| ▲ | jaredklewis an hour ago | |
Does Alpöge disagree? Can you point us to a particular quote or such? I read Alpöge's 4 page statement but can't find anything that would contradict the rather mild claim of the parent comment: a non-mathmatician would have been unable to solve this problem even with all LLMs in the world at their disposal. Parent is not saying that the human's contribution is greater than that of the LLMs, just that at least at present, there is apparently still some human input. | ||
| ▲ | bm3719 an hour ago | parent | next [-] | |
I'm replying to this part: "that director is the one who deserves the credit, not me, not you, not the calculator, not claude" On your point, we don't exactly know if that's true or not. Perhaps it would've burned more tokens, but if Claude did the heavy lifting here, then who's to say it couldn't have done all of it with just very persistent neophyte encouragement (not saying this person did that, just speculating on it being technically possible)? Large applications are being vibed right now this way, and yeah, they're often brittle messes, but if their job is to accomplish some singular goal, Claude can test for that and ensure the desired functionality. I encounter this analogous situation in my work more often than I'd like. | ||
| ▲ | unclebucknasty 16 minutes ago | parent | prev [-] | |
>Parent is not saying that the human's contribution is greater than that of the LLMs, just that at least at present, there is apparently still some human input. Actually, parent said "AI is just a tool, like a calculator", which certainly does imply that the human's contribution is greater than that of the LLMs. | ||