Remix.run Logo
▲ worik a day ago

I loved Firefox OS.

I had the phone.

It was great.

▲GuB-42 a day ago | parent [-]

It is not that Firefox OS was bad. It is that it was a commercial failure that diverted resources from the Firefox browser.

From my experience, Firefox was pretty bad compared to Chrome at that time, and the mobile app was even worse. It corresponds to the time I switched to Chrome, I only switched back to Firefox later, when they fixed some of their mess and Chrome enshittified.

To me, it was a strategic mistake. Firefox took advantage of the shortcomings of Internet Explorer to become significant, as switching browser is relatively easy. Trying to attack Android is a different story, you can't change your phone OS like you can switch browsers, and Google actually made good software and had a good reputation at the time, and as expected they failed. Not only that but they also seemed to have neglected their browser for too long, so they also lost the only battle they could have won.

If Signal begins making an OS, what will happen to the app? Signal is just a small company, against them are Meta, Google, Apple,... and they don't have the critical mass to hold their users for long. They can't really afford to divert their attention away from their main product. They can however partner with others (someone suggested GrapheneOS) for this.

▲godelski a day ago | parent [-]

  > you can't change your phone OS like you can switch browsers
There's a chicken and egg problem here. Sometimes you need to target power users first. Think about how the first Tesla didn't go after the everyday driver (like many other EVs). Went after people that wanted fast cars and could afford a high price. They then get established and can bring costs down to make cars that are more reasonably priced.

I think Mozilla killed it too soon. They got buyin from the nerds. They should have then used that as evidence that they could ship phones with it preinstalled. Though that's tricky because Mozilla doing anything generates lots of criticism from the community plus if they ship on a subpar phone people will conflate hardware issues with software. Us nerds are hard to please and we kinda just like complaining

▲GuB-42 a day ago | parent | next [-]

It is indeed a chicken and egg problem, for an OS to be popular, you need apps to be compatible, and for developers to target your OS, you need it to be popular.

That's why you need some way to bootstrap the system. And Mozilla, I think, didn't take it seriously enough. By comparison, Signal did. Signal originally was a pretty good SMS app that provided encryption on the side, so, use Signal for your SMS, and if the other guy has Signal too, then it is encrypted, making the switch easy. I wish they kept SMS support but that's another story. Also one of the few compromises Signal made to privacy is their system that let you know that your contacts use Signal, to create a network effect.

For Firefox OS, I always thought they should have focused on Android first. The idea would be to first make an app framework for Android, something like Electron, but based on the Gecko engine. Now, developers can start developing Firefox OS apps that run on Android, no additional development costs, and judging by how Electron is successful (much to my dismay), it could have worked. This would have served the Firefox mobile app as well.

They probably should have considered at least some compatibility with Android apps on Firefox OS. Firefox OS is Linux, like Android, and Android is open source, they probably could have done it with reasonable effort.

▲devilbunny a day ago | parent | prev [-]

It’s unfortunate that the way phones work don’t let you have a Signal the way we have Tailscale. TS is a product sold to geeks in management, and the way they sell it is to make the free tier available and not terribly restricted vs the paid. No non-geek is going to know it exists, let alone use it, but it has been an absolute godsend for me in dealing with family. “Here, let me install this on your computer, then I will be able to see into your network and fix things. Also, you can look at my large collection of Linux ISOs.”