Remix.run Logo
▲ perching_aix 2 hours ago

> Why live? Our servants can do that for us (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ax%C3%ABl).

I'm sure the author thinks this was an absolute slapper of a reference to prove their point, but the point proven doesn't exactly belong.

The whole passage seems to be an appeal to reject: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clay_Shirky#Shirky_principle

on the grounds of preferring to yield to our inherent bias of continued existence instead.

Meanwhile, our servants not being able to live on our behalves is completely independent of this. It is also robust against being considered a betrayal or a surrender, while the above really quite isn't.

Contrasting this with the identification of Alpöge's writing as words of final relief could have painted a much richer picture, than a literature and art references riddled myopic narrative concluding like every other like it.

Not that it has any need to arrive somewhere different, but still. It insists upon the illusion of sophistication it suggests should prevail, because it is at least human. Hardy any more actually satisfactory than the alternative despised. Quite the contrary, if anything.

But hey, if we insist on references, here, from the 1979 movie The Witness, satirizing the soviet occupation era politics in Hungary:

> - What is this?

> - An orange.

> - An orange?!

> - The new, Hungarian orange. It's a bit more yellow and a bit more sour, but it is ours.

> *proceeds to continue munching on the lemon slice with a pained, approving smile*

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1ghpXiBkCQ