Remix.run Logo
▲ NalNezumi 2 hours ago

I share your sentiment, but a recent episode made me doubt this position, and maybe you (or other HN readers) can enlighten me.

I don't want to out source thinking and therefore I'm very cautious with my AI use. This attitude caused a little quarrel with my partner, so I shared it with one of my close friend.

My close friend vehemently disagreed with me, he says AI is amazing and he have basically outsourced almost every thinking he does to it. Then he told me how it helped him:

One day he got a message about how his girlfriend was having a rough day at work. Late diagnosed ADHD as he is, he never really knew how to respond to this, so he just asked ChatGPT to write a reply to it (in his own tone). Later the day his girlfriend comes home, hugs and thank him that that compassionate message made her rough day feel much better. My friend doesn't tell her he used AI ofc, but internally thinks "wow is it this easy? Is all I needed to do, listen to the girl and validate her feelings?!" hes 35 btw.

He tells me that without AI he would've never realized this, and from his life decisions so far it's also clear that he never really had the patience to learn anything that is not of immediate interest to him. (and gf feeling seems to not have been)

I'm torn because I have to acknowledge that in the world the majority probably think like him; reading several books and listening to interviews and podcasts for 100+ hours about spousal communications after communication failure (like I did) is an outlier.

And this behavior is probably order of magnitude better than what he did before: getting relationship advice from Joe Rogan.

Edit: to clarify where I'm torn is not about my usebut the utility of it for cases like above. AI will probably (unless enshittification) HELP many people like my friend above, and probably prevent them from falling in conspiracy / online grifter scams because they now just prompt AI like "chat is this true?" and they're good at refuting bullshit. Essentially, we might have an antidote to Brandolini's law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law for the common man. I'm reserved because that's at the mercy of AI companies not enshittifying, and skill deterioration, and I have very little trust in that

▲larme 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I think this story can go 2 ways:

- Your friend get the positive feedback and begins to learn how to understand others better and give proper support to his family/friends (maybe with the help of AI)

- Or your friend begins to use AI to reply everything and becomes a hollow person

▲Planktonne 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

It sounds like he was already hollow, and AI is just letting him hide that better.

▲kouteiheika 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> One day he got a message about how his girlfriend was having a rough day at work. [..] he just asked ChatGPT to write a reply to it (in his own tone). [..] Later the day his girlfriend comes home, hugs and thank him that that compassionate message made her rough day feel much better. My friend doesn't tell her he used AI ofc

To me this reads like something taken straight out of a South Park episode: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Learning_(South_Park)

▲NalNezumi 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Maybe I should send it to him(or watch it with my partner)

▲delis-thumbs-7e 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> hes 35 btw

And he will be 36 and single. Maybe 40, difficult to say. Y’know, men have pretended to listen women and fake validate their emotions, those dumb things only girls (yuck) have, probably since the times immemorial, and women have noticed this at some point and left.

Btw, I have ADHD, read constantly and listen podcasts most of my waking hours. Your friend’s behaviour has nothing to do with ADHD, more with sociopathy or other antisocial disorder. Perhaps you should find better people to hang out with. At which point will he start answering all of your messages with chatgpt? Or maybe he does already?

▲NalNezumi 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Maybe I should clarify that I don't blame all his behavior on ADHD and I wasn't trying to insinuate that but that combined with other traits, it is a contributing factor to "not bothering to learn anything that is not of interest to him(or deep enough)".

Because we don't message much, he doesn't use chatGPT on me that much.

Except one occasion when we first talked about if "catching up on sleep" was possible or not, and then later he sent me links to two academic papers claiming you can't. Now this is a guy that barely got through high school, so I knew since forever he never read those and 100% sure it's just something LLM linked to him that he just copy pasted.

Since I've done research in my life before, I criticized the papers based on the methodology and sample size (really bad papers), noting that the evidence if anything could also be interpreted in the opposite hypothesis. Noting that he might be right, but those two papers don't prove that.

I guess another point is also that he now have a "good sounding AI" that works well for romantic communication but for the above kind of issue will just throw you citation that he himself do not fully understand. But, then again, vast majority don't either. And no real damage was caused by him linking it (but also no lesson was learned)

▲Planktonne a minute ago | parent [-]

> Maybe I should clarify that I don't blame all his behavior on ADHD and I wasn't trying to insinuate that but that combined with other traits, it is a contributing factor to "not bothering to learn anything that is not of interest to him(or deep enough)".

His partner should be of interest to him.

▲lenkite an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> At which point will he start answering all of your messages with chatgpt? Or maybe he does already?

Aren't your friends already doing this ?

▲delis-thumbs-7e an hour ago | parent [-]

Mine? Absolutely not. What's the point? I can talk to a LLM myself if I want to.