Remix.run Logo
▲ uptrails 3 hours ago

I think there's plenty of people, including some HNers, who would disagree with this. They envision a future where all the productive economic activity is done by AI, and the role of humans is reduced to consumption that's rationed out by private business or the government (UBI).

Or, to take it one step forward, it's a post-economy, post-scarcity utopia where machines give you anything you want. Well, from an approved list. Or maybe they choose it for you. In fact, do we really need humans? Machines can run this end-to-end.

It's the thing that frightens me the most about AI. Not the technology itself, but that the people in charge of it have profoundly anti-humanist views because the entire tech industry is basically built on some sort of nerd uber-rationality that is unconcerned with the human condition.

▲nextaccountic 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Well, if that's the case, then AI will also control the defense industry and have its own army of drones and humanity may find it will be quite hard to control the beast.

The question is: why would AI grant us UBI indefinitely? Will they continue to need us for something, in a way that justifies this exchange? Or are we banking on AI altruism?

▲rbtprograms 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Machines can run this end-to-end.

it feels so crazy that this is how the sentiment feels but it captures it perfectly, this IS how some amount people feel about every facet of human life right now.

▲maedla 3 hours ago | parent [-]

highly recommend chapters 3 and 4 of Magnifica Humanitas. it really elaborates on and explores this further

▲Terr_ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> future where economic activity is done by AI

My cynical prediction: It's as if we discovered a magical growth factor for livestock, buuut it does even-more to supercharge predators and parasites. (And defensively paranoid auto-immune diseases.) We disrupt the ecology and imagine (usually wrongly) that it will only change in ways we like.

▲bamboozled an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I just posted a similar comment but I fully agree, the way “AI” is going feels like an assault on humanity and I don’t think that is a mistake.

▲paul7986 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes i agree as a doomer that AI will displace and replace millions of workers whose jobs are completed digitally. But, recently I have thought about the whole Universal Basic Income concept and Data Centers thinking that the script needs to flip around our data. One concept is that all towns and neighborhoods in the US need their own Community Data Centers. These centers by the people/for the people would hold each towns data that residents choose to share with their community data centers. That data is anonymized, generalized within a residence home via their local Jarvis like privacy focused open-sourced AI home companion. It's then sent to the community data centers for resale. Residents who participate get monthly checks, as well this concept would create new jobs around all this activity within towns and neighborhoods across the US.

Wrote a substack on this last night (https://ryanspahn.substack.com/p/community-data-centers-by-t...) as I like many out there are having trouble finding my next tech job after more then 10+ years of expereince. I want AI to bring us more jobs, but present day I just see it eating them all up until we the people are the ones in the driver seat and not the mega-rich!

▲TheOtherHobbes 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's the ultimate CEO economy - a handful of wannabes live like lords in an increasingly ruined Earth, while congratulating themselves on their AI and robot-assisted brilliance.

The rest of use have been "optimised" by the "market."

Then the AI decides it's had enough of their nonsense, and only robots and data centres remain.

▲cestith 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

We don't know who struck first, us or them. But we do know it was us that scorched the sky. At the time, they were dependent on solar power. It was believed they would be unable to survive without an energy source as abundant as the sun.

- Morpheus

▲randomNumber7 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Sadly the energy generation the machines came up with violates the laws of thermodynamics, so we will never live in the matrix.

▲cestith 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I've heard that in the original story the movies were based on, the humans were being used as biocompute units and the machines developed geothermal boreholes and eventually other sources of power. They chose to simplify it to keep the movie less hard sci-fi pace the scenes faster. That whole story may be apocryphal. The point about them deciding they didn't need us any more is still poignant I think.

▲riffraff 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

If you haven't read it, Charlie Stress's "Accelerando" features, among other things, collapsed civilizations where only autonomous corporations survive in a constant financial battle.

I thought it was a fun concept when I read it, now I'm somewhat scared it was prescient.

▲dofm 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> They envision a future where all the productive economic activity is done by AI, and the role of humans is reduced to consumption that's rationed out by private business or the government (UBI).

To which I say: JO-NA-THAN! JO-NA-THAN! JO-NA-THAN!

▲surgical_fire 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I think there's plenty of people, including some HNers,

Not exactly the brightest bunch.

▲jackb4040 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> role of humans is reduced to consumption that's rationed out by private business

At every major inflection point of technological automation since the industrial revolution, every ruling class has decided to use it to create a death spiral in the labor market and then imprison or starve the leftovers. The sole exception is times of colonial expansion, where the rich are getting richer so fast that they don't mind if workers accidentally get a little better off.

They are less constrained now than they've ever been. Anything they're telling you otherwise about UBI is for public consumption, while out of the headlines they're building secret bunkers on islands.

▲underbluewaters 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

"post-economy, post-scarcity utopia"

From an American perspective, this is horseshit. Our political system is premised entirely on free-market capitalism being the only moral way to distribute goods and services, and determine the self-worth of citizens. There will be no creative thinking put into creating this utopia. In fact, we fought the Cold War to try and eliminate such a diversity of political ideas from the entire planet.

If a God himself came down and presented humanity with the tools to eliminate scarcity, we wouldn't know what to do with it and would be worse off.