Remix.run Logo
▲ breakwaterlabs 3 hours ago

Reading the article, and the comments in here, is a little sad because it suggests that the thing we all want (I think)-- open, tinkerable hardware that is profession-ready and sold by a sustainable business-- is not actually possible.

The hardware problems discussed are roughly what I'd assume were the pitfalls of a thing like the framework, and the support stories roughly what I'd expect from the cut-rate support that surely is inevitable with a smaller vendor in a competitive space. I had not heard of any problems with framework until this thread but the problems don't surprise me.

I hope that's not true-- that framework's issues are not inevitable but the result of fixable business decisions.

▲chironjit 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It's not really the hardware that's a problem though. I'm a serial upgrader, and we have 2 frameworks at home. Yes, I think in general the hardware quality doesn't match apple or xiaomi. But that isn't the problem - the issue is that in a modular, repairable laptop, you shouldn't have to deal with customer service for months to get a fix or a replacement part.

▲breakwaterlabs 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Consider that Framework's competitors-- Apple, Dell, Xiaomi-- have O(N) models to support and Framework is more like O(N!).

Then consider that Framework additionally has to spend on R&D for connectors, firmware, patches, errata to make their modularity work; and that they're doing all of this with far less revenue than their competitors.

Its expected that with those constraints that something would have to give, and that customer service would be the first thing to go-- particularly when your customers will tend to be DIY types that self-solve many/most problems.

▲Dylan16807 an hour ago | parent [-]

Everyone else lets you pick different CPUs and RAM amounts and some other aspects too. If you treat the I/O modules as external then Framework has a pretty typical amount of models to support. And that's reasonable to do given how isolated those modules are.

▲thewillowcat 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think this is right. At least for now, choosing Framework is a bit like choosing Linux. It's can be a great choice for the person who understands the pros and cons of the choice they are making, and a bad choice for the person who does not.

▲flaunf221 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> tinkerable hardware

How about using desktop PC?

I don't get the fascination so many people have with laptops. Tiny displays that are also way below the eye level. Subpar keyboards. Pointing device limitations.

They are portable yes, but how many laptop users actually spend their life in business trips to make laptop a real first choice for their production tool?

▲breakwaterlabs 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> How about using desktop PC?

Desktop PCs that are tinkerable are massive, and the ones that are tiny are generally not tinkerable (they tend to use custom laptop hardware). And desktop PCs get to benefit from the early days' industry cooperation to create interop standards.

Laptops, due to their priorities (size, thermals, battery), motivate integration, which disincentivizes interop standards. Framework is swimming against the stream here and it looks like they're having to develop custom firmware and connectors to make it all work. The difficulties in the article are entirely unsurprising, given that.

> how many laptop users actually spend their life in business trips to make laptop a real first choice for their production tool?

Downsizing to a powerful-enough laptop has a lot of IRL benefits. Not everyone wants (or can accomodate) a full ATX jet engine. Macbook Airs are not popular because an entire subset of geeks forgot how to build a PC or stopped doing geek things.

▲flaunf221 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> Desktop PCs that are tinkerable are massive

They are a bigger than laptops, but they can be quite small.

> jet engine.

Don't put jet turbines in your PC and you won't have jet engine.

> Not everyone

I understand that not everyone is professional computer user. Some people are satisfied with a tablet or even just their phone. Some maybe want to browse the web for an hour a day at home maybe, sure, go get that macbook air. But if you spend multiple hours per day (maybe 8+), why you settle for less? 5-in-1 fork-knife-flashlight-toothbrush-drill is convenient in case of emergency but is not great as daily tool.

▲breakwaterlabs 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I code, use docker, use VMs, play with LLMs. An M-series apple with 32GB does everything I would need from any desktop I'd be willing to pay for, comes with me so I can continue work on a train, lets me monitor email at work....

And if I need a bigger screen, sidecar and airplay work wonderfully. A wireless trackball plunks wherever my laptop is and I have everything I need, any time.

The desktop necessitates a permanent station with keyboard, power, and monitor. This necessitates a desk, which carves out a piece of my living space for an activity that is sporadic. It creates a need to synchronize not just code but workspace state across N devices, and synchronization carries inherent cost.

In a very many ways, laptops are more efficient with life, time, space, cognitive burden, and the sacrifices don't actually matter that much because they are trivial to mitigate.

▲vfclists 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't suppose you aware that laptops get connected to external monitors, and today laptops can handle monitors of any size?

As a developer when someone complains of a problem and you need to sit sided by side to see the issue can you carry your desktop to their office to view and debug the problem?

BTW in what alternate universe desktops are error free?

▲flaunf221 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> As a developer when someone complains of a problem and you need to sit sided by side to see the issue can you carry your desktop to their office

If you're a travelling developer whose job is to drive to different locations to fix peoples issues I understand - and I mentioned that group in my first comment.

> BTW in what alternate universe desktops are error free?

They are free from being stuck with any company. Just use different parts.