Remix.run Logo
▲ boringg a day ago

I mean isn't circular financing how the economy works as a whole? Its just what level we tolerate before people think its risky. Economies are circular in nature.

▲wmf a day ago | parent | next [-]

The real implication is that Nvidia is providing financing so customers can buy GPUs that they do not want or need. It's closer to channel stuffing.

I'm not saying I believe this, but I think this is the real concern for many skeptics.

▲lokar a day ago | parent | next [-]

Also providing financing at a substantial discount compared to what an independent lender would charge for that risk.

This then has the effect of artificially raising profits (you are providing a subsidy, but not counting it as an expense).

▲martinald a day ago | parent | next [-]

But literally every car company does this. If you take out a lease or a loan with eg Ford Credit they will offer incentives that no bank will.

While I think eg taking equity is one thing, providing finance incentives is pretty standard in "traditional" industries

▲watwut 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This argument keeps popping up, but no, car companies are not doing the same thing. The money lending company is different org then the car making one - per law.

▲lokar a day ago | parent | prev [-]

As long as you account for it correctly.

▲dcrazy a day ago | parent [-]

This is why so many companies keep coming up with newer, even more “inventive” extensions of EBITDA: to draw attention away from the numbers which reflect customer acquisition costs as expenses.

▲JumpCrisscross 21 hours ago | parent [-]

Ebitda is non-GAAP.

▲dcrazy 21 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, my point was that EBITDA isn’t enough nowadays. You wind up with truly crazy numbers like WeWork’s “Community Adjusted EBITDA.”

▲JumpCrisscross 21 hours ago | parent [-]

> You wind up with truly crazy numbers like WeWork’s “Community Adjusted EBITDA"

That one must reach back to a 2019 aborted IPO probably indicates that we didn't "wind up" with this.

Anthropic went public with audited financials showing GAAP figures. While it did also have management numbers in its prospectus, as is expected, the market seemed to fixate on price to revenues. Again, entirely GAAP figures.

▲JumpCrisscross 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> providing financing at a substantial discount compared to what an independent lender would charge for that risk

This is standard vendor financing and it’s fine. The weird part with Nvidia is the taking of equity in its customers. (Also sleeping with customers.)

▲throwup238 18 hours ago | parent [-]

> (Also sleeping with customers.)

Perks of the job. CEOs don’t just get free snacks like the rest of us.

▲JumpCrisscross 10 hours ago | parent [-]

> Perks of the job

This is being repeated by people who seem to believe this. But the firings of the CEOs of McDonald's, Intel and HP for this exact misbehavior indicates what actually happens when this is uncovered (to anyone other than Elon Musk).

▲ 11 minutes ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲sl0wbrainRot 16 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is/was most def going on

In 2024 I received an email to an address setup for a side hustle

Email was from a neo cloud with H100s for around 23% the cost of the usual suspects

Immediately wondered why a no-name neo cloud has such a fancy discount for a nothing side hustle with no traction

Emailed back hypothesizing channel stuffing. Reply was a simple

"You might be onto something ;)"

Since then been no question this all been a too big to fail push to make big deals and expect a bailout or the entire economy collapses

▲malnourish a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

My neighbor told me a few months ago that Nvidia contacted him and offered a program where he could finance GPUs and then immediately lease their usage back through an intermediary.

It was slightly more complicated than that, but he claims NVidia was practically telling him it was free money. He is a natural salesman/ entrepreneur and thus prone to some exaggerating, but he's not what I'd call a liar.

▲jaredklewis a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> GPUs that they do not want or need.

Wait what? Which customers specifically are you referring to? All of the financing I have heard about has been for customers I definitely believe are using them: CoreWeave, Nscale, Crusoe, Firmus, Nebius, etc... Not sure how to evaluate if those companies "want" or "need" them, but I also can't imagine how they wouldn't, seeing their whole business model is selling access to these chips.

▲anon291 a day ago | parent | next [-]

If these GPUs were not needed, then GPU rental price should be going down as all these neoclouds attempt to sell capacity, but GPU rental prices are going up.

▲eek2121 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Correct, however, NVIDIA has massive amounts of reserved wafer allocations at TSMC with no product/customer match. Those companies are also buying at their own pace, not at the pace NVIDIA needs them to. I would be REALLY surprised if NVIDIA pulls through this nonsense. They are profitable on paper, however, based on everything I've read, they are actually in a ton of trouble unless they can renegotiate everything. Like..."Bear Sterns" trouble.

EDIT: One small thing I wanted to mention, is that while I compared this to the downfall of Bear Sterns, NVIDIA is actually lower risk than the infamous investment banking company. There is a lot of room for things to go right. TSMC knows they'll have a ton of demand, regardless, so they could negotiate down allocations with NVIDIA. NVIDIA could also use their free cash flow and make more inventory, even without buyers, and sell it for smaller margins or a slight loss. They can even use those allocations for future gaming chips and other stuff. That second path will cost them big time. Hopefully, they can negotiate deals with TSMC.

▲etempleton 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Nvidia is not just profitable on paper, they are wildly profitable on paper. 70% + margins on 115 Billion a quarter revenue with even more projected for Q4.

I doubt Nvidia would have trouble finding a buyer for their chips in the medium term. Demand is incredibly high and most of the demand is actually originating from the big tech companies - SpaceX, Microsoft, Google, Oracle, Amazon, etc.

▲aeonik a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Weird, I've been dying to purchase a new computer but I can't justify the latest prices so I've been holding off.

Customers are there I think...

▲seanmcdirmid 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Not if DRAM is the limiting factor rather than GPUs.

▲dannyw 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Would you pay 10k USD for a 5090 though? No? If it was just 2k, then think about all the margin compression…

▲mrgordon 19 hours ago | parent [-]

Since when did the misinformation on here get to be as bad as WallStreetBets

NVIDIA never raised the price of a 5090 Founders Edition. They are still $2k although you won't find one.

Resellers charge $6k (NOT $10k) and NVIDIA does not get more than they did before so there is no margin compression for NVIDIA if they charge $2k in the future.

▲PeterStuer 14 hours ago | parent | next [-]

"you won't find one" carries a lot of the weight here.

▲jjav 12 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> They are still $2k although you won't find one.

In other words, they are not $2k then.

▲s1artibartfast 6 hours ago | parent [-]

If you're following the thread, this is about what shows up on Nvidia balance sheet. Revenue is 2K for them

▲ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲SilasX a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

GPUs are an extremely hot commodity right now and the bottleneck for a lot of high-demand production. It's very hard to imagine there being sales that are artificial, or companies buying overpriced units that they don't need, given the manifest extreme demand for them.

▲ifwinterco 13 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The issue is it's reflexive in both directions, feast can turn to famine very quickly

▲hyperadvanced a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Isn’t the whole point of this that demand is being artificially exaggerated by NVDA subsidizing consumption? I.e. the extreme demand emanates from NVDA loaning everyone money and then turning around and saying “wow, you guys sure want these chips huh!??” Of course demand is extreme when you hold all of the resource and then juice demand!

▲missedthecue a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Do not want or need? There is a 12-18 month backlog right now and the bosses of OpenAI just said yesterday they needed compute wherever they could find it.

Maybe everyone's lying to the point of committing felonies, but I'd need more proof than conspiracy theory posting. Could I buy a few racks of vera rubin right now?

▲TwoNineFive 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> GPUs that they do not want or need

> I'm not saying I believe this

Saying things you don't believe is called "lying". You are lying.

▲Grimburger a day ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]

▲gessha 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Circular financing has a very specific meaning with respect to supplier and consumer and generalizing it for the whole economy is either naive or trollish.

▲joshribakoff 19 hours ago | parent [-]

And if there is an intermediate party between the supplier and consumer to add indirection? Its a spectrum.

▲anon291 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes, when a bank makes a loan, suddenly, that's a new asset and this is the fundamental force of money creation in any economy.

▲janderson215 10 hours ago | parent [-]

A loan is a liabilities, not an asset.

▲fancyfredbot 2 hours ago | parent [-]

A loan is an asset to the lender and a liability to the borrower.

▲cmiles8 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Legitimate vendor financing is a thing and generally accepted as OK. For example a car company giving loans to credit-worthy folks to buy a car. Or leasing cars to folks via similar mechanisms. If the risk is managed properly it’s a nice profit center since now you get car revenue plus loan interest.

What Nvidia has been doing is closer to a car company finding a bunch of broke folks that will require a small miracle to pay back the loan, and financing cars for all them, then telling the market demand for cars if off the charts. If magically somehow these folks can generate cash to pay for it one gets away with it. If not, then you have a mini-2008 financial crisis unfolding on your balance sheet.

▲missedthecue a day ago | parent | next [-]

That second paragraph is basically how the aircraft leasing business works, and has worked for a very long time. Lend planes on credit to buyers intending to monetize and pay them back.

Boeing Capitals whole purpose is to provide financing to cash strapped airlines hoping to monetize the airframe.

I don't see a reason to be especially cynical about this business model because it has been proven to work in concept. I think the only thing left to answer is how profitable inference actually is, and how easy it is to use GPUs as collateral (it's very easy with a Boeing 777). We have 80 years of airline data and about 1-2 years of neocloud data.

▲cmiles8 a day ago | parent | next [-]

Except only around 1% of Boeing sales are vendor financed. Leasing aircraft is popular by airlines but that balance sheet risk is carried by separate leasing companies. And there is a very strong market for second hand aircraft including those decades old. So it’s a totally different market setup than GPUs.

▲cmiles8 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Ha. Yes. Hence the phrase how do you become a millionaire in the airline business? Be a billionaire and found an airline.

▲missedthecue a day ago | parent [-]

Well yes running an airline is a famously difficult business. But my point is that financing airlines has been fantastically profitable.

If GPUs turn out to be highly analogous to airplanes, (in the sense that they are monetizable capital goods offered on credit), then the neoclouds might suffer just like airlines over the long run while Nvidia and other creditors do handsomely.

▲delis-thumbs-7e a day ago | parent [-]

> If GPUs turn out to be highly analogous to airplanes

That’s some hefty if you got there. I don’t know much about aircraft financing, but I know that if you default on your airline company I paid for, I have a fledt of very very expensive planes ready to make money next 20-30 years. I also know they will have demand since people need to fly and demand is linked to GDP. Also, did not Boeing amputate it’s financing portfolio years ago precisely because it is so dangerous, whereas Nvidia takes money from left pocket, gives to neocloud to receive it back and puts it in his right pocket?

If CoreWeave defaults you got bunch of GPU’s deprecating as we speak and being out of demand in 5-6 years. Also you have AI demand of which everyone say is off the roof, but the numbers on the board don’t seem to add up. Basically it is almost like throwing trillions of dollars to Wright -brothers after their first flight.

I think the fundamentals will be there one day, but it doesn’t look they are there now.

▲missedthecue a day ago | parent [-]

So there are a couple of things here.

First, in the limited period of time we have had to observe inference economics, it's clear that these chips have an economically useful life that is longer than their accounting depreciation schedule. A100s sold in 2020 are still running 24 hours a day earning money. This is also true of airliners. United is still flying planes built in 1991. That has long long been depreciated and is still earning profit every day.

Second and far more important; Yes, an airliner lasts longer than a GPU, but the economic payback is also way way longer. A 737 can take generally 15 years to economically recoup the investment. Meanwhile they're saying a Blackwell is what, 9 months payback? And a Vera Rubin even faster.

▲Woodi 9 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Legitimate vendor financing is a thing and generally accepted as OK

> What Nvidia has been doing is closer to a car company finding a bunch of broke folks that will require a small miracle to pay back the loan

Did you noticed Nvidia being no.1 on Wall Street or something like that? They was doing it at global economy scale Not some random individual wanting to get car worth maybe 3 x DGX Sparks.

And do you know what is worth ~5 Sparks ? Commercial bakery furnance with 60 years warranty for heating elements (German steel, German welding ;) and maybe 3 days of work of building it in bakery.

That computer things are way overvalued and they keep pumping it - just one company ordered 40% of global RAM production without even having builded computer room. And that company do not even plan to be profitable so from where they had money to pay for order of global 40% of RAM ?

▲bigbuppo a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I know someone that works at a high credit risk used car lot. Their motto is literally, "We sell to sell again" and that's kind of a joke. It's not uncommon for them to resell a vehicle that has been reposessed several times before it finally ends up somewhere permanent or is beyond economic repair.

I'm sure nvidia's plan is/was to take over the neoclouds that failed, and then sell turnkey solutions (pre-racked systems or whole datacenters) to other hopeful neoclouds.

▲eyeat a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Yes, money exchanges hands. Wow, we engage in a society.

The issue lies within the entire market being concentrated on 7 companies... and then 5... and now 3... and with these companies being so high up on stilts, their relative risk is heightened.

I am certainly not buying $NVDA right now

▲rileymat2 a day ago | parent | next [-]

I thought the issue with NVIDIA is at times money was not changing hands, but they were getting investments in companies that needed GPU's at unsustainable markups? Or am I misunderstanding the controversy? If money was changing hands, this would not be an issue?

▲icedchai a day ago | parent | prev [-]

The market has a tendency to overreact in both directions. I'm not buying NVDA yet, but it's certainly on my watch list. I think it will be below $100 again, soon.