Remix.run Logo
▲ jstummbillig a day ago

I wonder he good we will be at not understanding anything to an ever increasing degree, with absolutely no hope of ever catching up. We will be super bad at absolutely everything within sciences and engineering and completely unable to contribute anything of substance, outside our own moods and quirks.

Can humans be okay with that? Can we be happy cats?

▲mapontosevenths a day ago | parent | next [-]

> Can humans be okay with that? Can we be happy cats?

Sometime in your youth you decided what was important to you, and how to define your worth as a person.

Many of us here decided that science, creation, and discovery were among the noblest of values... And consequently came to believe that those who did not engage in those things were therfore of lower value.

We were wrong, and maybe now we have to learn that we were... It might hurt.

Similarly the looming robotics boom means that those who define themselves by the very strange, but very deeply ingrained, protestant work ethic will come to find themselves in want of purpose... And a new means by which to judge the worth of others.

The only thing I can really promise is that nobody will learn anything meaningful, and that we will simply replace our existing fallacies with new ones.

▲Paul-E a day ago | parent | next [-]

> Many of us here decided that science, creation, and discovery were among the noblest of values... And consequently came to believe that those who did not engage in those things were therfore of lower value.

The nobility of old felt that they inherited "noble" qualities from their ancestors, and this justified their privileges and their elevated status as moral subjects. I can't help but see the parallels with the culture tech has built around intelligence and merit. It forms much our basis for identity and moral status. When AI exceeds us, does it take away our moral status, or does it challenge our value system based on intelligence and merit?

▲avereveard a day ago | parent | next [-]

It challenges our ownership of the means of production, we're speedrunning tumbling down the pyramid of maslow

▲cowlevel 12 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The nobility of new still believe that, but the inheritance comes in the form of several digits and an S with a stick through it.

▲epihelix 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Many of us here decided that science, creation, and discovery were among the noblest of values... And consequently came to believe that those who did not engage in those things were therfore of lower value.

> We were wrong, and maybe now we have to learn that we were

While I don't want to engage with that disturbing and loaded "lower value" comment -- what makes you think that scientific discovery is now devalued? LLMs are helping us increase our discovery potential, not decrease it. And if we didn't still value discovery, we wouldn't be prompting LLMs to help us.

▲mbowcut2 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Many of us here decided that science, creation, and discovery were among the noblest of values... And consequently came to believe that those who did not engage in those things were therfore of lower value. We were wrong, and maybe now we have to learn that we were... It might hurt.

I have this feeling like we're all being pushed toward art. We'll be either poets or slaves.

▲hobo123 14 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, and the sad part of this is that AI too can easily generate good looking art, and probably will be able to generate good sounding music (is been a while since I listened to anything suno).

But of course art we make ourselves will have a point and a purpose behind it, so that's no reason to not do it.

▲jaredklewis a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I’ll take poetry then I guess.

But just given the current capabilities of AI, I think dishwasher is more realistic. The AIs will do maths and poetry while we do the dishes and laundry.

▲jdndhxjxnxbzhxh a day ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲yen223 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You and I are already bad at 99.99% of things that can be done. This is just one more thing we are bad at.

▲reasonableklout a day ago | parent | next [-]

But before, you were still able to contribute to the 0.01% of things that you were good at. And by working together with other people that you trusted, you were able to collectively advance human scientific understanding.

Now we have to trust the models. How do we build and maintain that trust, especially over the next decades as generations of people grow up without having to build the same intellectual muscles?

▲yen223 a day ago | parent | next [-]

You are free to do maths the old-fashioned way. Nothing about the presence of LLMs prevents that.

▲cowlevel 12 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You can. It won't be a contribution.

▲MiiMe19 15 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I absolutely hate this argument and I am so sick of seeing it. Some of us have jobs to make money you know. Some of us enjoyed those jobs you know. Some of us don't want to clock in every day to a job that we hate for the next 30 years of our lives you know. "Nothing about the presence of the torture-you-at-work-machine 3000 prevents you from not being tortured after work bro."

▲xiphias2 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Just like how I trust the house I am in to not fall down.

It's simple: we have no choice.

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲ludwigschubert a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

https://gwern.net/doc/fiction/science-fiction/2000-chiang.pd...

▲nozzlegear a day ago | parent [-]

Somewhat related: Chiang's short story about mathematicians discovering that dividing by zero is legal and makes any number provably equal (or something like that, I can't remember exactly), introducing a crisis in mathematics. Fair warning, it's kind of a depressing story.

https://fantasticmetropolis.com/i/division/

▲bigDinosaur 20 hours ago | parent [-]

Isn't it more accurate to say that division by zero is intentionally not defined rather than 'undefined' since the latter implies it's just a discovery away from becoming defined? i.e. in JS lingo it's null rather than undefined, precisely because we want it to be and choose it to be.

If the story explores that then mea culpa as I haven't yet read it.

▲chr1 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If machines become that good, then they also should be able to invent ways to make us smarter.

It would be entirely ok if finding very complicated proofs becomes an activity for large machines, much like adding big numbers is. After all a proof is merely a path in an enormously large graph of repeatedly applied axioms. The interesting part is seeing how ideas are connected.

It would be really nice, if it turns out to be possible to make cats a bit smarter too, while keeping heir "catiness".

▲nradov 17 hours ago | parent [-]

It would certainly be possible to breed cats for intelligence (however you define or measure that attribute). But that would probably come with increased risk of certain genetic disorders. There are no free lunches in biology.

▲chr1 8 hours ago | parent [-]

If you only choose for only one specific trait, you are likely to end up with genetic disorders, but that is not related to increased intelligence. (E.g. dogs are smarter but do not have increased risk of disorders).

With ai predicting what changes to make, there is no reason for increased intelligence to cause genetic disorders, most likely it will simply cost them more energy. So your "no free lunches in biology" is true in very literal way, but humans and their cats have free lunches!

▲sl0wbrainRot a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We moved on from manual labor to knowledge work despite a lot of people complaining about loss of hands on skills

And if we meet the moment while generational churn replaces politicians we could draw a line in the sand... limit the AI at the hardware level from ever conjuring certain geometric patterns that lead it to certain tasks[1]; presumably "launch the nukes" and "add 1+1" are vastly different electrical geometry or "namespace collisions" occur in electrical state; but caveat being it's been a while since my hardware eng days so ...i could be way off being out of touch with the principles

So restrain it to never being able to consider "fully autonomous no humans in the loop" geometry by short circuiting geometry that approaches certain shapes; like grounding a car; circuit breaker is not encoded as ephemeral state but manufactured in

For utilitarian sake then, limit it to filling joann fabric and home depot and we all can be busy noodling local edge case solutions and keep up skills Norm Abrams-style in the event of systemic problems, writing zines and crafting mix tapes

Can still make art and play instruments away from a computer. Can still watch the night sky, start a campfire and cook smores. Doing it all on a laptop everyday is a recent diversion from millions of years of homo-this-n-that evolution

It's all resolvable socially and tech wise if we put in the effort. We got to the moon within a decade through similar collectivism

Media propaganda since Reagan been keeping people apart but everyone who was around for it keeps saying we were happier 25-30 years ago so maybe that's the social peak we aim for and let the robots do the mining and repetitive stress injury stuff

[1] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1742-6596/2987/1/...

▲mapontosevenths a day ago | parent [-]

The Jetson's got it backwards, and it's obvious in hindsight. Of course the robots came for the high-paying office jobs first, that's where the money is.

The robots will only come for the janitors job when there is nothing higher paying left.

▲sl0wbrainRot 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

A lot of the high paying jobs are also largely made up

Easy to disrupt social knowledge work that isn't keeping people biologically healthy and alive

Janitorial work keeps human spaces clean for us.

Relative to that sort of job, VP of Whatever who sits on Slack all day been doing nothing but noodling ephemeral finance variables

▲slopinthebag 20 hours ago | parent [-]

yeah good point. the total human value of all the slop produced by ai has gotta be pretty close to 0. yet to really see much big software that's meaningfully better. so who cares if it's slop?

▲onemoresoop 21 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You’re saying this as if the robots are going for the money. It’s really the money behind the robots which is chasing the money, the robots are just the vehicle.

▲bitwize 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

George's job was literally pushing a single button while the computer, RUDI, did the actual work.

But The Jetsons is still inaccurately utopian: One time when George was fired, RUDI intervened on his behalf and threatened to melt down the sprocket factory until he was rehired.

▲brookst 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How do you feel not understanding cars, the sun, the legal system from subatomic to macro system levels?

Computer science was a blip in time where something revolutionary was also simple enough for one person to understand from foundations to applications. Most things aren’t that way.

And yet left goes on. People have existing for millennia not deeply understanding the natural environment around them or the systems they use. When there’s a need for deep understanding, a handful of people fulfill the need.

I empathize with you because my life has been about understanding everything I possibly can, but I was never under any illusion that it would be possible to deeply understand everything. So if that makes me a happy cat, sure, count me in.

▲Tadpole9181 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That's the vast majority of people who have ever lived. Of course we can.

▲bluefirebrand a day ago | parent | next [-]

... Have the vast majority of people who have ever lived, had good lives? Were they happy?

I'm genuinely curious where the median human's experience falls throughout history. Mostly happy?

I suspect probably not

▲ a day ago | parent | next [-]
[deleted]
▲ a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲nomel a day ago | parent | prev [-]

To continue the absurdity, are cats happier in the wild or captivity? My cat was eaten by a coyote. Do we only count the time it was alive, or weight it somehow?

▲sigmoid10 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Yeah. The majority of humans will now be joined by the 0.001% of people who were capable of significant intellectual contributions to modern society.

▲GoblinSlayer 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Science is already there. "Shut up and calculate".

▲ChrisGreenHeur a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Luckily humans have the ability to abstract and simplify. Which is what we will now do.

▲ a day ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲drivebyhooting a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Didn’t EY have some raving essays about catgirl paradise. I’m sure one can trawl it out of the LW archives.

Soma is the endgame for 99% of humans.

▲the8472 a day ago | parent [-]

It's part of the fun theory sequence and more of an example of "you barely met the lower bound of good singularity outcomes, we should do better than that" sort of utopia.

https://www.lesswrong.com/s/d3WgHDBAPYYScp5Em/p/Py3uGnncqXuE...

▲cowlevel 12 hours ago | parent [-]

any autistic person could've told them romance is the most complicated thing ever

▲catlifeonmars a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Always have been. As an aside, cats likely run the world (or at least my household) so that may be a poor metaphor ;)

▲archagon a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

“We” is excluding the non-trivial contingent of humanity that will continue to do things with their own meat brains for the love of the game, or in anger.

And I suspect all future progress will actually rest on their shoulders, to the great consternation of the now-deskilled AI boosters.

▲0xbadcafebee a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is no logical reason that human beings would no longer be able to understand how things work. If you can understand the machine that created it, then you can understand what that machine creates. As far as anyone knows, there is nothing we can't eventually understand. It just might take more than 30 seconds of effort.

Let's take this one thing as an example. So, this one dumb machine created millions of pages of crap to try to prove a theorem. That doesn't mean a human being can't understand the proof. It just means this one proof is hard to understand. Hard - not impossible.

Hard doesn't mean we can't simplify the proof. Hard doesn't mean we can't break the proof up into bite-sized chunks and prove individual pieces of it. Hard doesn't mean that someone else won't find a much simpler proof. Hard doesn't mean we can't follow chains of logic to determine meaning. All it means is this one stupid machine in this one instance created a big stupid mess. A mess we can understand, if we try.

▲XorNot a day ago | parent | prev [-]

How much advanced mathematics do you understand today?

How well do you know how your car works?