Remix.run Logo
▲ kccqzy a day ago

I personally do consider the viewpoint of rejecting fair use as extreme.

Without fair use it would be illegal for you to quote my comment in order to provide your critique even if you had quoted only a sentence. You did quote me so I could sue you for violating my copyright just from this HN thread. That’s how extreme it is. Under such a regime, copyright would become a powerful tool that makes the first amendment a shell.

▲andersonpico a day ago | parent | next [-]

> Without fair use it would be illegal for you to quote my comment in order to provide your critique even if you had quoted only a sentence.

You are arguing in bad faith: it's perfectly possible to imagine a copyright framework in which AI-training is not permitted but some other notion of fair use exist (or any other legal idea that would make it ok for people to talk to each other on the internet).

It is also possible to disagree with what a court decision consider fair use without being against the concept itself. People disagree about what counts as freedom of expression all the time, but if someone says that a bomb threat is not covered by the first amendment would you say that he's rejecting freedom of expression?

▲Timon3 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Who is rejecting "fair use"?

▲kccqzy a day ago | parent [-]

The person I was originally responding to (not you).

▲Timon3 a day ago | parent [-]

Where? I read over GP's comment again, they said nothing about fair use.

▲phoghed 10 hours ago | parent [-]

Perhaps paste it into your favorite AI and ask it how it could possibly be conceived that the original comment is saying that. Because as I read it that’s a trivial and obvious interpretation of it. That person also didn’t seem to disagree with that interpretation in their reply.

▲Timon3 9 hours ago | parent [-]

The trivial and obvious interpretation of GPs comment is that Anthropic has committed theft. There is no indication that GP was implicitly talking about all fair use.

GP also has not responded to the comment where kccqzy accuses them of rejecting "fair use", so your point about their reply is moot. Though I'd note that none of their replies indicate that they were talking about rejecting "fair use" as a whole.

▲phoghed 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Unfortunately it’s only been found that anyone committed any kind of theft or infringement by not paying for books, not in how they used them, and not by scraping the Internet.

This is fact, this is not an opinion based topic. Anywhere this has been tried this has been the only outcome so far.

That’s what the person seems to disagree with.

▲Timon3 34 minutes ago | parent [-]

I'm unsure if you meant your last sentence as "they disagree with the fact that these rulings exist" or "they disagree with the rulings".

If it's the earlier, I genuinely haven't seen any indication that they deny the existence of these laws. In this case I'd appreciate if you quoted the exact part you mean.

If it's the latter, then... yeah, that's my point? People can disagree with these rulings. That doesn't mean they must automatically also be throwing out the entire concept of fair use.