Remix.run Logo
▲ artninja1988 6 hours ago

Is it really wise to only rely on credentiallism to verify things? Plenty of mathmaticians top of their fields believed they have proven something when the proof contained some flaw. Just look at Mochizuki

▲tptacek 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Hacker News is a water cooler conversation, not a peer review system. It is in fact quite useful in this context to short circuit a whole raft of standard dismissals!

We went through this with Alpöge over the Jacobian Conjecture and the resulting thread was pretty embarrassing.

▲moffkalast 33 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Can't even get complementary cold water around here these days smh.

▲moralestapia 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

On this water cooler conversation, I sure appreciate the comments of my fellow @artninja1988.

If anything goes, anything goes.

▲supern0va 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> If anything goes, anything goes.

This sort of black and white thinking isn't helpful. Their point in giving context about the author is to give you more data for your internal heuristic to figure out whether this result is plausible and worth discussing.

As opposed to, for example, someone with AI psychosis on Twitter posting that they've solved it.

Even if Terence Tao came down from the clouds with a beautiful human-written proof, no one would be certain that it is solved--people make mistakes. But again, it gives confidence and something fun to discuss until the math community digests it fully and comes to a consensus.

Anyway, TL;DR is that no one is telling you to go put your life savings on a prediction market bet that it's solved. Relax a little.

▲lanstin 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Math is hard; even to understand the questions and what the entities are which the questions address takes a lot of deep study, even for smart people. So credentials are not sufficient but they are for sure necessary. I have tried my whole life as a software engineer to study math as an amateur and then started a masters program and learned more details thoroughly in three months than in decades of self teaching.

▲hephaes7us 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The study is what's necessary. The guidance of a program is a helpful accelerant. A credential is merely suggestive.

▲lanstin 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Not in a Bayesian sense, not "merely" suggestive, but quite suggestive. Not sure how many full professors you have met, but they aren't like that under-performing coworker that people have to cover for.

More like IIT grads in being, Bayesianly confident, quite exceptional.

▲Davidzheng 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Why is it necessary--just check the proof

▲killerstorm 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Nobody claims it's verified. It just seems very plausible.

It really irks me that people think beliefs have to be binary rather than come in different degrees of certainty.

▲randomNumber7 2 hours ago | parent [-]

This just depends on intelligence.

▲hyperpape 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No. The mathematicians will verify this, and come to a conclusion.

What the credentialism does is establish that this should be taken seriously and has a real possibility of being right. The Lean also helps (no Lean for Mochizuki’s work).

▲ 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲questionable_ju 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

he's just pointing out that this isn't some rando claiming to have video of aliens.

▲317070 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

credentialism, and a lean codebase that compiles and certifies Riemann is correct.

▲well_ackshually 6 hours ago | parent [-]

No. A lean codebase that certifies that whatever definition of the Riemann hypothesis their LLM wrote is correct.

I can write Lean that certifies that 2 + 2 = 5 is correct, by redefining every axiom about natural numbers on the way. Or abusing bugs in Lean. Stop believing Lean is the response to everything.

▲latent-person 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Just like Navier stokes etc they use independently written Lean statements written by humans; formal conjectures [1]. Indeed, they have one for the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis too [2].

> I can write Lean that certifies that 2 + 2 = 5 is correct, by redefining every axiom about natural numbers on the way.

Which you would catch using comparator?

> Or abusing bugs in Lean.

And just like all the other ones, people check with multiple independent kernels, so you need to abuse bug(s) in all of them.

> Stop believing Lean is the response to everything.

Stop believing Lean is so flawed.

[1]: https://google-deepmind.github.io/formal-conjectures/

[2]: https://google-deepmind.github.io/formal-conjectures/theorem...

▲math_dandy 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The statement of the Riemann hypothesis is included in the Mathlib library which is a human written and highly regarded foundation for formalization. See https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/master... for the two-line statement.

For a discussion of how to check that the untrusted proof isn't playing fast-and-loose with the axioms of mathematics or exploiting kernel bugs, see Kevin Buzzard's recent post "...and the proof is checked in Lean" at https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-i....

▲astrange 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It imports a standard definition of RiemannHypothesis. It could be wrong in other ways, but not that one.

▲quchen 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The axioms would be a given to the theorem prover of course, as is the norm for theorem proving. This then reduces a complex proof to checking whether the theorem is stated correctly and the proof kernel is correct. This may not be (provably) easier, but it is so far removed from yet equivalent to the original problem that you get a machine-verifiable independent audit as a result.

And don't reduce "is not the answer to everything" to "is the answer to nothig", there is tremendous value in automated verification, especially in the AI age where the moat to it going mainstream is shrinking by the day.

▲stale2002 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> whatever definition of the Riemann hypothesis

Do you... think that there might be existing definitions for one of the most famous math problems of all time and that maybe they used that?

Or do you think that they just vibe coded up a different definition, for kicks?

This kinda feels.... easily provable either way.

▲steinwinde 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>whatever definition of the Riemann hypothesis their LLM wrote

Given that the proof is provided by Levent Alpöge, who is known to be more than familiar with Lean, is it not unlikely he made up his own definition of the problem?

https://leanprover-community.github.io/mathlib4_docs/Mathlib...

▲RunSet 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I understand the proofs generated by the slop engines are beyond mortal kenning, such that they must be backstopped by appeals to authority.

▲EGreg 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I heard Fermat himself had a marvellous proof, but it was too small to fit into the margins. A pity!

▲abnry 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I have a marvelous lean proof but my hard drive is too small to contain it.

▲dgellow 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

No it’s not. HN main approach to analyzing anything is to rely on chaining heuristics. Which is generally sort of fine for software, but doesn’t make sense in the real world. It’s at best one signal to weight in your analysis, nothing else

▲wat10000 5 hours ago | parent [-]

It's the only realistic way to operate for nearly everything. Try determining whether a sandwich is safe to eat without applying a shitload of heuristics.

▲swatcoder 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The difference is that you generally need to eat something and so drawing some conclusion about th sandwich is essentially forced upon you.

Getting buzzed over headlines about math or medicine or whatever, on the other hand, is just an irrelevant hobby of bored gentry and the opportinity to just not draw a conclusion at all remains open.

▲TeMPOraL 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Tell that to the general population wrt. politics. The "opportunity to just not draw a conclusion" has a much greater payoff there.

▲wat10000 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Do you just not contemplate anything that isn't directly related to your physical needs? What a sad existence. I wonder what you're doing here, in that case.

▲mtlmtlmtlmtl 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Easy. Eat the sandwich, see what happens. No heuristics necessary.