| ▲ | 10111001 21 minutes ago | |
> Certainly it's a fact that the schools didn't care in the past, but I think that's mostly a result of AI not being in the spotlight then, and there wasn't a broad anti-AI faction then. > From TFA: >> Attendees of all ages held signs reading, “NO AI IN MY SCHOOL!”, “A.I. Gets an F,” “Stop stealing our imaginations,” and “SCHOOL Librarians = THE BEST Search Engines.” > I'm pretty sure these people would not be okay with plain search if they understood the extent to which it uses and has used AI. I doubt it, and if they did, it'd probably be due to misunderstanding where they conflate LLMs with pre-LLM AI technology (e.g. the "12-15 years" tech that was used for Google Search ranking). The emotions are pretty clearly being driven by the current thing (LLMs and similar models). I think you're making the mistake of interpreting their statements too literally, using definitions and interpretations that they simply don't share, to falsely twist their statements into embarrassing contradictions. You can use the word "AI" and they can use the word "AI" and you can both mean different things (or have some conceptual overlap but with significant differences). > (Also, I suspect you and other commenters have an implicit belief that the AI plain search uses and what the AI box does are fundamentally different, and I doubt that. The search algo is going to incorporate new tech as it comes along, and it's unlikely there is zero LLM involvement.) When they say AI, they are almost certainly referring to the chatbots, the AI overviews, etc. and excluding search, which has no user-obvious AI component. Being "but ackchyually" to try to turn their position on its head can be pretty disrespectful. | ||