Remix.run Logo
▲ A_D_E_P_T 3 hours ago

If this is real, and the results on all sides check out, the author made a HUGE mistake by not publishing a few months ago.

Other mathematicians should take heed. If you've got any ten-year-running projects, take them out of the shadows and into the light, or an Anthropic or OpenAI employee is going to solve your problem when they decide to bother with it and have enough spare compute at hand. And then you'll be scooped, with, at best, a "runner up" trophy.

I'd also add that the time is upon us where hobbyists can solve outstanding problems and prove theorems. The short-lived age of the professional mathematician may be genuinely over.

▲camdenreslink 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I don’t agree, because his work is considerably shorter and more comprehensible than the Anthropic proof. That will always have more value than some giant lean proof.

▲cmpb 3 hours ago | parent [-]

While I wholeheartedly agree that shorter and more comprehensible proofs are more valuable, I see no reason to think that LLMs won't _also_ start producing shorter, more comprehensible proofs before long

▲zfnmxt 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Alright, and I see no reason to lend any credence whatsoever to your comment. You offer no evidence or argument of any kind. Even an appeal to authority (which is objectionable anyway) doesn't work here---who is cmpb and what do they know about the progression of LLMs with regards to proofs?

These types of comments are just invasive on HN. Just broad, completely unsubstantiated claims about AI capabilities and the future. It's just ridiculous.

▲skeledrew 2 hours ago | parent [-]

A lot of "ridiculous" things have been happening, almost ~biweekly, for the past year now.

▲j2kun 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Keep your work secret and you'll get scooped. Make partial progress public and they'll ingest it into the model and scoop you anyway.

▲ahsillyme 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'd value the meticulous work. I don't think this was a mistake, for one thing how could he have known? Secondly, mathematics is a human activity, whose reward is insight. I'll value the effort and insight -- or what is the point of priority, to prove you are better than the rest? In that case it's already an apples to oranges comparison. Well, it has to be a matter of personal philosophy on whether it's a mistake or not, I guess. Side note, for the record I have no objection in principle to resolving an unsolved questions using AI, the objection is entirely in what I find valuable besides the answer.

▲alabhyajindal 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> mathematics is a human activity, whose reward is insight

If the author believed that they wouldn't have published now. They did it because one of the rewards for solving a problem is the recognition from your peers for doing so.

▲gigabyts 3 hours ago | parent [-]

insight can only come with bread on the table no?

▲petesergeant 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I suspect history will celebrate the human author

▲HDThoreaun 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I dont

▲devin 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I disagree. Why would you feed years of your work to aid an LLM in beating you if you think you’re close to the answer yourself? Furthermore, many mathematicians have referred to the AI proofs as jumbled incomprehensible messes. Humans should continue their work unabated by the threat of some slop paper that claims a solve.

▲Pragmata 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This.

Publish what you got, when you got it, or get overtaken by someone who will.

▲duplessitous 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

By publishing half a result, the mathematician guarantees an AI will have the chance to build on their work and beat them. How do you expect these people to get grants if all they do is publish half solutions that machines poach?

▲skeledrew 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Everyone stands on someone - or something - else's shoulders in some way. The way grants are awarded will just have to be updated. But even if grants totally disappear there will always be enthusiastic people working on and sharing X with the world just for the heck of it.

▲duplessitous 6 minutes ago | parent [-]

My comment really has nothing to do with building on other peoples work. This comment chain is about how human mathematicians should be publishing unfinished work to get their crumbs from the LLM companies who use their work to publish headlines and then move on without a second thought for the actual mathematics. It reeks of defeatism

> The way grants are awarded will just have to be updated

Oh, the institution that refuses to change and has its power concentrated in the oldest members just has to change. Well good thing this just requires the coordination of the federal government, the NIH, the NSA, and every major academic institution in America. That'll be easy, why didn't the stupid, young academics ever think to just change things

I get it, you are an accelerationist but you still have to actually present reasonable answers if you want other people to join you. The response of 'oh well institutions 100s of years old with no incentive to change will just change overnight to make it easy for their younger members' is, patently, stupid

▲kurtis_reed 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Because it's more credit than nothing. Also, building on others' work is not "poaching".

▲sunshowers 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The problem is the idea of getting credit for publishing the first proof, no?

▲duplessitous 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

LLMs are not humans, they don't 'think' yet we use that term to describe what they do. Using the term poach to describe what LLM companies are doing is not being done as a parallel to how that term is used by human academics

With that kind of thinking, why don't we all just give a few companies access to all our personal thoughts? That way we can all get partial credit from our favorite LLM company

This also ignores the fundamental question: how do mathematicians get funding from anyone for publishing half complete problems? They can't and it isn't enough to say academia must change. Academia doesn't change until professors die. You're decades away from this sort of change and the people who it harms the most [young academics] have no say in making the changes people are proposing

▲kurtis_reed 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> This.

This... what?

▲yewenjie 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Sorry, most mathematicians don't want to look ridiculous by posting something that doesn't hold up careful scrutiny for something as big as RH. See the ABC conjecture and Mochizuki fiasco for example.

▲A_D_E_P_T 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Circumstances have changed. I think the community will understand; everybody is in the same position, after all.

▲preommr 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> made a HUGE mistake by not publishing a few months ago

Oh no, they'll lose out on some minor press.

Their work will still stand on it's own and for the people that it matters to, they'll know of him and his work.

The broader public probably wouldn't care much anyways, and solving math problems is going to lose a lot of glamour now that llms can do it to large degree. Not to say that it isn't impressive, but there's a large segement that just wants problems solved and doesn't care if it's done by human or otherwise.

▲simplyluke 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think this is severely under-selling the role of Levant Alpöge at Anthropic in that proof. I am not a mathematician, but he is, Princeton PhD and all. His work was a lot more informed and involved than a bored engineer with an unlimited token budget typing "plz solve GRH" and letting it run.

That doesn't mean the models aren't getting very good at math, but as in every other field, an expert pilot is going to get results a novice will not. Anthropic is hiring a lot of field domain experts and giving them space + compute to chase problems they were already interested in.

Edit to add: I also suspect that if validated, Masullo will receive appropriate recognition in the community for this work, and some grace for it maybe not being as polished as hoped.

▲cobbal 2 hours ago | parent [-]

His choice to bury his work under a mountain of slop means the rest of us don't have to pretend to care about it if we don't want to. Long live the humans!

▲simplyluke an hour ago | parent | next [-]

To be fair, I'm personally more interested in the AI side of this discussion just because the math is so far out of my own depth.

But I also realize as part of that there's no universe where even with anthropic's super secret model and an unlimited budget, I'd be getting to the same result.

▲shawabawa3 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

He chose to publish as soon as he had a lean proof and before editing the written proof because he knows openAI could publish a proof any minute

He has all the time in the world to edit it down now

▲fwlr 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A few months ago, nobody except Ant/OAI employees could possibly have had valid reasons to suspect GRH would be AI-solved within a few months. Arguably, the author’s only real mistake was being human and trying to achieve something while Ant/OAI were in the process of shredding and pulping all human achievement to convert it into share holder value.

▲Ericson2314 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No it's fine. No one cares if some not-yet-comprehensive LLM thing beat a person a few fewer hours. Obviously the humans didn't cheat to finish their proof if it is totally different.

▲solyin 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well but you wouldn't want to rush it out in case there's a mistake and then you'd look like an idiot, which in math circles is tantamount to treason.

▲ComplexSystems 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Or just give them both the Fields medal. Who cares?

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]