Remix.run Logo
▲ saghm 10 hours ago

If I don't get my paycheck, I immediately notice and can complain, and a human will be able to rectify whatever issue caused it. If I literally never got a paycheck again, we have decidedly non-mathematical ways of dealing with it (a legal system).

I don't see the comparison here. Detecting issues in a 17 million line proof is not remotely trivial, if we accidentally build a bunch of math on a failed proof, we don't have a retroactive way of getting all of that time and effort back.

I'm not saying that automated proofs like this aren't worthwhile, but the parent comment did say "functionally equivalent". The level of trust that's needed in the people who used the system to produce the output is a pretty clear functional difference in my mind between payroll and huge generated proofs. I don't think I need as much trust in someone who produces an automated proof as someone who claims that god told them something directly (since that's a lot harder to believe in general), but I also don't have a particularly large amount of trust in the average employee of Anthropic making a bold claim either.

There have always been a large number of people in the world (and still are!) that believe any number of things on the basis on faith rather than evidence, and it's not crazy to draw a parallel between "that religious authority says so" and "that Anthropic employee says so"; for the overwhelming majority of people in the world, the claims are essentially both impossible to falsify, so at the end of the day we are still relying on trust (whether from that authority directly or from a consensus of other people we trust).