Remix.run Logo
▲ win311fwg a day ago

A matter of perspective.

Imagine, as the tractor was arriving on the scene, a farmhand saying "we will get more valuable, see how much more we can do, we're more productive than ever!!!". You seem to be saying the tractor will make their farm labor less valuable. Which is true. But they're saying that the tractor freeing them from the field allows them to move on to more valuable activities, like software development. It is undeniable that software developers have been far more economically valuable than they would have been as farm laborers if the tractor was never invented.

Of course that is conditional on "software devs, a highly educated workforce" being true. If it is true then "we" are well poised to leave software behind to jump on the next big opportunity, but I suspect it isn't actually true.

▲packetlost a day ago | parent | next [-]

> You seem to be saying the tractor will make their farm labor less valuable

It did, it lowered the price of the end product, so the scale needed to increase to make the same amount of revenue with the ultimate consequence of there being less farmers necessary to sustain the demand for their crops.

> they're saying that the tractor freeing them from the field allows them to move on to more valuable activities, like software development

Surely you see the issue with this reasoning. In aggregate it allows society to 'rebalance' where labor is deployed over generations of time, but at the individual level it just leaves people jobless and eventually poor.

> Of course that is conditional on "software devs, a highly educated workforce" being true. If it is true then "we" are well poised to leave software behind to jump on the next big opportunity, but I suspect it isn't actually true.

Or it results in a further shrinking of the middle class and dramatic increases in inequality.

The real question is at what point does software saturate the demand. I personally thought that the market was already heavily saturated before AI, which does not bode well for career software engineers.

▲deeringc a day ago | parent [-]

Also, if AI can write software, create art, run a business and detect cancer in scans, better than any human what exactly is left for humans to move "up" to? The transition from farm labour to software was just blue collar to white collar, physical to intellectual. But if machines have taken the physical work and AI has taken the intellectual work, what exactly is left for us to pivot towards?

▲pigpop a day ago | parent | next [-]

Taste was the answer that we agreed on a few years ago. Being able to choose the best output or know when things are off. Having design sense and the tenacity to dogfood the output in order to fix the things AI can't see. It's like a combination of a design lead role with a QA role, you have to know every feature from the perspective of a user, sense where there is friction and confusion and know how to do it better. Maybe calling it a "director" role would be more apt since that combines creative vision with hands on, detail oriented work and directing the work of others to redo the product until it is right.

▲archagon a day ago | parent | next [-]

I would strongly argue that you can’t cultivate taste without having done, and continuing to do, the low-level work.

Few creative insights come from management.

▲ 10 hours ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲aquariusDue 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I suppose the coding ninja and programming rockstar will be joined by the new vibecoding auteur.

▲Creamsicle47 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

AI has solved software. Bugs are not yet solved. Humans still need to ship a fix for that.

▲9rx 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> what exactly is left for humans to move "up" to?

Same place the economy has already been going for a while: Looking the other way.

In other words, those with resources get to buy the ability to do things that are unacceptable or illegal for everyone else. The job is to accept it.

▲ThrowawayR2 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

In that analogy, current developers are more like the horses that pulled plows than the farmhands. Anyone noticed any horses on the gigantic industrial farms doing "more valuable activities" lately because the tractor freed them from plowing?

The farmhands are closer to product managers and architects but none of them are former horses.

▲9rx a day ago | parent [-]

Do you consider horses (any horse) to be highly educated? The earlier comment already recognized that the lowly educated are unlikely to find their way.

▲est31 7 hours ago | parent [-]

The horses aren't highly educated but they are very strong. The tractor replaced muscles, not brains. Now it's the brains that are being replaced.

▲9rx 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Brains were never all that valuable, though. Most of us were writing software at five years of age. It is no great feat. Almost none of us were writing software professionally at five years of age, however, because adults don't want to build relationships with children. Relationships are where the value has always been.

It is true that the poorly educated don't understand how to build meaningful relationships. They are destined to become the modern horse. But the highly educated aren't sought after for their brains. They are sought after because they're fun to be around and can share compelling conversation over a beer at the bar. There may be an AGI future where it too can build relationships, but AI is not that.

▲rpcope1 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

On the highly educated workforce thing, I think that's at least a little overstated if you think about the median front end or enterprise developer (maybe underrepresented on here), and also kind of confused being "educated" with being able to adapt and change quickly, which again from what I've seen, there's a lot of software engineers not only have literally no idea what happens in adjacent roles like sysadmin nor skill, but also seem to lack a lot of broader inclination or general skills (hard to become an electrician if you don't know what a DMM is or have never changed a lightbulb; hard to become an actuary if you never made it past trig).

I would also ask, even for those who can adapt, what exactly comes next? It's not remotely clear where and what could absorb the legions of "tech people". It's kind of like the people that jerk off self driving trucks, when you realize how many people are employed as truckdrivers (hint: in many states it's the most common profession) and ask "where the fuck is this horde of people supposed to go?"

▲themgt a day ago | parent | prev [-]

If it is true then "we" are well poised to leave software behind to jump on the next big opportunity, but I suspect it isn't actually true.

Much like discretion is the better part of valor, if your plan in 1916 is doing a gallant feathered cap cavalry charge at the machine gun nests, don't worry too much about whether high command will promote you up the ranks later.