Remix.run Logo
▲ badpun 2 hours ago

> But the problem is the front door in hiring is broken.

Is it really broken? I haven't heard about companies having trouble with filling positions with people they are largely happy with, so hiring seems to work as intented.

If by "broken" you mean "frustrating for cadidates", then it's a different matter. But, it could be argued that the job itself (cushy, high-paying, low stress office SWE job) is more than enough compensation for the frustrations required to get it. Similarly (but much more extreme), Navy Seal candidates go through recruitment process that is actively built for breaking their will. But, those who perservere, get rewarded with an elite and prestigious posting.

▲mjg59 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I applied for a role involving Linux kernel development, TPMs, and corporate security. I got rejected immediately. I was able to follow up with a friend in a senior engineering position who was able to get my resume in front of the hiring manager, and I was interviewed the next day and made an offer less than a week later. An anecdote rather than data, but on the other side you're rarely going to see the people you're missing out on - they may be filling positions with people they're happy with, but that doesn't mean they're filling positions with the applicant who'd do the best job.

▲bruce511 an hour ago | parent [-]

I'd counter this with two realities;

Firstly, most employers don't specifically target "best". Partly because "best" is hard to define, and includes measurements across multiple axles. And partly because it's impossible to know you have just seen the "best" so leading to paralysis.

Typically companies thus target "good enough" and for lots of positions there are several candidates that fit that bill. Sure they'll choose the one they think will be the best, but there's no way to know for sure.

Secondly, and speaking generally here, for most of us, this is probably a good thing since it's very likely there is a better candidate than me out there somewhere. If companies only hire "the best" then all us "second best, still good enough " folk would struggle a lot more.

Of course we all think we are the best possible option. Because we value our strengths and devalue our weaknesses. But objectively what are the odds that out of hundreds of applicants we're the actual "best"?

This doubly so when so many high quality people are looking for jobs?

▲grumple 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

No, it’s broken. On the hiring side, most resumes are fraudulent, most phone screens will be with foreign spies, and the sheer quantity nearly drowns out the plentiful number of good candidates. Also our old way of doing code challenges doesn’t make sense in the age of AI.

▲adastra22 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Arguably it didn't make sense before either.