| ▲ | peter_d_sherman 5 hours ago | |
>"One of the sources of my fascination with Magic, and, indeed, one of the reasons that a truly performant and complete software implementation of the game has yet to be achieved, is the nature of abilities in the game. Abilities in Magic can compound exponentially , and the amount of different possible interactions that can occur when any ability is triggered leads to a situation where although there may not be an unfeasible amount of state in principle, the amount of checks that are required to ensure that no further side effects must be put on the stack also grows exponentially, and as we all know, exponential behavior is an enemy of us mere mortal computer scientists." This is not different than any other system... In Computer Programming, for example, software features may affect other software features (or functions may affect other functions, or state may effect state, if you prefer), and they may compound linearly, multiplicatively, or exponentially (or conversely, not at all, or negatively linearly, negatively multiplicatively, or negatively exponentially). "The whole might be greater than the sum of the parts", as that old expression goes, but then again (conversely), it might also be exactly equal to the sum of the parts, or even (if parts detract/subtract from other parts), less than the sum of the whole of the parts". In Physics, waves can add to one another (aka "constructive interference"), not interfere with one another (if at the wrong direction/angle/frequency (etc.) relative to the medium), or subtract from one another (aka "destructive interference"). But, exponential (aka "compounding effects" aka "synergy/synergistic") behaviors are possible in a variety of systems with multiple parts (heck, any system with multiple parts!)... including but not limited to such things as corporations, governments, militaries, trade, economics, video games, and even such things as education, both personal and nationwide... I'd even go so far as to potentially believe that exponential, compounding effects are even responsible for every winner of every Nobel Prize, because exponential / compounding effects happen in the space of Ideas as well... That is, think of each possible Idea that could exist in the mind of someone -- as its own "Magic: The Gathering" card... Now what happens when we (or the Nobel Prize winners, as the case may be) "stack" or compound several really good existing ideas together? Idea A + Idea B + Idea C What happens? Well those ideas (and there may be more than 3 of them, often many more!) stack or compound... That is, they become exponential in their effect; they generate exponential behavior! (But, we can observe exponential behaviors in a variety of systems... M:TG is one example of such a system...) Anyway, great article! | ||