Remix.run Logo
▲ mjburgess 19 hours ago

Some people i've shown this to (in admiration for Feynman) have had the same reaction, but I just cannot see it. I'd be interested to know why you think he's unpleasant.

Are you a physicist? I wonder if non-physicists just misread his frustration. The question isnt about some macroscopic physics problem that decomposes clearly into something satisfying. Its a question about one of the most basic constituents of reality. A "why?" question about something so basic has no answer other than "just because". Insofar as anything can be said, it will be so abstract and technical that it wont satisfyingly address the question.

It is a little like a lay person asking a mathematician: why is 0*1 = 0, but 0+1=1 ?

Except, somewhat more extreme than that, because such basic things as 'magnetism' are introduced into all accessible physics formalisms as assumptions.

▲loose-cannon 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Because he projects a certain kind of frustration that's not warranted in that moment. He's being asked a technical question without any means to give a rigorous answer. I appreciate rigorous thinking, but the interviewer doesn't necessarily want a perfectly rigorous answer, nor does the average person. He's not responding to a need, he's projecting his own perfectionism.

The interviewer most likely would not have interrogated him further about the underlying properties of ice (or engaged in that entire fictitious interaction). Feynman clearly understands that there are several levels to understanding.

So just give an answer that you feel is appropriate, add a disclaimer ("this answer is hand wavy"), and move on. Why is that so hard?

▲mjburgess 18 hours ago | parent [-]

The answer is, "I cannot explain that force to you. It is just, as a matter of fact, one of the fundamental forces of nature."

He's taking it as read that the reason he is giving his extended answer is to explain why he cannot answer at all.

What he could have said to a physics student is that: wave-functions of charged particles have a property, "phase". The problem is that point values of phase cannot be observed, and if you formulate the laws of physics with raw "phase" values (like a measure of mass, at 5kg), they dont work. So something must exist to "track" phase, so that every pair of measurements "cancel out" the effect of this property. That something is the EM field. Magentism is a spatial aspect of this field. Eletricity is a space-time aspect of this field. So the magnetic force arises out of a need to "conserve phase", and that phase is how a pushing force is experienced: two particles experiencing a magentic interaction take on different phases (their wavefunctions interfere such that..).

This might "feel" like an explanation to the physics student, because they will be willing to make the assumptions needed, and they will find conservation-style explanations sufficiently satisfying. ie., they can already see a wavefn description will have a free phase term. But a lay person wouldnt feel satisfied because more unknowns have been introduced, and conserving "another unknown" is no advancement in understanding.

That's the gulf which is frustrating feynman. There's nothign to be said to the interviewer other than the force has no explanation in terms of anything he's familiar with. The question is too basic. And feynman is not going to go thru a formulation of QM in terms of wavefns in 5min -- it would be an entire lecture course.