporate are somehow accountable to regular consumers is to understand the political forces exactly backwards from what they are in reality.

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲HeatrayEnjoyer an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Votes should be proportioned by individual, not by wealth.

▲thayne an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

With a monopoly or oligopoly, you don't have a choice of who you can "vote" for with your wallet. It's like a "democracy" with only one name on the ballet.

▲pepperoni_pizza an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The problem with voting with your wallet is that some people have few votes, and some have few billion votes.

▲karmakurtisaani an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

So how do I influence a tobacco company when I don't smoke?

If I disagree with a political party, I can always vote a party that does opposite policy.

▲Avicebron an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> Yes. It’s called voting with your wallet.

And when your bank doesn't let you download their app because you aren't on a android or iphone? Voting with your wallet is a fun zinger, but in practice it's not really a solution. That's why people have said for decades (centuries?) that laissez-faire capitalism is bad.

▲r7000 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What were the most powerful corporations 10, 20, 30 or 40 years ago?

What states had power and a monopoly on violence?

Which ones changed?

▲myersj 32 minutes ago | parent [-]

Is your argument that because Standard Oil isn't important anymore, corporations are good, or that because the United States exists as a nation, governments are bad? Or do you think Ronald Reagan is also still President, and that the state of Texas (or whatever) still has the same government, that obviously government doesn't change on significantly shorter timescales than most companies go out of business?

▲inshard an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Public shares.

▲Avicebron an hour ago | parent | next [-]

What percentage of a company should a government own to force them to act them in the best interest of the people?

▲pasquinelli an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

people own shares to make money, they are citizens out of a need to live.

▲BobBagwill an hour ago | parent [-]

I invested all my retirement savings in Soylent Green. They even sent me a free invitation to the Thanatorium as a thank you!