Remix.run Logo
▲ rus20376 a day ago

To clarify with an example: currently an employer can avoid attracting qualified American applicants, and still be compliant with the laws, by only publishing an advertisement in a print newspaper. Proposed changes will require the role be advertised online and an auditable record of non-immigrant applicants kept.

My question then is how such changes would affect the process of ensuring an organization can otherwise intentionally hire someone requiring a visa. What do you think, in your professional experience?

▲z2 a day ago | parent | next [-]

Are you referring to the November 17 proposed PERM reforms? Those concern permanent labor certification rather than temporary visas, so I'm curious how you see them affecting temporary visa sponsorship. PERM concerns permanent immigration, not temporary H-1B visas. Existing PERM requirements already extend well beyond newspaper advertisements, esp. for professional positions. The new proposal would increase documentation requirements that _already_ exist, rather than introduce something new, so why would your implied intentions, even if true, hold?

▲Izikiel43 a day ago | parent [-]

Because companies won’t want to deal with the hassle of hiring just for h1b and not getting the person permanently in the gc process, and same with applicants, if getting a gc through h1b becomes much harder they won’t even apply to the visa itself, it acts as a deterrent.

▲aprilthird2021 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Sure they would, why not? There is tons of hassle and no guarantee the employee will even stay with you for GC but they've been hiring this way for decades bc that is the only option they have.

▲Izikiel43 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Getting from zero to PERM approved is around 3 (pwd/labor market is 1 year, perm is a bit over 2 now) years now at least. If the company has a layoff in between, add 2 years at least according to the new rules, and if it happens after pwd/labor market test but before term, add 3 years because those steps will need to be redone as they will be expired, which now means you have waited 1 + 2 + 1 = 4 years just to file PERM, so then another 2 years if they manage to file.

Your H1B visa won't last that long.

▲ptaffs a day ago | parent | prev [-]

>>currently an employer can avoid attracting qualified American applicants

Why would a patriotic American employer avoid qualified applicants? Should we tighten the laws for American employers and have increased government oversight of their hiring processes?

▲rus20376 a day ago | parent [-]

patriotic or not, many employers like having a knob to dial in terms of selecting exactly who they want for a role. sometimes this is a choice at the hiring manager level.

▲proberts a day ago | parent [-]

Like most attorneys, I'm not a fan of the PERM process; I don't think it protects U.S. workers and just imposes financial and other burdens on employers. So, I don't think trying to fix something that is fundamentally broken makes a lot of sense and will address concerns related to the employment of U.S. workers. There has to be something better that allows U.S. employers to sponsor the workers it needs without short-selling U.S. workers.