Remix.run Logo
▲ Show HN: The Riemann Proof Handbook(github.com)
51 points by tamnd 5 hours ago | 19 comments
▲tito 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I built a tool so anyone can run the Riemann proof on their spare CPU cycles.

And there's a global leaderboard too (6 people running it now). Graphics inspired by SETI@home

https://riemann-at-home.github.io/riemann-at-home/

I’m here for all the tools to understand this Riemann Hypothesis breakthrough!

▲brandonpelfrey 20 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This feels like it has nowhere near enough massaging of the writing style, it’s as if they just told Claude to write a book and used defaults. You absolutely must tell models to speak in certain ways, use guidance to reduce Claudisms, and run adversarial review with other separate models that take a viewpoint of a uniformed reader. That is the only way to start getting semi-reasonable writing for something like this.

▲henearkr 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I thought that the Lean project for the RH had been built and checked already several times with different kernels?

▲QuesnayJr an hour ago | parent [-]

They have.

▲irnbrudrinker 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Has anyone scanned through and found any unknown insights Claude might have used? Or is the whole thing just stuff we could already do but was past the scale of a human's ability to do so?

▲QuesnayJr an hour ago | parent [-]

From what I can tell, yes, there are new insights. The proof goes by a route that nobody had seriously considered. It's a fundamentally new proof technique, and may open up new frontiers. At the same time, it relies on a lot of existing math from the last 100 years, so it's not like humans accomplished nothing of relevance in that time.

▲reader9274 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't think any one person would have been able to link so many areas of math to come up with this proof in the ai-form. Masullo's proof is definitely more digestible and human-plausible.

▲rustyhancock 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Something similar was said about Andrew Wiles FLT proof - i.e. that it was stunning a single person that traversed such vast mathematical territory.

Over the past 30 years (apparently I can't testify to this personally) it's much slicker but for the most part it is still covers mostly the same range of vast mathematics.

I do wonder if eventually someone will simplify it somewhat.

Apparently, if the ABC conjecture is true FLT becomes a one pager proof.

But the only "proof" we have for ABC is basically illegable with months of work and those who have taken the effort to try do not believe it to be correct.

To attack this disagreement apparently the majority of the current effort is on using AI to translate it to familiar mathematics arguments and lean to verify.

It feels romantic to say maybe the proof is correct but we're stuck between complex maths arguments people understand or alien seeming maths only one guy seems to understand.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2522687-the-secret-proj...

▲throwaway81523 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I saw something about that pretty recently. The formalization effort hit a snag in the exact same place that Scholze and Stix did when they tried to review the ABC paper by hand. Unless a fix is forthcoming, things are as they were.

▲geordiew 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

< apparently...

I believe this is true for asymptotic FLT (ie FLT for large enough n) and Mordell but not the full FLT.

▲eru 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Alas, it's also incomplete, and perhaps even 'wrong'.

▲varjag 2 hours ago | parent [-]

There's no source for that other than few randos' Claude sessions.

▲eru an hour ago | parent [-]

The 'incomplete' is from the author himself.

▲bananaflag 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> in PDF and EPUB

Okay, so there should be prominent links to the PDF and EPUB.

▲alex-moon 2 hours ago | parent [-]

At the very top of the README.md it makes it clear that the PDFs and ePUBs can be downloaded from the release artifacts, which view is linked directly. My humble opinion is that this is the most correct or at least standard way to do this on GitHub.

▲Timwi 11 minutes ago | parent [-]

I agree. I had no difficulty finding and opening one of the PDFs just for curiosity. (Of course I understood absolutely nothing in it)

▲reader9274 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I got the first 2 definitions. I'll take a break now.

▲eru 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Nobody has built the Lean project in full yet

Huh? I thought multiple people did?

▲Luke2642 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I'll wait for the human rewrite.

Rather than making my eyes bleed with claudisms, it needs completely rewriting. For example, the unitary hypotheses node page intro paragraph is:

The Lean code ends the trunk with one existence statement. A record of forty-six fields, called HypsAlt, has an element. This page says what that record is, what the words "definite side" and "closed bound" mean in the code, and what the three large branches prove.

But wouldn't an intro be so much nicer with a little narrative leading:

This final node of the main proof shows that a 46-field record called HypsAlt has at least one element. The Lean theorem takes seven inputs, including sixty literature hypotheses on unitary groups and a "closed bound" on families of arithmetic data. Three main branches use these inputs to prove the "definite side" condition and two estimates, then build the HypsAlt element.