Remix.run Logo
▲ auntienomen 6 hours ago

Alpoge is a smart and principled guy, and he is probably the world leader at getting LLMs to do math. But he's not an expert in these subjects. If we're going to argue from authority, let's wait for an actual authority to weigh in

▲xyzzyz 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Of course he is an expert in these subjects. He has a mathematics PhD from Princeton, with a thesis on algebraic geometry. If you cannot call someone like that an expert, you cannot really call anyone that.

▲auntienomen 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It probably looks like that to someone outside mathematics.

But a math PhD from Princeton (even in arithmetic statistics, which is what he actually studied) doesn't make you an expert in the Riemann hypothesis.

▲xyzzyz 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I have a graduate degree in mathematics, with a thesis in algebraic geometry myself. I know what I know and what are my limits. I am not an expert in Riemann hypothesis now, but if I spent a couple of months of focused study, I would be. That’s where Levent surely is right now, at the very least.

▲godelski 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You two are just talking past one another and using different, and valid, definitions of experts. Yes, Alpoge is an expert in mathematics. Though how much of an expert he is in number theory? I don't know, I'm not an expert in number theory myself, I don't know Alpoge, and I don't know where he's been focused lately.

But either way both of your arguments comes down to speculation unless you two are also experts in number theory and know Alpoge or at least what he's been working on (to a sufficient level).

▲fn-mote 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> if I spent a couple of months of focused study, I would be

It seems more likely that in a few months you would discover the depth of what you do not know about RH.

If you are a very accomplished geometer, I apologize, but from anyone else this would be very egotistical.

▲auntienomen 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I think we mean different things by expert. You appear to mean "superficially familiar with some known approaches to the problem". That's all you're going to get in months.

And, yes, I've also published papers in algebraic geometry.

▲xyzzyz 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, if by “expert” you mean one of the top 10 people in the world, then sure, but that not how regular people typically use the word.

▲datsci_est_2015 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Silly definition. I'm a "top 10 people" in the application Data Science to [niche that my company works in] because there are so few people working in this area, but I've only scratched the surface in my 3 years of working specifically in this domain.

Some things just really aren't well-understood or well-studied.

And other things are extremely well-studied and well-understood where 10 is significantly too low a limit.

▲jeremyjh 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I disagree. I don’t know that the answer is 10, but its definitely a very small fraction of math PhDs and they all know each other.

▲Vachyas 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

If only 10 people understand the problem well enough to contribute to it, then yeah, that would be a case of a problem with only a handful of experts.

I don't think regular people would have a problem with that, since the idea that some problems could be _that_ deep isn't particularly new.

▲FeepingCreature 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

His writeup says he's been angling to work on Riemann since he was a student. It does seem plausible he's an expert.

▲Tuna-Fish 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

From the writeup for the lazy:

> It was my secret in my student days that my plans were for this problem in decades, which meant then that I tried to become familiar with all tools that I could possibly recognize in the problem when it was time

▲auntienomen 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm going to wait for Sarnak to weigh in.

▲ahurmazda 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Alpöge is a grand-disciple of Sarnak.

Alpöge -> Tsimerman -> Sarnak

▲_flag 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Sarnak weighing in is completely irrelevant. There is a lean formalisation, and it either compiles or it doesn't. (And the statement of RH is well established so there is no issue there.)

▲nocturn9x 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Lean can and does have bugs. It compiling doesn't mean anything, because that doesn't tell you whether the proof actually encodes what the mathematician intended. Plus, again, there can be prover bugs.

▲_flag an hour ago | parent [-]

In principle, sure. But the likelihood of a plausible proof strategy produced by an AI agent with human assistance somehow accidentally exploiting a Lean bug is incredibly low. In any case, the fact that the Lean compiles is certainly going to be, in this setting, a more reliable assessment of the proof's correctness than the opinion of any expert, unless that opinion also comes with an identification of the bug being exploited.

▲causal 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Feels like we're reaching for arbitrary levels of expert to undermine the claim. I'm sure the world's foremost Riemann Hypothesizer will come forward at some point, but we don't need to wait for that to take the Princeton math PhD seriously.

▲Davidzheng 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There are actually no experts on the Riemann hypothesis bc before now no one knows how to do anything lol

▲bad_haircut72 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Its all relative. If you're on hackernews then conpared to you, dear reader, hes an expert.

▲dang 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

"Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." It's reliably a marker of bad comments and worse threads.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

p.s. FWIW, I know of at least one Nobel Prize winner on HN.

▲auntienomen 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The beauty of the internet is that no one knows you're a dog.

▲danlitt 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What an odd thing to say. By this logic dumb people should defer to worse experts because "compared to you, they're very smart". Dumb people need the best experts of all!

▲ 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲ 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲golemotron 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Credentials are not authority. Especially in math.

▲serioussecurity 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Math doesn't work like that sadly.

▲conradkay 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The model(s) that solved it is an expert, I guess. Maybe they can send it to OpenAI and have their internal model check.

▲HarHarVeryFunny 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Apparently he has a Lean proof, so all that needs to be verified is that the Lean formulation of the problem matches the hypothesis, which I assume he's qualified to do (and has done).

▲killerstorm 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Did you read the document? He is very much an expert. JFYI you don't need a medal to be an expert.

▲auntienomen 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

No, you need a long track record of working on the Riemann hypothesis. You need to be the person who's called to verify a possible proof of the Riemann hypothesis. I have a lot of respect for Alpoge, but he is not the person a journal would call to verify this.

▲darkwater 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Asking out of real curiosity, not trying to provoke at all: and what happens when somebody verifies it and say the result is legit? Would Alpoge become an expert on the topic or wouldn't, due to the AI assistance?

Also, if it were the most expert person on the Riemann hypothesis the one working with AI to prove it, how would the verification work? The 2nd most expert person? Or would they be trusted directly?

▲auntienomen 4 hours ago | parent [-]

It's a fun question. I don't think AI assistance transfers expertise from the agents to the user. Alpoge says much the same thing himself, noting that Claude produced 250000 pages of slop and that he doesn't trust his own summaries in places.

For the other question: We'd want multiple independent expert verifications.

▲akie 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Man, are you being deliberately obtuse? 250000 pages of proof in a formalized language is not "slop"

▲auntienomen an hour ago | parent [-]

250k pages is the "natural language proof" that Alpoge chose not to publish because it was slop.

The lean proof is 17M lines. That did get published, although good luck compiling it if you don't have access to 1/2 TB of RAM.

▲pell 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That’s a strange form of credentialism. I understand it if you wanna reject amateurs who make graphs and don’t understand what they’re saying but this is an actual mathematician and clearly he has thought about this particular problem for a long time.

▲killerstorm 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

From the document: "It was my secret in my student days that my plans were for this problem in decades, which meant then that I tried to become familiar with all tools that I could possibly recognize in the problem when it was time".

It's true that he haven't been publicly recognized as a top expert. But it's not like he's just a software dev who got lucky with prompting - he's a mathematician who specifically studied this problem.

I don't think we should delegate gatekeeping to journals - a lot of crap is published, by "experts". (Also a lot of good results don't get published - there are well-known examples.)

▲francasso 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't get it, if the proof is formalized in Lean, the only expertise you need is running lean, asking if there were any additional axioms added in the proof that shouldn't be there, and if the statement being proved is the GRH (verifying all the definitions involved match expectations).

▲LtWorf 4 hours ago | parent [-]

You need to check that there are no bugs in the lean formulation of course.

▲francasso 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If that means checking the formalized theorem states the GRH correctly yes, but you hardly need to be an expert in the RH to do that.

▲vetronauta 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The usefulness of a Lean proof is that it is possible to just look at the theorem statement and at the axiom that are used. Riemann hypothesis is quite straightforward to define and to be checked even by a undergrad. Obviously a bug in Lean kernel is still possible.

▲slashtom 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The paper is not a proof and has not been peer reviewed / published in a journal. So yes, let's wait and see.

▲killerstorm 4 hours ago | parent [-]

There's no paper. It's just a letter about the discovery.

▲auntienomen 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The lean proof is public. Although, if it's anywhere near as long as the "natural language" proof, most people probably don't have enough compute to check that it compiles.

footnote: I object to calling the langauge that Claude produces "natural". It appears to be uniformly distributed over the space of grammatical constructions.