| ▲ | jmyeet 5 hours ago | |
The example many people use is the cotton gin. When it was invented it greatly reduced the labor required for a certain part of the cotton harvesting-to-textile process. Some believed this and other labor-saving machinery would reduce the demand for slaves. Spoiler: it had the opposite effect. Cotton became so much cheaper than demand exploded and the demand for cotton basically doubled every decade after its invention. So AI is going to destroy certain industries and others will have much lower demand for employees. The optimistic view is that AI will be like the cotton gin. Those industries will get cheaper and demand will go up or new industries will form in their place, sort of like the telegraph, electricity, radio and the Internet created industries. The pessimistic view is that this won't happen. There will be a tipping point where labor supply will exceed demand and this will put severe downward pressure on wages and create an unemployment nightmare that we're simply not prepared for. The last time this really happened was the Great Depression and at least then, the majority of the population was rural and way more self-sufficient for food and the like, not that I want to diminish the devastating effects. I'm in the pessimistic camp. I believe automation in general and AI in particular is destroying labor demand faster than it's being replaced. You see this with decades of stagnant real wages (in aggregate) and the net effect is that we're creating a massive wealth concentration in a handful of people. As Alfred Henry Lewis put it in 1896, "the only barrier between us and anarchy is the last nine meals we've had." And now we live in a country with more guns than people so we'll see how that goes. | ||