Remix.run Logo
▲ maplet 4 hours ago

I understand that Tao does not want to promote a result which could turn out to be incorrect, but I simply cannot imagine posting about a Riemann Hypothesis result and not commenting about the significance.

▲emil-lp 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I would think that readers of his blog are already familiar with its significance.

▲cximenez 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The comments on the blog supply a measure of discussion of the significance, even if Terry is withholding comment for the moment.

▲Phelinofist 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What actually IS the significance of a proof? People on Reddit say "not much value in proof because operative assumption was it is true, so nothing changes". I know nothing about it.

▲athrowaway3z 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I would offer an alternative that I haven't heard yet.

The standard answer was that if somebody could prove it the techniques itself would require and add new insight.

However, that does not seem to be the case for now, as its currently several GB.

Instead, what I find significant, is that a lot of people were presuming Elegant math and what we got is several GB - and it might just be that.

There is an obvious tectonic shift happening but seeing RH proven like this and perhaps _not_ be reducible to something understandable by a human would be the nail in the coffin for what I believed math and logic is, and a starting shot for something new entirely.

I'm not too plugged into the academic world - so maybe they've already understood this.

3b1b had hopes that maths in the age of AI would become about explaining and simplification. However, I now have to entertain the idea if not outright accept the reality, that the biggest questions we thought to ask have answers that simply sit outside the realm of human capability to wrap our head around.

The significance for me is we lose the presumption of elegance.

Instead our human-maths are the tip of the iceberg that just so happen to be simple enough to be human comprehensible; and a sampling error on our part to think the pattern would hold.

▲mxkopy 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Even in principle I’d reject this idea. Humans already break large pieces of math up into pieces (see the complete classification of finite simple groups and basically any other large work with multiple authors), so in a sense we’ve already been in this regime where things are too big to wrap our heads around for a long time. It’s not that tectonic of a shift. If anything it’s kind of an insult because the relationship implied here is that mathematicians should spend their time trudging through 200,000 page proofs instead of collaborating with other humans, which is a complete waste unless we know the AI can output the most succinct and powerful version of the proof (which we’re pretty sure it can’t, see the other comment about another GRH manuscript - at 1000 pages it’s still long, but makes the LLM one look suspiciously like LLM slop)

▲sprinkly-dust 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I wouldn't be too sure; there was another post a couple minutes ago from the?chair? of the American Mathematical Society where they were in a rush to post a proof of the GRH that someone has been working for years and is 'only' 900 pages compared to the hundreds of thousands for the Anthropic one.

▲carefree-bob 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes, this is correct. Every working number theorist assumes it is true. So this validates those assumptions and many theorems whose hypothesis is "if RH then X" will now be shortened to "X is true"

▲euroderf 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, but sometimes it seems like almost everything "interesting" is contingent upon RH. So this proof proving valid would be like pouring concrete where there used to be a toothpick sculpture.

To be fair, the proof of the quasi-RH was reinforcing the toothpick sculpture with some epoxy.

▲igravious 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Of any proof? Of this proof?

The impact of the RH proof (assuming nothing torpedoes it) is any of the new machinery involved in the proof.

▲tonetegeatinst 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Agree, I know I don't fully grasp how big a moment this could be....but If its actually solved I know it would be massive.

That said Just because something is solved doesn't mean we don't work on making the proof simplified and easier to understand.

▲ambicapter 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Maybe he understands that a proof that no one understands is not really useful, so the significance is fairly lessened until the result is boiled down and understood.

▲nater5000 3 hours ago | parent [-]

>Maybe he understands that a proof that no one understands is not really useful

Compared to the volumes of pure math proofs which are useful?

>so the significance is fairly lessened until the result is boiled down and understood

Significant enough to make a blog post about it the same day it occurs, but not significant enough to mention the significance of it within the blog post itself lol

I imagine Tao is just being careful and conservative with what he's saying it this point. His previous posts discussing AI in mathematics probably garnered way more attention (including negative attention) than he expected, so it'd be fair if he kept his perspective a bit more neutral and muted now. But it's pretty obtuse to assume that Tao doesn't consider this to be one of the most important events in his life. You don't need a PhD in mathematics to appreciate the significance of this.

▲themgt 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The Pope is forwarding reports that the sixth seal has broken, but not elucidating the significance.