Remix.run Logo
▲ Ericson2314 3 hours ago

I know we're not gonna get a perpetual motion machine from this or whatever, but I would still like someone to build a physical demonstration.

A real world approximation, where the fluid started to be "weird", for some definition of "weird", would be the ultimate Exploratorium exhibit.

▲HarHarVeryFunny 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This result doesn't prove that reality can "blow up" - that you can get a water vortex moving at infinite speed - but rather that Navier Stokes incorrectly predicts that such impossibilities can happen.

I wonder if we have enough compute, and/or modelling accuracy, to do a molecule level fluid simulation to see what would REALLY happen as this blow-up scenario is approached? It's not necessarily going to be weird.

▲amluto an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I don’t think you need anything that complex. Long before any field reaches infinity at any point, lots of things are likely to happen:

- Cavitation or other phase transitions

- Ionization and even nuclear reactions (which is kind of just an extreme example of the above)

- Viscosity strongly deviating from the linear approximation in N-S.

- Radiative heat transfer away from the hotter regions.

On the flip side, black holes appear to exist and can be formed from fluids. So one might argue that, if you take a fluid and subject it to finite, smooth initial conditions that will turn it into a black hole, then the system really does blow up. But the blowup is described by Einstein’s equation plus some relativistic fluid model, not N-S.

Sadly (IMO), reports of bubble fusion in otherwise mostly ordinary fluids seem to be largely discredited, but I have no real doubts that sufficiently extreme conditions involving real liquids would induce actual fusion or fission. (Fission bombs are generally just imploding blobs of stuff. They might not be liquid, but they’re certainly in a regime where it’s reasonably to attribute some fluid-like properties to them. Fission bonds are conceptually similar except that so much implosion is needed that a fusion bomb is used to supply the energy.)

▲Ericson2314 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Water doing something other than Navier Stokes predicts is also weird! I would be perfectly happy with that.

This is why I wrote "for some definition of "weird'".

▲cman1444 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Probably just a lot of friction on the molecular level right? So that Classical mechanics and thermodynamics begin to more accurately describe the physics.

I'm not expert though, so someone correct me.

▲_notreallyme_ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The point was precisely to show that the set of equations, while correctly modeling fluid physics for some known solutions, could also describe impossible behaviors.

If you are familiar with the Maxwell equations, they perfectly describe all of the electromagnetic field of physics. Navier-Stokes do not have that property for the fluids, unfortunately.

▲OscarCunningham 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Maxwell's equations don't perfectly describe the electromagnetic field. We know that quantum electrodynamics is more accurate than them. In particular two photons have a tiny chance to interact, whereas Maxwell's equations are linear so waves pass right through each other.

▲evanb 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Navier Stokes is a low-energy / long-wavelength approximation (an effective field theory) of the true physical description. Like all EFTs it breaks down at small length scales where it ceases to be a valid description. For example, NS doesn't account for atoms, so it HAS to be invalid as a description of real fluids if you look in enough detail.

▲Ericson2314 44 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Think how the double-slit experiment shows that something is wrong at ~human scales. What I am hoping for is something like that for water.

▲mitthrowaway2 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

But that also means if we set up an experiment in the lab replicating the boundary conditions that produce a finite-time singularity in the equations, they'd be in for quite a show, up to the point where the atomic-scale discretion of matter becomes substantial.

(Unless the solution requires non-physical parameters, like negative viscosity or something, which would be much less interesting).

▲hnaccount_rng an hour ago | parent [-]

Why? One (relatively) easy way to have NS loose its meaning is at a transition from fluid to gas. So as soon as that transition moves to a low enough density part a solution for the problem of “speed up water to infinity” is just ending in steam. Which is.. well.. not spectacular

▲bijowo1676 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

doesn't NS describe well the subatomic particles like quark-gluon plasma ?

▲uh_uh 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As far as I understand you can't do that exactly because Navier-Stokes is not an accurate representation of how real fluids work, which is why it blows up.

▲Ericson2314 40 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's perfectly conceivable that it both doesn't blow up, and is also not accurate to reality.

People forget that just because classical things are not true, doesn't mean that are not coherent, or that some other classical universe (which might be dull without chemistry etc. but whatever) isn't still "possible".

If I understand the result correctly, it means that the Navier–Stokes equations fail on classical terms, because they don't conserve energy in all cases. This is a theoretical failure, not just an empirical one.

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲Florin_Andrei 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Navier-Stokes assumes the cow is spherical. Don't read too much into the singularities of these equations.