Remix.run Logo
▲ vorpalhex 2 hours ago

Except he.. didn't do those things?

Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.

Which is:

+ Not a failing of Jensen

+ Still an open accusation that may well be false (it was previously investigated and found not true)

+ Has no named accusers!

That sounds pretty weak to me.

▲dofm 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.

From here there are immediately stronger forms:

1) they fully should have known, because they are a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items and get advice from all across government, and "Singapore-washing" is a widely understood phenomenon, and therefore they are very significantly negligent, which probably breaks the law itself.

This is IMO completely unarguable.

2) they did know they were doing it

It seems impossible to argue then that since they didn't stop when it became obvious that Singapore-washing is a thing, they were continuing in the knowledge that they were, effectively, breaking that law.

3) therefore it is really impossible to argue against the idea that he knew because he was sleeping with one of the major beneficiaries.

4) if he knew, and didn't stop it, he personally made a choice to continue to violate the law.

You can get all the way to 4) without ever considering the possibility that there's actual evidence chips left Singapore for China. And yet there's so much circumstantial evidence that a highly plausible route from Nvidia to e.g. Century Litong (and therefore benefiting DeepSeek) actually existed.

If you were to argue that it gets no further than 1), you're essentially making the argument that Jensen Huang is just an ignorant idiot. I wouldn't make that argument.

▲vorpalhex an hour ago | parent [-]

1) This claim is false

It was investigated already.. and debunked.

2) Treating your argument as a conclusion

Is a poor form of arguing. It betrays a lack of rigor.

3) Unverified assumptions

Are not evidence of wrongdoing.

4) Just because you want it to be true

Doesn't mean it is.

▲dofm an hour ago | parent [-]

What is it about 1) that is false and debunked?

Are you arguing that Nvidia aren't a nationally significant manufacturer of export-controlled items? That is not something that can be debunked, because it is true.

That they (and Jensen Huang) wouldn't therefore have been constantly monitored and in contact with the State and Commerce department (diplomacy, compliance, advice, all that)?

That they didn't know and weren't advised Singapore-washing is a thing? They should have known this at the very latest by May 2025, because that is when they were first asked for records about Megaspeed. That is not debunkable.

They were almost certainly advised it was being investigated well before that. Singapore police were known to be investigating Megaspeed in February 2025, and Singapore was prosecuting a smuggler then too — Dell servers with Nvidia GPUs.

Reuters first reported evidence of smuggled GPUs way earlier than that — in 2023, and then there is this, in the South China Morning Post, also from 2023:

https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-war/article/3225594/tech-war-...

Do you think nobody at Nvidia reads the South China Morning Post? Or are you arguing that they were not negligent even if they did know?

Or that negligence is not something export law cares about?

Any links you have about how it was debunked would I am sure be interesting. Because, come on, you should really be stipulating. And from there, we can move on to 2).

▲nateglims 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Companies are punished for selling to intermediaries who went on to violate laws even when the company didn't know it. I've worked for one who still got fined despite not knowing and fully complying with the investigation.

And the reporting is exactly that he has the attention of the federal government. We are talking about risk management by lawyers not standards of innocence at trial.

▲jeremyjh 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Actually there are KYC requirements in these export bans. Even selling to a distributor in the US that exports to China can create meaningful exposure if you don’t do any due diligence.

▲grg0 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

ITAR covers re-exports. It's your responsibility to audit the full chain.

▲enraged_camel 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>> Right now the strongest form of possible accusation is that nvidia sold chips to someone who then ferried them to someone on the blacklist.

Based on extensive investigative journalism by NYT, WSJ and others, there appears to be strong evidence that NVIDIA was not only fully aware of what was happening, but also their sales team actively worked around US export controls in order to sell more chips, and this was sanctioned and even encouraged by Jensen.

Right now Jensen's only possible saving grace is that these chip sales to Megaspeed were approved by the Dept. of Commerce under Lutnick. Lutnick, though, seems to have his own finger in the pie and profited from NVIDIA's behavior.

The whole thing stinks to high heavens and IMO it is very unlikely that Jensen is innocent. My guess is that he will be pardoned by Trump at some point, either pre-emptively or after a conviction.

▲dofm an hour ago | parent [-]

If Lutnick skates, then Jensen Huang arguably even deserves a pardon; it would be unjust, I think, to punish him for lawbreaking that the Commerce department knowingly enabled, if there are no consequences for Lutnick. I would hope that is the outcome for him in that scenario.

Not least because as a non-American who uses open weights models, my view is that Chinese open weights competition has made US open weights models better, I think this is a view Jensen Huang holds and if it were me in that position I would be making a stronger case for that than turning a blind eye.

Then again, I don't think anyone in Trump's cabinet really deserves to skate if the USA is to justifiably regain its reputation for anything other than kleptocracy, and if this is the thing that ironically finally nails Howard Lutnick then so be it.

▲ 24 minutes ago | parent [-]
[deleted]