Remix.run Logo
▲ __MatrixMan__ a day ago

Wouldn't it be fun if they were both correct, but with wildly different structures? We could maybe use the proof difference to characterize the prover difference (AI-assisted vs not).

▲thomquaid a day ago | parent | next [-]

That is the current situation. There are big differences at key steps, though most of the plumbing is in common.

▲ignoramous a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Wouldn't it be fun if they were both correct, but with wildly different structures?

Theories in (Quantum?) Physics (Heisenberg / Feynman / Schrodinger etc) are very much like this, apparently.

▲teiferer 13 hours ago | parent [-]

Lambda calculus vs Turing machines vs μ-recursive functions also come to mind as an example. All equivalent in the end.

▲korbonits a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

this is actually something i'm trying to study

▲__MatrixMan__ a day ago | parent [-]

Structurally, like, treating the proof like a graph or something along those lines? Or socially, like this part of the proof resembles proofs given by this group of mathematicians, so we can say it has a certain heritage? Or some other way?

It's easy for me to wish for such a thing, but I have no idea what one would latch onto when granting such a wish.

▲DonHopkins 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That's one of the central questions in Stanislaw Lem's "His Master's Voice"!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/His_Master%27s_Voice_(novel)

>His Master's Voice (original Polish title: Głos Pana) is a 1960s science fiction novel written by Polish writer Stanisław Lem. It was first published in 1968 and translated into English by Michael Kandel in 1983. It is a philosophical first contact story about an effort by scientists to decode, translate, and understand an extraterrestrial transmission. It is considered to be one of the three best-known books by Lem, the other two being Solaris and The Cyberiad.

https://lem.pl/en/works/novels/his-masters-voice

>Lem's Opinion: Human beings should accept some humility. Sometimes we face phenomena the essence of which we are unable to understand. Even if we are equipped with the most modern scientific apparatus and knowledge we are incapable of resolving whether they are accidental or intentional. Newton once said that with respect to nature we are just children playing with shells on the seashore.

https://www.donhopkins.com/home/catalog/lem/Lem.html

>HIS MASTER'S VOICE. Stanislaw Lem. Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich, c1968, English translation by Michael Kandel. c1983 (hardcover -- I understand the paperback is out now).

>Faren Miller in LOCUS called this book 'more a readable meditation than a novel' and after reading the book I would have to add my qualified agreement. The book is a philosophical retrospection by one of the key members of the 'His Master's Voice' project, the mathematician Peter Hogarth. The HMV project was secretly founded by the US government to analyze and (if possible) translate a signal discovered in modulated neutrino emissions from deep space. The military hoped to extract technology which could be used for new weapons against the Russians. Hogarth and the other scientists held the military in contempt, and sought instead to interpret the message and find a way to understand the Senders. Several strange results came from the study of the signal. One result was a peculiar protoplasm-like material created by irradiating a chemical soup with the signal. This goo had the peculiar characteristic of sustaining itself not through normal biological energy cycles, but through atomic reactions. Hogarth and friends then discovered that the material had the capacity for causing remote nuclear reactions: an explosion near it released its energy at a distance. The possibility arose that detonating a hydrogen bomb in a roomful of the protoplasm in Nevada might cause Moscow to be destroyed. Hogarth and his colleagues had to decide: what should they tell the military? Besides this ethical problem, Hogarth also considers the question of whether there really were any Senders... This novel is very difficult but I found it to be rewarding.

https://dokumen.pub/his-masters-voice-mit-press-0262538458-9...

Chapter 6, p. 109:

>Out of the infinite number of possible mathematics we have chosen one; our history decided this for us with its various unique and irreversible vicissitudes.

The mathematics we practice may reflect historical selection among alternatives. This also connects to MatrixMan’s speculation about different foundations.

Preface, p. 16:

>Here I will say only that the world injected its patterns into human language at the very inception of that language; mathematics sleeps in every utterance, and can only be discovered, never invented. What constitutes its crown may not be cut free from its roots, because it arose not in the course of the three hundred or eight hundred years of civilized history, but through the millennia of linguistic evolution: at the loci of man’s encounter with his environment, from the time of tribes and rivers.

Our mathematical habits have a cultural and linguistic history. An AI trained on human material complicates any clean opposition between "human mathematics" and an alien alternative.

Chapter 9, p. 143:

>It is true that we differed in our style of thinking; I was fascinated by ergodic processes, a field that Dill made light of.

Chapter 9, p. 144:

>I do not think I ever finished any larger paper in all my younger work without imagining Dill’s eyes on the manuscript. What effort it cost me to prove that the Dill variable combinatorics was only a rough approximation of an ergodic theorem! Not before or since, I daresay, did I polish a thing so carefully; and it is even possible that the whole concept of groups later called Hogarth groups came out of that quiet, constant passion with which I plowed Dill’s axioms under.

Personal preferences, rivalry, and the desire for recognition can influence mathematical discovery.

Chapter 10, p. 153:

>This, I thought, illustrated a certain small but characteristic feature of the history of science, because neither the fortuitous bends in the road of research nor the accidental circumstances assisting at the birth of a discovery ever completely detach themselves from its final form. Indeed, it is not easy to recognize these relics, for the reason that, fossilized, they become embedded in the heart of all later theories and formulations, like a print of a coincidence which turns to stone, to an iron rule of thought.

The finished argument may preserve traces of its discovery, although recognizing those traces is difficult.

Chapter 2, p. 42:

>With an exaggeration that is necessary for the clarification of my meaning, I will say that in the course of my work (it is difficult to say exactly when this occurred) I began to suspect that the “letter from the stars” was, for us who attempted to decipher it, a kind of psychological association test, a particularly complex Rorschach test. For as a subject, believing he sees in the colored blotches angels or birds of ill omen, in reality fills in the vagueness of the thing shown with what is “on his mind,” so did we attempt, behind the veil of incomprehensible signs, to discern the presence of what lay, first and foremost, within ourselves.

Chapter 2, pp. 42–43:

>None of us knows, therefore, to what extent we were the instruments of an objective analysis, to what extent the delegates of humanity (in that we have been shaped by and are typical of our society), and to what extent, finally, each of us represented only himself, with the inspiration for his hypotheses about the contents of the “letter” being supplied by his own—possibly raving, possibly wounded—psyche in its uncontrolled regions.

Interpreters bring their own expectations, institutional assumptions, and psychological investments to unfamiliar intellectual products.