Remix.run Logo
▲ Frost1x 2 hours ago

I don’t think this is true because it makes an assumption that reductionism is always possible, you can always distill every increasingly complexity into something less and less complex and maintain the overall behavior. I don’t think complexity is always reducible because sometimes the detailed nuance is absolutely critical to the distinction.

You may be able to take core ideas from something and distill them but when you have multiple interacting core ideas you may not necessarily be able to reduce them to simple terms. And almost always when you do there’s a big asterisk that the analogy has a lot of flaws.

▲vasanthv 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This is exactly what the article says. If you find it hard to explain in simple terms then you do not understand it enough.

▲croes an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Doesn’t mean it’s true

▲rocqua an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

So Feynman didn't understand magnets enough?

▲QuadmasterXLII 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It may be that sone things can’t be explained in simple terms, but perhaps they are just not understandable?

▲streetfighter64 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I think it's not really about making simple analogies, because they don't really "explain" anything in the proper sense of the word. An analogy might make somebody feel like they understand it, but it doesn't really give actual understanding (see pop sci explanations of quantum mechanics).

It's more about breaking down stuff into simpler parts. For example, you want to explain a buffer overflow exploit in a web server. Then you'll ask your audience, do you understand addressing / memory allocation, and do you understand HTTP? If they say no to any of those, then you'll have to explain e.g. memory allocation first. And if they don't know how a CPU / RAM / caches operates, then you'll have to explain that first. And maybe you'll have to explain boolean algebra and how to build an adder from logic gates. And so on.

So I would claim that "reductionism is always possible". More complex things just take longer to distill into less complex things, but it can always be done. The exception would be things that "nobody really understands", like Feynman says about magnetism:

> I really can’t do a good job, any job, of explaining magnetic force in terms of something else you’re more familiar with, because I don’t understand it in terms of anything else you’re more familiar with.

▲Frost1x 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Well I would push back on that claim because I don’t feel like you’re reducing things. You’re filling in gaps in understanding of something they already understand across the entire conceptual landscape it’s just masked by prior knowledge, they already know other concepts in detail and using a strategy to break a larger problem into smaller parts to make it digestible over time, you’re still dealing with the full set of complexity.

I think reductionism absolutely is possible in a lot of cases but I tend to agree with Stephen Wolfram’s concept of “computational irreducibility” or concepts we essentially know from compression in information theory (like Shannon entropy, Kolmogorov complexity) that there are limits to just how much you can reduce an idea or concept, and the bound for the human mind is likely much higher than those lower limit concepts.

Magnetic force is pointed out because it’s a more unique experience people don’t have a lot of prior knowledge and experience baked in that you can leverage as an assumption to reduce the concept, I think this holds true with lots of things. That isn’t to say we shouldn’t try to explain things simpler, just that that big caveat asterisk becomes ever more important when we use reductionist explanations. It’s not unlike when people try to explain spacetime curvature with a ball on a rubber sheet and things rotating around it… sure, that kind of gets at the idea, but there’s a huge asterisk that it’s simply not what’s really going on, it hints at the concept of curvature on a 2D plane you need to somehow conceptually extrapolate to other dimensions.